logo

54 pages 1 hour read

Charlie Donlea

Those Empty Eyes

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “The Return”

Part 3, Interlude 10 Summary: “Camp Montague; Appalachian Mountains”

An unnamed young girl attends summer camp with her older brother. She enjoys the first few weeks. One night, however, an adult camp counselor named Mr. Lolland takes her to his private cabin, telling her, “Tonight is our little secret” (118).

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary: “Manhattan, New York; Sunday, January 15, 2023; 8:45 p.m.”

Tracy Carr, the journalist who first broke the story of the Quinlan murders, has seen her career blossom in 10 years since then. In addition to a career writing for the Times, she maintains a true crime hobby in which she continues to investigate cases like the Quinlan murders. Tracy uploads a video for her many followers in that casts doubt on the verdict of Alex Quinlan’s innocence and asks her followers to help her find Alex.

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Friday, February 3, 2023; 11:48 p.m.”

Alex Quinlan, now living as Alex Armstrong, has a job as an investigator for Garrett’s firm. She works closely with Buck Jordan, one of Garrett’s partners at the firm. Together, they’re gathering information about a new client, Byron Zell.

Part 3, Chapter 21 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Friday, February 3, 2023; 11:56 p.m.”

Zell approached the firm for a wrongful termination suit, and Buck and Garrett, wanting to do their due diligence to determine their client’s innocence, are using Alex to gather information on Zell. As Buck watches from a car outside, Alex breaks into Zell’s apartment. She accesses his financial records on his laptop and emails the records to Garrett, using Zell’s account. Buck warns Alex that Zell just entered the building, and Alex narrowly escapes without him seeing her.

Part 3, Chapter 22 Summary: “Manhattan, New York; Friday, March 3, 2023; 9:20 a.m.”

Laura McAllister, a student at McCormack University who runs a small but popular gossip-channel-turned-reporting-outlet, arrives at NBC, where famed news anchor Dante Campbell interviews her. Dante praises her for her work spearheading programs to help improve safety for female students on college campuses.

Part 3, Chapter 23 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Saturday, March 4, 2023; 11:58 p.m.”

An unnamed female college student, debilitated by a date rape drug at a frat party, is raped by a frat boy. The next morning, she goes to the hospital and reports the crime.

Part 3, Chapter 24 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Monday, March 6, 2023; 9:10 a.m.”

Larry Chadwick, the presumptive nominee to fill a recent vacancy in the Supreme Court, meets with Annette Packard, an FBI agent tasked with vetting him and digging up any potential blemishes in his history that would affect his nomination. Larry is convinced that his life is superficially perfect and that Annette will have to work very hard to uncover any “dirt.”

Part 3, Chapter 25 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Monday, March 6, 2023; 8:36 p.m.”

Alex, now 10 years removed from her family’s massacre, has uncovered new evidence thanks to Leo’s leveraging of Drew Estes. She discovered that the bank statements in her parents’ closet belonged to Roland Glazer, a businessman convicted of trafficking teen girls who died by suicide in jail before his trial could start. Glazer is now the focal point of Alex’s investigation.

Part 3, Chapter 26 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Monday, March 6, 2023; 8:36 p.m.”

Garrett makes a surprise visit to Alex’s apartment. He asks her if the files sent from Zell’s computer could be traced back to the firm in any way; Alex assures him that she covered her tracks. Garrett tells her that while the files showed no fiscal wrongdoing, they contained child pornography, so Garrett reported Zell and the files to the police.

Part 3, Chapter 27 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Monday, April 10, 2023; 7:48 p.m.”

Annette Packard’s assistant informs her of a major issue that arose during the investigation of Larry Chadwick.

Part 3, Chapter 28 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Thursday, April 13, 2023; 10:32 p.m.”

Laura McAllister considers the investigation she spent the past month working on: a deep dive into allegations of rape at McCormack that the university’s administration systematically covered up. As she’s thinking about the ramifications of releasing her work, she receives a call from Duncan Chadwick and realizes that her story must have leaked.

Part 3, Chapter 29 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Friday, April 14, 2023; 6:45 p.m.”

Annette arrives at Larry Chadwick’s residence. She reflects on how her team uncovered Larry’s covering up his son Duncan’s DUI. However, the new revelation that her team discovered will be much worse for Larry.

Part 3, Chapter 30 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Friday, April 14, 2023; 7:00 p.m.”

Annette informs Larry and his wife that Laura McAllister is about to release a report on the rape cover-up at McCormack. The report connects the rape to the frat that Duncan pledged to. Annette informs Larry that to get ahead of this, he, his wife, and Duncan must release a statement before the report is published.

Part 3, Chapter 31 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Monday, April 17, 2023; 12:20 p.m.”

The Chadwick family delivers remarks at McCormack, strongly denouncing sexual violence. Larry dodges questions about whether the brewing scandal will affect his nomination.

Part 3, Chapter 32 Summary: “Washington, D.C.; Friday, April 21, 2023; 11:35 p.m.”

Even though her story was leaked, Laura decides that she must publish her report. Rather than publishing it using the University’s media platform, however, she decides to use her own media accounts. Laura pockets the USB drive with her report and leaves campus to head to her apartment; this walk is “the last time anyone would see Laura McAllister alive” (175).

Part 3 Analysis

Structurally, this section differs radically from the previous one: While the second section is narrated largely from Alex’s perspective, this section oscillates chapter-to-chapter, often introducing new characters’ perspectives every few pages while also revisiting characters introduced in earlier sections. Tracy Carr’s depiction, which reveals how she uses her fame to keep her followers engaged in continuing to question Alex’s innocence in her family’s murders, again highlights The American Obsession with True Crime as a theme. One of the most mysterious and significant new perspectives is the unnamed third-person narrator of the Interludes throughout this section. The novel doesn’t reveal this character’s identity beyond being female. Only in the novel’s final section does it reveal that this “she” is Jacqueline. The choice not to name this character in this section creates tension by provoking questions about this character’s identity and purpose in the story, such as whether “she” is a character whom the novel has already introduced and why it’s important to keep her identity anonymous. Introducing The Effects of Sexual Violence as a theme, this element of the novel centers on the silencing effects of sexual abuse. The refusal to name this character in the Interludes is another representation of the erasure and silencing that Jacqueline experiences because of Lolland’s violence.

Rather than slowing the pace in this section, the novel uses oscillating perspectives from chapter to chapter, creating tension. The introduction of new characters—Laura, Larry, Annette, Byron—raises questions about how they all connect and, more importantly, how they connect to Alex’s plotline. The novel’s resistance to immediately answering these questions demands that readers seek these answers themselves, thereby creating more tension as it introduces new perspectives. The text doesn’t withhold the answers to these questions for too long, though. In the final chapters of this section, these characters begin to cross each other’s paths: Duncan Chadwick calls Laura, and Annette becomes aware of Laura’s potential involvement with the Chadwicks.

Although Alex is less present in this section of the novel, it continues to build her character. She has now found a way to cope with the trauma of her history: changing her identity entirely. Alex has discovered that by “neatly organizing her life into three categories” (148)—an anonymous self, an old self, and a true self—she can compartmentalize her trauma. This “categorized” life introduces the idea that identity is something that can be constructed. For Alex, the construction of identities that can mask her “true” self is necessary simply to move through the world without being recognized. Throughout the next sections of the novel, however, other characters use the masking function of identity construction for more sinister purposes: Garrett and Jacqueline have constructed identities as lawyers to mask their work as vigilantes; Duncan Chadwick uses his father’s privilege and his own identity as an upstanding student to mask his identity as a rapist; and Alex will find new ways of hiding both her identity and her ambitions in order to survive.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text