42 pages • 1 hour read
James L. SwansonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In The President Has Been Shot!, James Swanson focuses extensively on the Cold War. The origins of the Cold War start with World War II. The war had severely weakened Japan and the powers of Europe, loosening or outright destroying their grip on their colonial empires. Meanwhile, the United States emerged relatively unscathed, with an economy bolstered by the war effort. Although the Soviet Union had been badly devastated and lost tens of millions of lives during the war, it soon recovered and also became a major military and economic power.
During World War II, the United States and the Soviet Union had been allies. After the war, tensions grew between them. They were the post-war world’s two superpowers, something historians and political scientists call the “bipolar” world. However, they also had very different economic and political systems. The United States followed capitalism and democratic principles of government; the Soviet Union practiced Communism and had an authoritarian, strongly centralized government. It was not just a rivalry between governments, but between different ideologies.
Since both superpowers had nuclear weapons, they avoided direct military confrontation. Instead, they fought each other via proxy wars, meaning wars where other countries went to war with their backing, or fostered regime changes in other countries to create allies and eliminate rivals. For Americans, the most famous example of such a proxy war is the Vietnam War. There, the Communist government of North Vietnam fought the United States-backed government of South Vietnam.
At the same time, the United States also became more socially and culturally conservative than it had been around the 1920s and early 1930s. Part of this was because of a fear of Communism. In The President Has Been Shot!, Swanson thus examines The Impact of the Cold War on Kennedy’s administration and his assassination.
The assassination of President John F. Kennedy is one of the most debated and analyzed events in United States history. The Zapruder film, which is the most complete film capturing the assassination itself, has been viewed countless times and extensively analyzed by both conspiracy theorists and their debunkers.
As Swanson notes, the Kennedy assassination is sometimes regarded as signaling a bleaker turn in the United States. With important exceptions like the ongoing discrimination experienced by African-Americans, generally the 1950s were a period of confidence and optimism in the U.S. government and its democratic ideals. However, the assassination of a young, popular president inspired conspiracy theories that he had been killed by right-wing politicians, the FBI, and/or the CIA. Events of the following years—the assassinations of Malcolm X, Bobby Kennedy, and Martin Luther King Jr.; the increasingly unpopular Vietnam War; and the Watergate scandal involving President Richard Nixon—fed into these conspiracy theories and a growing attitude among the public that the government could not be trusted.
As a result, conspiracy theories about the assassination were referenced heavily in pop culture, including the 1975 novel The Illuminatus! Trilogy, the 1990s comic book Shade the Changing Man, and the 1990s TV series The X-Files, among many others. Perhaps the most famous is the 1991 film JFK, directed by Oliver Stone. Stone claims the film was meant to be fictitious, but it did take inspiration from two non-fiction books proposing conspiracy theories about the assassination. Historians criticized the film for giving credence to conspiracy theories, with some theories persisting to this day. Swanson argues for The Unlikelihood of Conspiracy Theories in The President Has Been Shot!.
The President Has Been Shot! has been generally well-received. It was especially praised for how successfully it addresses its YA audience, taking a complex topic and crafting a narrative packed with facts that can be easily read by teens. By including so many facts about the assassination itself, James Swanson has been praised for combating conspiracy theories about John F. Kennedy’s assassination. The book was nominated for a YALSA-ALA Excellence in Young Adult Nonfiction award. Critics have also praised the book for its brisk narrative pacing and its use of maps and images.
Not all of the reception for The President Has Been Shot! has been positive. Some have criticized how Swanson does not discuss Kennedy’s life in more detail. Aside from civil rights actions and cutting taxes, Swanson does not mention the Kennedy administration’s other domestic policies, such as raising the federal minimum wage for most employees of the federal government or some expansions of the welfare state. Nor does Swanson mention certain unsavory details about Kennedy’s personal life, such as that he had extramarital affairs. One review accuses Swanson of failing to be “neutral,” of engaging in “mythmaking”, and writing a book that is “almost hagiographic,” meaning it almost portrays Kennedy as a saint (“‘The President Has Been Shot!’: The Assassination of John F. Kennedy.” Kirkus Reviews, 24 Sept. 2013).
By James L. Swanson