42 pages • 1 hour read
Walter Dean MyersA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Index of Terms
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
This is the 1971 Supreme Court case that ultimately ruled on Muhammad Ali’s effort to secure an exemption from conscription into the US Army. Still named Cassius Clay in the eyes of the law, Ali declared that he was a conscientious objector, opposed to military service on the grounds that it violated his Muslim beliefs (Islam is not pacifistic but does impose strict limits on what constitutes a just versus an unjust war). The local draft board rejected his claim, which the US Department of Justice initially upheld on the grounds that Ali’s objections were based on an objection to the Vietnam War in particular and not a fundamental moral conviction against war in general. Once the case reached the Supreme Court on appeal, the justices decided that this was an arbitrary distinction since various religions include the possibility of making a distinction between the justness of one war and the unjustness of another. Ali had already been allowed to return to the ring when the case was decided (including his unsuccessful attempt to reclaim the championship from Joe Frazier), but the case was no less important for both freeing him from potential legal consequences and validating the justness of his cause.
In professional boxing, there are three kinds of ways a fight can end. A knockout occurs when a fighter falls to the canvas from a punch and is unable to stand up before the referee completes a count of 10. A technical knockout occurs when a ring official (such as a doctor or the referee) determines that a fighter cannot continue without excessive risk, perhaps due to blood or swelling interfering with a fighter’s vision or an inability to defend themselves. A fighter’s corner may also signal their desire to stop the fight, but this is typically not an official act until the referee or doctor certifies it. If neither kind of knockout occurs after the scheduled number of rounds (as few as four and, in Ali’s day, as many as 15, but now 12), then it becomes a matter of scorecards. Three judges at ringside award points after each round based on who they think had the better performance, docking points for suffering a knockdown or committing a foul. Usually, as long as at least two judges agree on a winner, that person wins by decision, but draws can also occur if judges allocate rounds evenly or the disparities in scoring add up to a tie. Ali completed his professional record with 56 victories, 37 of them by knockout or technical knockout, and five defeats, one of them by technical knockout.
The Nation of Islam is a Black nationalist organization that argues that Black people in America will never be treated equally under a white establishment, and so they need to build up their own independent social structures in all possible respects. Founded in 1930 by Wallace Fard Muhammad, it came to prominence in the 1950s under the leadership of Elijah Muhammad (born Elijah Poole) and his chief spokesman, Malcolm X (born Malcolm Little). In 1964, it gained its most famous adherent when the newly crowned boxing champion Cassius Clay announced himself a member of the nation, shortly afterward taking on the new name Muhammad Ali. The Nation has been a controversial organization, largely for its view that white people are literal devils, as well as accusations of antisemitism, particularly directed against its current head, Louis Farrakhan (born Louis Walcott). The Nation has a distinct theology that has drawn critique from many traditional Muslims. Ali left the Nation after Elijah Muhammad’s death in 1975.
Named for James Parkinson, the English physician who published the first writings on the subject, Parkinson’s disease is a condition affecting the brain that causes the death of cells, which in turns impact the brain’s ability to direct the body. Its most visible symptoms are shaking, especially in the hands, while much of the rest of the body is stiffened. Over time, speech and movement tend to become more limited. Parkinson’s disease is a degenerative condition. It is not entirely clear, even to this day, whether Muhammad Ali’s development of Parkinson’s was due to his boxing career.
In 1954, the countries of North Vietnam and South Vietnam were created from the former French colony of Indochina. The North was ruled by a communist party. The United States committed itself to preventing the southern half from also falling under communist control, and by the late 1960s, this resulted in over half a million US forces in the country fighting a local pro-communist insurgency. As the conflict became more costly and destructive, it became a source of painful division in American politics, shattering a longstanding culture of confidence in governing institutions. Meyers portrays Ali opposing the war. The last US forces withdrew from South Vietnam in 1973, and in 1975, forces from the North captured the Southern city of Saigon and renamed it Ho Chi Minh City after the longtime leader of the communist movement. Over 58,000 US soldiers died in the war.
By Walter Dean Myers