logo

67 pages 2 hours read

Rick Riordan

The Mark Of Athena

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2012

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 41-44Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 41 Summary: “Piper”

Jason and Piper have a picnic in a nearby park. Piper’s cornucopia provides their meal, including a birthday cake and candles. Jason admits it is his sixteenth birthday (the first of July, Hera’s sacred day, which the Romans would find auspicious). Jason admits to feeling like a failure and being disappointed in Hercules. Without Piper, Jason says, he would not have been able to stand up to the hero. Percy comes running toward them.

He has a bad feeling about Annabeth, and with time running out for Nico, Leo, Frank, and Hazel have still not returned. Percy suggests that Piper use Katoptris to find a clue to Nico’s location. She sees a vision of the Romans preparing their invasion of Camp Half-Blood. The next vision is of the Forum and the circular room from her nightmare, then one of Nico, who is now out of pomegranate seeds. Percy says they cannot wait for Hazel, Frank, and Leo to return. Whatever is waiting for them, they must face it to save Nico. Leaving Coach behind, the three demigods head to the forum.

Chapter 42 Summary: “Piper”

Piper, Jason, and Percy quickly find the circular stairwell they are looking for, and Piper reveals that Katoptris showed the three of them drowning in a cylindrical room. Puzzled, Percy reminds her that he cannot drown and offers to investigate first. When he returns, he assures Jason and Piper that the room is holding no water but also has no exits. The three descend together. When he steps into the middle of the room, green and blue lights appear on the walls, accompanied by the sound of a fountain and the smell of the ocean. Jason notes that the room is a nymphaeum, “a shrine to the nymphs” (355).

The room feels “hostile,” not what Piper associates with the flirty, gossipy nymphs at Camp Half-Blood (356). Jason shares that that ancient Romans had them outside their villas to ensure fresh water, and demigods would invite nymphs to live in their nymphaeum, for good luck. Percy reminds him that this would bind the nymph to the water source. Piper wonders what would happen to nymphs bound to an underground nymphaeum. The sound of water transforms to hissing, the lights turn purple and lime, and “nine desiccated zombie nymphs” appear to answer her question: They would suffer and wait for revenge (357).

The nine nymphs reveal that they were present at the birth of Zeus and promised honors back “in the old country, in Greece” (358). A son of Jupiter invited them a new home in Rome, but when the city fell, the nymphs’ master did not release them. They have been trapped for centuries without water, and now their minds are warped with hatred. Piper and Percy offer to help them, but they reveal they are working for the giant twins who promised that if the nymphs deal with the demigods, they will be freed from their suffering. The chamber begins filling with “sickly dark water, like oil” (359).

Chapter 43 Summary: “Piper”

As black water pours into the chamber, Piper recalls Achelous reminding her of a Cherokee flood story that her father used to tell her. In the story, a family’s dog gives them the key to surviving a flood: build a raft and sacrifice the dog. When the father grabs him to throw into the water, he is revealed to be a skeleton. The family survives the flood. Piper wonders why Achelous reminded her of the story, feeling that she is already dead.

Chapter 44 Summary: “Piper”

The room fills quickly, and the demigods cannot find a way out. Percy dives underground to try to locate a drain and barely makes it back to the surface. Poisoned by the nymphs’ malice, the water is abnormal; Percy cannot breathe in it. The nymphs are draining the demigods’ power. As the water reaches their chins, Piper remembers the skeleton dog’s sacrifice and how her cornucopia works. Her plan is to channel Jason and Percy’s power through the cornucopia to flood the chamber with clean, fresh water. She urges them to work together, offering their power as a gift to the nymphs.

Clean water blasts out of the cornucopia, quickly filling the room to the ceiling. Just before the demigods go under, Piper tells Jason she loves him. Just as Piper wonders if the room will crack, the water begins draining. Piper breaks the surface and pulls up Percy and Jason, saving them. The nine nymphs are now young and beautiful. Eight vanish, leaving one behind, who explains that the demigods have released the nymphs, who will now go in search of new homes. Both the stairs and a sewer pipe appear; the demigods can choose to return to the surface or descend further to find the giants.

Chapters 41-44 Analysis

Jason opens up to Piper, giving her insight into her importance to him and his effectiveness as a demigod. His crediting her with helping him stand up to Hercules reinforces the idea that heroic qualities come in many different forms. Piper has not always appreciated being or wanted to be a daughter of Aphrodite, as suggested when she saw her mother in Charleston, but Aphrodite’s power is about more than just beauty and romance. With the cornucopia, Piper taps into her mother’s generative power and channels it to create positive outcomes. She will use this power to advantage in the battle against the giant twins at the end of the book, and it is the key that enables her, Jason, and Percy to survive the nymphaeum.

The Greek demigods do not recognize the room and need Jason to interpret it, reinforcing the message that Romans and Greeks must work together. The difference between Greek and Roman mindsets is exemplified by demigods’ reactions to the room. Jason recalls that, for Romans, attracting a nymph to one’s nymphaeum is good luck, but Percy and Piper are concerned about the consequences of binding nature spirits to an underground water source that has been removed from nature. The nymphs’ response may speak to the consequences of the Roman penchant for conquest and control that can lead the conquered into rage and a desire for vengeance. This is seen not only in the nymphs but also Athena when Annabeth recalled her meeting with her mother. Athena is a goddess of strategic thinking, yet she is impaired by her own rage when Annabeth sees her.

Drawing on the generative power of the cornucopia and her Cherokee grandfather’s story, Piper understands what it means to make a true sacrifice, the kind Nemesis referred to in her conversation with Leo. Piper must be willing to give everything to save the nymphs, without regard for herself. Collaboration must take precedence over resentment. Piper channels only positive, creative forces and orders Jason and Percy to do the same. By saving the nymphs, they save themselves, but only because they stopped caring about saving themselves.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text