logo

44 pages 1 hour read

Lisa See

The Island of Sea Women

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 17-19Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Fear (1947–1949)” - Part 4: “Blame (1961)

Chapter 17 Summary: “Day Four: 2008”

Young-sook and many of her elderly friends attend a ceremony for the official opening of the Jeju April 3 Peace Park. It is meant to commemorate the year-long anti-insurgent purge that began on that date in 1947 and to honor those who died during that time. In the intervening years, the government has tried to cover up the atrocities that occurred, but a public acknowledgment of these crimes is finally taking place.

At the park, the assembled crowd hears grand speeches about rising above the past and looking toward the future. Young-sook thinks, “But it wasn’t time for her. Even now, she’s too accustomed to her anger and sorrow to change” (261). After the speeches, the visitors inspect a memorial engraving where Young-sook finds the names of her husband, son, and sister-in-law. She makes a charcoal rubbing of their names and realizes that she’s being observed by the tourist family. Afterward, Clara comes up to her and says, “My mom asked me to follow you. She wants me to make sure you’re all right” (264).

Chapter 18 Summary: “Years of Secrecy (February 1961)”

In February, it’s time for the shaman to perform an annual ritual, asking for the blessing of the goddess on both the fishermen and the haenyeo of Jeju. Since shamanism has been outlawed, this is a risky undertaking, but everything goes off without any interference from the authorities.

Shortly after this, a group of men appears in Hado. Some are Korean, others Japanese, and some are Caucasian. They are led by a Korean man named Dr. Park. He announces that they are scientists looking to study the haenyeo. Apparently, the divers have the highest resistance to hypothermia of any group of humans on the planet, and he is looking for volunteers for this study.

Young-sook’s twelve-year-old daughter, Joon-lee, talks her family into volunteering. The girl attends school and is the brightest in her class. She is fascinated by the scientists and acts as an intermediary between them and the divers. The scientists are impressed by Young-sook’s cold tolerance and conduct tests for two weeks before moving on.

Young-sook worries about her children because their father was a teacher, and the government might be watching them as potential dissidents, which is known as the guilt-by-association list. She confides to Do-saeng, “‘What future can I give my children when we have the guilt-by-association system?’ ‘Those we lost were not guilty of anything.’ ‘That’s not how the government sees it. Anyone who died is considered guilty’” (280-81).

 

For some unaccountable reason, the government decides to send textbooks to the schoolchildren on Jeju. All the girls receive Heidi. It doesn’t take long for all the islanders to become addicted to the story. Joon-lee announces that someday she’s going to Switzerland.

Chapter 19 Summary: “The Vast Unknowable Sea (August–September 1961)”

Three months later, Dr. Park and his team of scientists return to study the haenyeo in Hado again. They measure the calorie intake a haenyeo consumes to maintain her body temperature. Young-sook invites the doctor to her house for dinner to see the typical diet. That evening, Joon-lee’s teacher, Dr. Oh, arrives to say that the girl has been chosen to compete in an academic contest in Jeju City. Joon-lee is thrilled and goes out for the evening with her friends. Later, the family learns that Joon-lee had a bicycle accident. Young-sook is furious because the bike belongs to Mi-ja’s son, Yo-chan. Dr. Park drives everyone to the hospital where the girl’s broken arm is set in a cast. Back at home, Young-sook worries that her sixteen-year-old daughter, Min-lee, or her best friend, Wan-soon, might be having sex with Yo-chan.

On Sunday, the diving team plans its next outing. Min-lee and Wan-soon are partnered together. Diving chief Gu-ja insists that they go out into deeper ocean water to avoid the onshore winds. Later that morning, Wan-soon goes missing. Young-sook and her daughter look for the girl, only to discover a dangerous underwater rip current. Young-sook pulls Min-lee out of danger just in time, but Wan-soon’s body is never found. There is some speculation in the village that Wan-soon might have gotten pregnant by Yo-chan. Mi-ja and her son abruptly leave town to avoid the rumors.

Ten days later, the shaman holds a ceremony to quiet Wan-soon’s wandering spirit. As the diving chief, Gu-ja is particularly upset by the accident. Young-sook says, “Dealing with an accident or death is every haenyeo chief’s greatest torment. She must lead, even as she feels grief and culpability” (297-98). Gu-ja announces that she wants to step down as chief. Young-sook is immediately nominated to take her place, and everyone agrees.

Dr. Oh tells Young-sook that Joon-lee has been selected to attend middle school in Jeju City. She will board with a family there. Despite Young-sook’s fears that the authorities will target the girl as an intellectual radical because of her father, Dr. Oh says that they are looking favorably on her achievements and may even send her to the university one day. Young-sook bids a tearful farewell when her daughter steps onto the bus for the big city.

Later, Young-sook goes to see Mi-ja’s empty house. All the furniture and possessions are still there, and the door is unlocked. She walks inside and thinks to herself, “I touched her things and sensed her all around me. The house became the scab I could not stop picking” (30).

Chapters 17-19 Analysis

This segment begins in 2008 just as the peace memorial is being opened to the public. While the Korean government is willing to move beyond the wrongs of the past, Young-sook is in no frame of mind to agree. She listens to all the rhetoric about forgive and forget with cynicism. Her personal sense of outrage about the Bukchon Massacre and Mi-Ja’s betrayal still remain fresh.

When the narrative shifts back to 1961, the focus is held almost exclusively on the theme of haenyeo culture and how progress is reshaping this way of life. Once Dr. Park and his team arrive to study the cold tolerance of the female divers, the reader is given quite a bit of data about the physiology of these women and how unique it is. Implicit in this study is the point See wishes to make about just how physically tough the haenyeo are. At the same time that the scientists laud the divers’ accomplishments, Young-sook is already becoming aware that she is part of a dying breed. The future direction her descendants choose for their lives underscores the effect that the modern world will have on the haenyeo when Joon-lee leaves to pursue an academic career.

Throughout the novel, Young-sook shows an allegiance to tradition. She upholds the ways of the haenyeo and bemoans the fact that young women no longer want to pursue the life of a diver. Her attitude can be construed as inflexible and rigid in the face of change. This rigidity becomes even more pronounced when she learns that her daughters have crossed paths with Mi-ja’s son. She forbids them to associate with him. Ironically, she herself cannot sever her connection to her old friend since she haunts Mi-ja’s abandoned house. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text