48 pages • 1 hour read
Johann Wolfgang von GoetheA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The letters that begin Book 2 recount Werther’s employment with the ambassador and his impressions of his new milieu. The October 20 letter contains resolutions to work diligently and to avoid as much as possible making comparisons with other people. By November, he can report that his life is “tolerable,” owing largely to a friendship with Count C. Werther describes him as possessing intellectual depth while also being capable of warm affection. He values the Count’s kindness. However, this connection to the Count also causes friction as an assistant to the ambassador. By Christmas Eve, Werther is openly frustrated with the ambassador’s pedantic nature. In turn, he accuses the ambassador of being overly critical of Count C. because the Count prefers Werther’s company to that of his employer. He blames Wilhelm for placing him in such an artificial position of “glittering misery” and expresses disdain for the societal emphasis on distinctions of rank. Nevertheless, he also reports his growing closeness to one Miss von B., an aristocratic and reasonably “natural” young woman. In a short letter a week into the new year, Werther criticizes those who dedicate their lives to social advancement and challenges the notion that one’s place in society determines true greatness.
Werther addresses his January 20 letter to Lotte from a country inn. He describes his detachment and dissatisfaction with his current life. He also describes his connection to Miss von B., who reminds him of Lotte, with her “great soul” and disdain for her high rank, but he also admits to Lotte that they often speak of her instead. Werther ends the letter by asking about Albert, with a somewhat probing question about Albert’s significance to Lotte, but adds an apology for the inquiry.
Werther considers the bad weather during the week of February 8 to be a blessing because he is spared unwanted social interactions. He reflects that people spoil things, including health, fame, and happiness, despite having good intentions. He expresses frustration at their self-destructive tendencies. On February 17, he describes the deterioration of his working relationship with the ambassador. He finds the ambassador’s way of conducting business ridiculous and often has to contradict him, leading to arguments. The minister recently reprimanded him due to the ambassador’s complaints. Despite contemplating resignation, he decides against it after receiving a letter acknowledging his sense of duty and perseverance in business. The letter seeks to soothe Werther and encourages moderation rather than the destruction of his passionate drive. As a result, Werther finds contentment but wishes that such states were less transient.
Werther addresses the letter of February 20 to Albert and, more indirectly, to Lotte, congratulating them on their marriage. He confesses that he had been waiting to hear about the wedding date so that he could mark it by taking Lotte’s silhouette from the wall, but is grateful not to know about it until after it happened. Lotte’s picture remains on Werther’s wall. He affirms that he must hold at least second place in Lotte’s heart.
Werther’s employment and social situations continue to deteriorate during the spring, culminating in his resignation from his post and departure. On March 15, Werther recounts a distressing incident that occurred at the Count’s house. He had dined with the Count on a day when the “nobility” usually came to the Count’s home later in the evening. The arrival of Lady von S. with her husband and daughter reminds Werther of everything he hates about the aristocracy, but before he can take leave of the gathering, Miss von B. enters the room. He talks to her, but she seems uncomfortable during their conversation. The situation becomes more awkward, and Werther slowly realizes that many of the guests are whispering about him. The Count politely asks Werther to leave, and he complies, though not without suffering from the insult.
The next day, he falls further into despair. He encounters Miss von B., who says she suffered during the gathering and scolds him for tarnishing her reputation among other members of the nobility. She warns him that there will be further repercussions for his “arrogance” from those who want to put him in his place. An isolated and agitated Werther contemplates murder and self-harm. On March 24, he announces his resignation to Wilhelm and asks him to tell his mother. Despite potential career advancements in the position, he emphasizes his inability to help himself, let alone others. He reveals that a prince has taken a liking to him and has invited him to stay at his hunting lodge for the season. Werther sees this as an opportunity to be his own master and agrees to go. Werther avoids replying to Wilhelm again until April 19, worried that his mother might intervene to prevent his resignation. On May 5, he leaves the town and intends to revisit his birthplace.
Werther becomes increasingly restless in May and June and repeatedly refers to himself as a “pilgrim” and a “wanderer.” The May 9 letter relates his visit to his hometown. He describes the changes in the village, expressing disappointment in new additions and alterations. Werther feels a deep connection to the old schoolroom, now converted into a shop, and contemplates the stream and the farm. He questions the importance of rote knowledge compared to his intimate connection with nature on his own land. Two weeks later, writing from the prince’s hunting lodge, Werther reveals that he had planned to enter the military, but has now officially abandoned the plan because of the prince’s objections. By June 11, Werther is restless and dissatisfied. The prince is well-meaning but does not provide Werther with the intellectual or artistic stimulation he desires. The brief letters of June 16 and 18 reaffirm Werther’s status as a “wanderer” and suggest that, despite a stated intention to visit some mines, Werther is really planning to return to Wahlheim.
Werther’s return to Wahlheim reactivates his mental distress. More than a month elapses before he writes to Wilhelm, and the letter itself (July 29) is disconnected and frantic. He claims that Lotte would have been happier with him and that Albert cannot possibly satisfy her. Still, he admits that Albert loves her entirely. His despair deepens when, on August 4, he reports to Wilhelm that the younger son of the family he met in May of the previous year has died, and the husband has returned from Switzerland without the hoped-for inheritance. Although he can’t provide a solution, Werther offers a small gift before leaving. As he revisits familiar places, he writes on August 21, he likens his feelings to that of a departed prince witnessing the decline of his palace. He experiences fleeting moments of happiness, often disrupted by darker thoughts. The one-sentence letter of September 3 reveals that Werther does not fully grasp the fact that Lotte loves Albert more than him. On September 4, Werther recounts his meeting with the farmer lad who had been in love with his employer, but who at present is unemployed and shunned by the community. The young man confesses to Werther that his repressed feelings led to the sexual assault. The widow’s brother, who had always been suspicious of the farmer lad, expelled him from the house and made it impossible for him to continue the affair. Werther continues to sympathize with his commitment to his love, even as he makes the effort to write an unusually calm letter.
Much of this section focuses on the theme of The Struggle for Authenticity in an Artificial Society. Werther’s employment at court forces him from a position of class superiority to one of inferiority, and he is forced to comply with social norms and power dynamics that he does not take to well. His impulsive nature leads to frequent conflicts with the ambassador, whom he refers to as “the most punctilious oaf imaginable […] a man whom it is impossible to satisfy because he is never satisfied with himself” (74). The two are at constant odds, often due to Werther’s impulsivity. He admits this when he writes that he “cannot help contradicting him, and often I deal with something in my own way and in accordance with my own judgment” (79). Werther’s attitude reflects his lack of understanding regarding society’s expectations of his behavior and the ramifications he should face if he breaks away from them. He resents being controlled. He also rails against being patronized. In doing so, he fails to recognize how he has taken a similarly superior view toward the lower-class individuals he talked about earlier in the novel. However, he revels in certain aspects of being in a higher-class company. He boasts of how an unnamed prince admires him and his friendship with Count C. Of note regarding the relationship between Werther and the Count’s companionship is that it allows the former to temporarily divert his focus from his romantic longing for Lotte.
Werther also meets a young aristocratic woman named Miss von B., with whom he begins a tentative courtship. He elevates her above her peers because “Her rank is a burden and satisfies none of the wishes of her heart. She is longing to put all this brouhaha behind her, and we spend many an hour imagining country scenes of unadulterated bliss” (78). In his eyes, Miss von B. is better than the other aristocrats because she takes a poor view of her class in favor of a romanticized ideal of rural life. He possesses a similar view of the Count. However, in his overly idealized view of their respective relationships, Werther fails to recognize the limitations imposed by their respective positions within the social hierarchy. His lack of self-awareness leads to his humiliation after he inadvertently intrudes on a party at the Count’s home; Werther cannot conform to social conventions even when he tries. Neither the Count nor Miss von B. supports Werther, and he, in turn, begins to believe they are just like the others.
The theme of The Destructiveness of Unrequited Love underlies Werther’s time in court. His friendship with Miss von B. should indicate that he is moving past his prior obsession. However, the opposite is true. Werther writes to Lotte about Miss von B. and says that she “resembles you, my dear Lotte, if it is possible to resemble you” (78). His insistence that the two women are similar is contradicted by what he actually writes about them. This includes their personalities and physical descriptions, as Lotte has dark eyes while Miss von B. has blue. This seems to be yet another instance of Werther’s projections of his fantasies onto others. He is still infatuated with Lotte, so he must turn Miss von B. into a copy of his idea of her.
Werther’s downward spiral is clear in his response to the news of Albert and Lotte’s marriage, and the fallout from his mental health crisis marks the beginning of the end of his work with the ambassador; his unrequited love poisons even those relationships that are not personal. As with most of his other troubles throughout the story, the issues Werther faces here result from his ego and emotional instability that, to him, are signs of his authenticity and artistic sensibility. True to what he told Wilhelm in his first letters, he is unwilling to rein himself in. Yet, despite Werther’s commitment to sincerity, his letters hint that he is not entirely honest, even with himself, about his intentions to return to Wahlheim. When he does do so anyway, the village itself reflects his sense of discontent. It is far darker and less romantic than it was before he left. The family who once represented the joys of simple, rural life has suffered death and disappointment, and the farmer lad’s vaunted admiration for the widow has taken a decidedly unsavory turn that disrupts Werther’s recounting of the tale. Though he would never force himself physically on Lotte, the parallels between himself and the farmer lad are unsettling.
By Johann Wolfgang von Goethe