logo

72 pages 2 hours read

Garrett M. Graff

The Only Plane in the Sky: An Oral History of 9/11

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 61-EpilogueChapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 61 Summary: “In the Oval Office: ‘We Go Forward to Defend Freedom’”

President Bush delivered an address to the nation, acknowledging citizens’ heartbreak and anger and assuring the American people that the government was in operation and that the terrorists responsible for the attacks would be found and held accountable. Vice President Dick Cheney was flown to a safe bunker that evening.

Chapter 62 Summary: “The Evening of 9/11: ‘I Spent the Evening Just Crying’”

People whose families were involved in the tragedy reeled from their losses. In other cases, people tried to track down news of family and friends from colleagues; confusion and misinformation ensued. People checked hospital lists in person or by phone, hoping for good news.

FDNY workers returned to firehouses, only to find that whole companies were missing, presumed dead. Others made their way home through quiet streets, covered in dust, to reunite with ecstatic and relieved family members.

Boats that had been shuttling people from Manhattan island began the reverse journey, delivering relief supplies and rescuers.

Emergency workers scoured the site for survivors; this was an overwhelming job in the acres of destruction. The PAPD’s William Jimeno heard voices and called to them. The FDNY’s Scott Strauss, the NYPD’s Paddy McGee, and civilian ex-paramedic Chuck Sereika lowered themselves into the hole in the rubble and worked to free Jimeno, which took three hours. He was badly crushed and in immense pain. Sergeant McLoughlin was quiet for a time as Jimeno was freed, and the team of emergency workers didn’t realize that he was there. They eventually freed both men, who were sent to the hospital with significant injuries.

It was an exciting and encouraging moment for emergency workers who, aside from Jimeno and McLoughlin, had found body parts only. Jimeno was distressed to reach the hospital and see dozens of doctors and nurses standing around; he asked where the other survivors were.

Chapter 63 Summary: “The Day Ends: ‘I Wondered, ‘Did They Get Out?’”

The FBI established a command center in an automotive garage. The hijackers were identified. At all the crash sites, fires burned throughout the night. At the WTC site, dump trucks began to arrive to start clearing the wreckage away. Floodlights illuminated the acres of debris as emergency workers continued to look for survivors. Across the country, people mourned, felt fearful, and had sleepless nights.

Epilogue Summary:

“Wednesday”

The Pentagon workers who were not injured or killed on 9/11 returned to their offices the next morning, determined to contribute to the nation’s war effort. The fire at the Pentagon was finally extinguished at 2:30 pm on September 12.

Lyzbeth Glick, the wife of deceased Flight 93 passenger Jeremy Glick, made a resolution to live a full and happy life for their daughter. Vaughn Allex, a ticket agent at Dulles International Airport in Washington, DC, was overcome when he realized that he checked the hijackers onto their flight, as well as everyone who died because of them, including children and families.

A Middle Eastern restaurant put up a sign condemning the attack. Americans of Arabic descent felt scared and ostracized.

Emergency workers returned to the WTC location where they found Jay Jonas and Lieutenant Mickey Kross, looking for more survivors. The FDNY’s Paul Somin calls out and hears a response. He finds the hand of Genelle Guzman and holds it. It took 45 minutes to extricate her from the rubble. She was the last survivor recovered.

Herb Ouida and his wife frantically searched hospitals. John Napolitano (a former firefighter) joined the search at the WTC ruins, known as “the pile,” but his son was never found. “Missing” posters plastered the city of New York. Joe Asher recalls preparing thousands of death certificates so that family members of the deceased could access estates.

Staff at the Capitol were terrified when an evacuation alert sounds; people were on edge about another attack. The investigation into Flight 93 in Pennsylvania continued.

“Thursday”

Air traffic resumed, with careful bomb checks of planes. Monika Bravo found her rendering of the September 10 storm, which now felt premonitory.

“Friday”

President Bush spoke to rescue workers at the pile. Some families continued to desperately search for loved ones. A candlelit vigil took place in New York.

“Saturday”

Lisa Jefferson, who spoke to Todd Beamer, received permission from the FBI to pass his final message on to his wife, Lisa Beamer. Trinity Church’s yard, which contained the remains of illustrious Americans like Alexander Hamilton, was cleared.

“Sunday”

The mayor encouraged New Yorkers to support their city by shopping locally and resuming their lives as best as possible. President Bush declared that the stock markets would reopen the following day.

“The Following Weeks”

On September 24, Mayor Giuliani announced that there was no hope for finding additional survivors at the WTC site. Firefighters, police officers, rescue workers, other first responders, and skilled tradesmen continued the recovery operation, searching through the pile. They used rakes and shovels but at times used small shovels and hand picks to extricate body fragments. The work was emotionally taxing and physically grueling. Conditions improved somewhat when The Red Cross installed a tent with cots and St. Paul’s Church opened to supply the searchers with food. The center of the pile remained intensely hot from the fires still burning.

New Yorkers begin attending funerals and wakes. Some firefighters attended numerous funerals per day for weeks.

At the Pentagon, urban search-and-rescue teams entered to shore up the building so that the FBI could enter. Debris piles removed from the building had to be separated into body parts, personal items, classified information, and airplane parts; it was a labor intensive process. At the Flight 93 crash site, excavators found the cockpit voice recorder, however the cockpit had disintegrated at the moment of impact.

The US launched war on Afghanistan. The survivors and victims’ family members and friends began to try to return to a new routine.

A Victim Compensation Fund was established. First responders rang the bell to open the stock exchange every day for the rest of 2001. Survivors, including Pasquale Buzzelli, struggled with survivors’ guilt.

“Years”

The events of 9/11 altered the course of countless lives and began two wars.

Many first responders experienced PTSD. Others developed physical ailments resulting from the day’s events, especially in New York, where the dust clouds from the WTC collapse later manifested in respiratory illnesses and cancer in first responders and civilians on the scene.

Ticket checker Vaughn Allex struggled with feelings of personal responsibility for checking in and hurrying the hijackers toward their flight, which they almost missed.

In 2011, Ladder 6 firefighters attended the funeral of Josephine Harris, whom the survivors from Stairwell B credit with their survival.

Osama bin Laden was discovered and arrested by a US military SEAL team in 2011. He was killed, and his body was buried at sea. US President Barack Obama addressed the nation, referring to the 9/11 attacks: “We can say to those families who have lost loved ones to al-Qaeda’s terror: Justice has been done” (811).

Chapter 61-Epilogue Analysis

These chapters explore the theme of Resilience and Heroism in the Face of Adversity through the country’s response to the terror attacks in the subsequent days, weeks, and years. Pentagon employee Lieutenant Colonel Ted Anderson recalls his pride at the turnout on September 12: “Ten thousand people showed up to work at the Pentagon that morning. It made me extremely proud” (747). Senator Tom Daschle notes the immense resilience of the US on September 12; he believes that this day showcased “the best and the worst of our country” (764). He continued, “The best part was how resilient our country can be in the tragedies of this magnitude. The worst had to do with the vulnerability and loss of so many lives and the knowledge that there was agony and so much pain” (764). Similar resilience was demonstrated by the devastated families who lost loved ones in the attack, such as Lyzbeth Glick, whose husband, Jeremy, was on Flight 93:

The morning after Jeremy had died, I remember looking down at our daughter, Emerson—she was sleeping—and just crying because she would never know her father. I thought she would only know a sad mom. We had trouble having her—took us two and a half years—and then to have everything taken away. We had dreams for our family. Then something just kind of clicked in my head, and I said, ‘You know, I have a choice. I’m not going to ruin her life. I’m not going to ruin my own life’ (749).

In this moment, Lyzbeth decided to resiliently choose to find joy in her and her daughter’s life despite the horrific fact of Jeremey’s death. Lyzbeth’s resilience mirrors that of thousands of Americans, who adjusted to a new future after losing beloved family members and friends.

In addition, this final section explores how life changed irrevocably after the 9/11 attacks, particularly in terms of security. Mary Beth Cahill, a Capitol employee, recalls, “When I first came to Washington, you could walk up to the Capitol, to every monument. You could walk in to talk to your representative, without having your bag searched” (765). Reflecting on the security present at airports and important national sites after the terrorist hijackings, Cahill feels that pre-9/11 “was a different world” (765).

Life also changed irrevocably for Arabic Americans. As explored in previous chapters, discrimination and attacks increased for this population. A Middle Eastern restaurant displayed a sign “saying how sorry they were about the terrorist attack and that they didn’t support it” (751), illustrating their anxiety about retaliation and boycotting. Similarly, Gabriella Daya-Dominguez, whose father is Arabic, recalls “feeling a sense of dread that week. I couldn’t eat at all. Food tasted like paper. It was hard to put something in my mouth. I felt that there was going to be a backlash against Arabs. I remember being terrified” (751).

The distress of survivors, first responders, and victims’ families and friends illustrates the theme of The Psychological and Emotional Impact of Terrorism. Survivor Matt Claus’s two-and-a-half-year-old daughter picked up on her parents’ obvious distress: “From the chaos that was in our house, my daughter started to stutter. She started having nightmares. She said Daddy works in buildings that fall down” (782). The girl’s manifested stress exemplifies how the psychological stress resulting from the attacks affected entire households; her parents were acting differently, and the world felt unsafe and terrifying to her. Likewise, Buzzelli, who survived despite incredible odds, struggled with PTSD and survivor’s guilt:

I remember not being able to sleep at night, getting nightmares. You would fight this battle inside of you and you say: ‘Hey, asshole, you’re alive, you should be happy.’ Then you are happy for a second and you say to yourself: ‘Hey, asshole, you’re happy and someone else is dead—you’re happy you’re alive, what does that say about you?’ (794-95).

Buzzelli had difficulty reconciling his own survival in light of the deaths of so many others, which complicated his recovery from the mental and physical stress he experienced. This alludes the theme of The Tragic Randomness of Decisions in Dictating Life or Death. Lieutenant Joseph Torrillo read the list of firefighters killed on 9/11 and was shocked to see his friend’s name, Timmy Stackpole: “I was with him when the building came down, but he went to the left, I went to the right. Timmy is gone” (758).

The tragic symbolism of the relatively empty hospitals continues to echo through these chapters, as evident in Jimeno’s emotional recognition of the consequences of this fact:

As we got to the hospital, I’m thinking there’s going to be thousands of people in there. That’s the second time I cried. As they pulled me off the ambulance, I see these doctors standing around and nurses. I said, ‘Where is everybody?’ They’re like, ‘You’re it’ (735).

The relatively empty hospitals allude to the immense loss of life; for the most part, people either walked (or ran) out of the WTC towers to safety or died in the fires or collapses. Jimeno, who was pulled from the rubble badly hurt but alive, represents tragically rare cases.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text