logo

101 pages 3 hours read

Marion Zimmer Bradley

The Mists of Avalon

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 1982

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Fate and Destiny

Fate and destiny are the grounding principles of Avalon. All members of the Holy Isle learn from a young age that they ought to follow their destinies, which often intersect with other overarching forces like gender or religion. Igraine’s journey to understand and accept her fate does not and cannot exist without her struggles with her gender role. When she tells the Merlin that she “feels trapped” by her destiny with Uther, she is also expressing dissatisfaction with the options available to her as a woman: Regardless of what she does, she will still be subjugated as a woman and a wife. In The Mists of Avalon, fate thus underscores socio-political problems that various characters grapple with.

Many characters, especially those with heritage in Avalon, regard fate as more important than any moral principles or personal relationships. Viviane acknowledges this in the aftermath of Morgaine’s experience at Beltane. Morgaine is crying, traumatized by the incestuous situation Viviane placed her in. All Viviane has to offer at this is, “And at this moment, the hope of Britain is more important than your feelings” (191). Viviane’s callous response demonstrates that fate is the supreme principle in Avalon, even at the expense of others. Viviane and Morgaine are never able to rekindle their previous closeness because Viviane chooses fate over her foster daughter. Her calculated planning also implies that some characters in the book regard fate as uncertain or would at least like to see it come faster. For example, if Arthur’s reign was fated, then Viviane should not have needed to meddle as much as she did.

When fate is invoked as a justification, it invites the reader to scrutinize a character's actions more closely for hypocrisy or other dishonesty. After Morgaine has Kevin killed, she reflects:

‘I must believe that I had no power to do other than I have done’
must believe that I never had a choice…a choice to refuse the king-making, a choice to destroy Mordred unborn, a choice to refuse when Arthur gave me to Uriens, a choice to hold back my hand from the death of Avalloch, a choice to keep Accolon at my side…a choice to spare Kevin Harper a traitor’s death, and Nimue… (810).

At this point in the story, Morgaine has wronged several people she loved while pursuing her goals. However, this is the closest she comes to taking any responsibility, admitting to herself that if she allowed herself to question whether she was acting for a higher power, she would have no choice but to think about the gravity of her actions. She also uses fate as a coping mechanism for the horrors she endured throughout her life.

The Constraints of Traditional Gender Roles

As a text that puts its female characters front and center, The Mists of Avalon places a heavy focus on gender roles in Arthurian society. Many characters find the expectations of their gender confining and struggle to shoulder this burden. Igraine exemplifies this in her struggle to accept her fate. When she consults Taliesin, who encourages her to pursue Uther on the grounds that she is unhappy with Gorlois, Igraine cries, “I feel trapped” (53). Taliesin tells her that she always has a choice, but Igraine knows that is not the case. Gorlois rapes and beats her almost daily and in the height of his rage confines her to the house. Given the dire nature of her circumstances, “choosing” Uther is not really a choice at all. Igraine later faces the same trap after Uther’s death. Igraine’s power as High Queen came from her proximity to Uther; without this connection, she retires to a convent. where she lives her life in accordance with the patriarchal Christian God. The entirety of Igraine’s journey throughout The Mists of Avalon reflects the burden of her gender.

Gwenhwyfar’s journey elaborates on the struggles of Christian womanhood. Though she enjoyed her childhood in a convent, it caused her to internalize a misogynistic way of thinking: She learned that Original Sin meant that all women live in sin regardless of their conduct in life. The Christian way of looking at her gender compounds the sorrows she later feels at her miscarriages, when her first instinct is to assume she was doing something wrong. When she consults a priest, he confirms this, saying, “You must not be so quick to assign blame to others […] If there is fault, it must be your own” (391). This marks a turning point for Gwenhwyfar’s religious fanaticism. Christianity seems to offer her the opportunity to identify sins and repent for them, but its teachings on women force Gwenhwyfar to place the blame on herself and her inherent shortcomings. For Gwenhwyfar, Christian womanhood is therefore a trap that serves to further alienate her from her friends and loved ones; the more she clings to Christianity and pressures Arthur to do the same, the less she acts like a submissive Christian woman, contributing to a vicious cycle of guilt and recrimination.

Male characters like Kevin are also burdened by the expectations of their gender. Kevin’s disabilities make him unable to participate in traditional male activities, such as war. They are also immediately visible and mark him as different. This has left Kevin with a warped sense of his own masculinity, telling Morgaine that he fears she “thought this crooked body of [his] was not a man’s, and did not think of [him] so” (417). This anxiety haunts all his romantic endeavors and ultimately leads to his downfall. When Morgaine seeks to punish him for bringing the Holy Regalia to Camelot, she uses this weakness to her benefit. He craves love after constant rejection and therefore seizes on Nimue’s apparent desire for him, even as he carries his gender insecurities to the very end—as he leads Nimue into the forest, he says “I am glad it is dark…that my misshapen body will not terrify you” (797). All of these cases demonstrate that Zimmer Bradley portrays the expectations of gender as oppressive, showing several characters who are trapped (metaphorically and literally) by these ideals.

The Cycles of Life

The Mists of Avalon portrays time and history as cyclical. Avalon is rooted in its rich customs and tradition, many of which involve cycling through different stages of life. The Goddess, Avalon’s primary deity, has three faces that correspond to each stage of a woman’s life: Maiden, Mother, and Crone. For instance, when Viviane goes to visit her dying friend Priscilla, she thinks, “I have brought life and now I come as the Death-crone…Mother, I do for her only what I would that one might do for me one day” (341). Viviane recalls when they had their babies together and is shocked that they have grown old so fast. In confronting death in someone dear to her, she must reckon with her own. Acknowledging these cycles is often what prompts many characters to act. Once Viviane faces the reality of her age, she reflects on her lost relationship with Morgaine and hopes to make her the Lady one day, thus ensuring that her cycle will continue.

Cycles also inform the very structure of the book. The Mists of Avalon spans multiple generations, and they all face similar struggles. For Igraine, Morgaine, and Mordred, struggles with fate and identity seem to be genetic. Igraine harbors resentment toward Viviane and Taliesin for thinking that they can control her. Despite this, she is still caught up in their plan to have her marry Uther. Though Igraine is not unhappy with him, she realizes that fate “had not brought them together for her own joy” (107), and that this will be a marriage bound by their duty to the land. Morgaine’s journey centers around a similar cycle of events. Viviane tells her that she needs to remain a virgin until she receives a signal from the Goddess. Though she wants to lose her virginity to Lancelet, Morgaine stops herself, holding on to the idea that the Goddess has a plan for her and inadvertently sleeping with her own brother. This leaves her unmoored—she is unable to figure out her relationship with Avalon until it is too late, and she can never have successful, long-term romantic relationships. Her son Gwydion must also deal with the expectations of others from the moment of his birth. All of Avalon thinks he will be their savior, and all of Camelot thinks he could be a great knight and a great king. Gwydion is torn between these two identities, and his final descent into corruption can be read as a way of desperately attempting to reconcile his two identities. At the end of his life, he melds patriarchal Christianity with polytheistic Avalon, creating an ideology that reads as incoherent and disastrous.

The novel also depicts these cyclical events in similar styles. The best example of this is the parallel between Morgaine’s ritual with Arthur and Morgaine’s ritual with Accolon. Zimmer Bradley describes Arthur’s frenzied running with the deer in punctuated phrases: “[H]e swayed and struggled, wrestling the deer with his strong hands and young body…a knife slashed upward; blood spilled on the earth, and he was bleeding too, the Horned One, blood on his hands” (176). The beginning of her ritual with Accolon has a similar rhythm:

[A]nd suddenly it was as if a horn rang out, far and eerie, through the hazel grove…or was it the hazel grove? And then the leaves lifted and stirred, and there was the rushing of sudden winds, making the branches creak and sway (677).

In describing both rituals in succinct phrases, Zimmer Bradley establishes both as moments of frenzied ecstasy. Their similarity is apparent despite them occurring years apart from each other.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text