logo

51 pages 1 hour read

Lisa Taddeo

Three Women

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Electronic Communication

Texts and phone calls—and their absence—elicit desire, stress, and heartbreak. Aidan’s communication characterizes him as uncaring in the face of Lina’s overwhelming devotion. When Aidan texts Lina “what u into,” Lina knows this to mean: “I will fuck you right now if you can get near to where I am within the allotted time” (226). The brevity of his messages and their implicit demand that Lina should immediately make herself available to him highlights Aidan’s self-centeredness. Aidan also makes frequent demands of Lina to send him “hot pics,” and Lina obliges, buying new clothes and lingerie with him in mind. While electronic communication serves as a means of contact between the two, it is weaponized by Aidan to control and manipulate Lina. It brings pleasant sexual distraction for Aidan, but heartbreak and frustration for Lina.

Similarly, Knodel uses electronic communication to control and manipulate Maggie. Knodel explores the idea of an illicit relationship with Maggie via text. Knodel messages Maggie, “I’m a teacher and you’re a student, and we shouldn’t be talking like this” (75). Tellingly, he does not stop messaging her. Knodel carefully controls his and Maggie’s electronic communications in a way which typifies their relationship dynamic. He always messages her first, and Maggie must program his wife’s number into her phone, so she knows to avoid answering it. At one point, Maggie starts to lose interest. Knodel, sensing this, messages her to say, “I think I’m falling in love with you” (113). This text “resuscitates her dwindling obsession” (113). Maggie, smitten and excited, agrees to come to his house later that week, and they have a sexual encounter. Later, the prosecution refers to the astounding amount of time the two spent on the phone: “Incoming calls, from Aaron to Maggie, forty-six at 752 minutes. Outgoing calls, from Maggie to Aaron, forty-seven at 1,405 minutes” (205). Unbelievably, the defense manages to represent this time merely as a concerned teacher checking on a troubled student.

For Sloane, her communications with Richard during sexual exploration are a vital part of their open relationship. It can also be a source of pain and stress. Sloane often films her encounters on her phone to send to Richard or watch with him later. It is also a requirement of Richard that he and Sloane stay in touch via messages or phone calls throughout her sexual explorations. During one encounter, Sloane’s phone dies. Richard is upset and angry, “I can’t have you not in touch with me…that was terrible” (215). Later, Sloane’s flirtatious messages to Wes are found by Jenny, his wife, and this brings an end to Richard, Sloane, and Wes’s relationship. As with the other women, messaging enables sexual and romantic connections to flourish, but can also bring expectations, exposure, and immense stress.

Illicit Affairs

All three women are involved in illicit affairs, which brings excitement and intrigue, but also stress with the constant risk of exposure. The fact that Lina can only occasionally see Aidan for clandestine sexual encounters in cars and hotels fuels her obsession and desire. Even when they have a plan to see each other, Lina is filled with a “crazy, anxious Will I see him or won’t I” inner monologue (172). On her way to meet with him, Lina hopes that he won’t suddenly feel spooked or guilty for continuing to cheat on his wife. She prays: “God, please don’t let him cancel” (173). When Aidan spends a whole day and night with Lina in a hotel, Lina feels “sated” and “cared for” (182). For the first time in her life, she feels like a completely “happy” and “loved” woman (182). Aidan becomes evasive again after this encounter, but Lina continues to pursue the sense of joy and fulfillment she experienced. In this way, Aidan’s pattern of withdrawal and reengagement in their affair fuels Lina’s obsession.

Maggie feels “holy-shit disbelief” that her 30-year-old teacher seems to be interested in her (75). Maggie thinks over the banter and smiles they share in his class, and senses that “something has been growing” (76). Over Christmas break, Knodel asks “if she’s seeing someone,” and then later asks if she received a New Year’s kiss (76). Maggie is intrigued; the messages feel illicit and exciting. The illegal nature of their relationship means that Knodel is constantly on edge. Exposure is always a risk. In Knodel’s classroom, when Knodel’s hand is down Maggie’s pants and the doorknob wiggles, Knodel “jumps back like he’s been burned” (120). When they have a sexual encounter at his house, Knodel tells Maggie, “had you called me Mr. Knodel [rather than Aaron] I probably would have stopped everything right there” (118). Maggie is kept in thrall with Knodel by the stress and excitement of their illicit relationship.

Sloane has mixed feelings about her and Richard’s arrangement of involving third and fourth parties in their sex life, but she likes the idea of being “naughty and different” (213). As with Maggie, subversive sex which breaks conventional rules is perceived as exciting and enthralling. While Sloane and Richard’s involvement with Wes was consensual, Wes hid the relationship from his wife, Jenny. This illicit relationship was discovered by Jenny, and Sloane was chastised by Jenny and condemned by her community. As was the case with Maggie, Sloane suffers more from the consequences of the illicit relationships than the respective men (who orchestrated these affairs). Through the responses of Maggie and Sloane’s community, united in condemnation, Taddeo draws attention to sexist double standards. Women are persecuted for being sexually transgressive, whereas men are excused and even celebrated. 

Female Beauty and Thinness

All three women obsess over their relative attractiveness, and they are each preoccupied with their weight. Their thinness is tied to whether they feel they deserve to be respected, heard, and desired. Sloane was raised in a family where image was everything. As a young child, her mother tells her: “I think you’ll be more comfortable if you lost some weight,” and she is prescribed weight loss pills (131). As a teenager, she developed bulimia trying to an idealized “skinny party girl” image (136). As an adult, she still ties her value to her physical appearance. She goes to the gym “a lot” and eats “little” (209). She obsessively does “micro thigh presses” while on the phone or making dinner (210). Her skinniness and beauty still define her, and any sign of aging makes her feel panicked and insecure.

Going into the trial, Maggie is acutely aware of the thirty pounds she has gained since her affair with Knodel. She wonders whether Knodel will still find her attractive. The defense calls witnesses to the stand who Maggie feels are intentionally chosen for their appearance; Maggie notes that they are beautiful and thin and feels that the implication is: “look at us, we are pretty and cool, and he didn’t go after us” (205). Taddeo implies that Maggie’s appearance is weaponized against her. Her weight gain, her medication, her sexual history, and her family’s relative poverty are all used to characterize her as broken and unreliable. Taddeo contrasts this with the way the beautiful women are depicted as inherently more trustworthy.

As a teenager, Lina “feels okay about her stomach” when she “skips dinner” (24). This illustrates that Lina only feels entitled to feel “okay” about herself when she is thin (24). It is telling that Lina’s frustration in her unhappy marriage to Ed becomes more acute when she loses weight. In her new, thinner body, she feels the “cool weight of untouch” (149). There is the implication that Lina feels more deserving of desirous love and sexual attraction when she is thin. Her husband’s refusal to touch or kiss her was more tolerable when she was thirty-six pounds heavier.

Lina, Sloane, and Maggie all feel, or are told, that they are more deserving of love, respect, and attention when they conform to societal standards which dictate that women should be thin and attractive.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text