95 pages • 3 hours read
Kelly BarnhillA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Luna and the crow escape from Sister Ignatia. Luna suddenly experiences a flood of knowledge that she doesn’t remember learning as memories come pouring back. Luna remembers being frozen during one of her blanked-out moments and hearing Xan tell Glerk how Xan lies to Fyrian and Luna to protect them both. Glerk disapproves of the lies and worries about Luna falling into these trances. Xan confesses she sensed something dangerous in the woods and thought it was the Sorrow Eater, but she was mistaken. Glerk wants Xan to tell Fyrian the truth about Luna. Xan refuses because if he slips up and mentions Xan is a witch, Luna will drop into a trance every time she sees Xan. Luna learns that she was enmagicked, and that Xan will soon be gone. Now Luna knows the truth: She is a witch.
Luna realizes that she remembers all the words and lessons Xan taught her while she was tranced. She knows she needs to find Xan. Luna instinctively uses her magic to create a scrying device. She tells it to show her Xan. Instead she sees Antain, scared and moving fast through the woods. Luna tries again and gets an image of Antain carrying an injured swallow. Luna realizes this is the picture she drew before. Luna keeps asking, and the device keeps showing her the swallow, which seems to see and recognize Luna—and Luna understands that Xan is the swallow.
The thought of dying and leaving Luna makes Xan despondent. Antain senses that the swallow is unwell and talks to her as he cooks a meal. Antain is also very sad, and Xan tries to comfort him as best she can. Crying, Antain tells Xan about Ethyne and how “she makes everything beautiful. Even me” (303). Xan feels that Antain is broken inside, and she peers into his heart to find the cause. To her dismay, she sees an image of a woman clinging to the ceiling of a home, holding a baby with a crescent moon birthmark. Antain describes the yearly Day of Sacrifice.
Xan is horrified that she hadn’t looked past the sorrow in the Protectorate to see what was really going on. She knows the babies she rescued had happy lives but feels terrible for the parents who lost their children. Xan sees how guilty and ashamed Antain feels about his part in taking the madwoman’s baby. She wishes she could transform and tell him that the babies are all happy and safe. Xan wonders how this terrible practice of sacrifices started and remembers the echo of “something quiet, predatory, and terrifying” (305). Knowing how dangerous sorrow is, Xan pushes her own sadness deep down inside.
Antain reveals that he is in the woods because his own baby boy is next in line to be sacrificed. He worries that if their child is taken, it would kill Ethyne, a “tender soul” who might go insane with sorrow. Even though Antain has “never harmed any creature” (305), he loves his family and will do anything to protect them—including killing the Witch.
Ethyne remembers her mother’s stories about the Witch. When Ethyne learned that her older brother was one of the sacrificial babies, she asked her mother lots of questions. Unfortunately, Ethyne’s curiosity drove her mother to fixate on the Witch. Ethyne’s mother died when Ethyne was 16, prompting Ethyne to join the Sisters and learn the truth. But Ethyne discovered that no one in the Tower would talk about the Witch.
Ethyne visits the Sisters and tells them the truth: Sister Ignatia made up all the stories about the “baby-eating Witch” (311) so she could eat everyone’s sorrows. Now that the sun is shining, Ethyne says she “can see clearly” (312) and calls on the Sisters to leave the Tower with her. Antain’s youngest brother, Wyn, helps Ethyne by locking the novitiate and the Sisters who don’t follow Ethyne in their rooms. Ethyne and Wyn free all the Tower prisoners and open all the doors.
Since Sister Ignatia left, the mothers who sacrificed babies are having visions. They see their children growing up in other families and having families of their own. They feel as if they have just lost their children again. At the same time, as the fog lifts, they feel hope and joy. Families wonder and question whether their babies are really dead. A crowd, holding signs and giving speeches, gathers in front of the Tower.
The Elders are alarmed at the sudden uprising. They blame Grand Elder Gherland, since Ethyne, the “rabble-rouser,” and Antain are his family. Gherland assures them that these difficulties are temporary, that their lives will go back to normal when Sister Ignatia returns and Antain is dead. At that moment, the volcano rumbles and threatens to erupt.
Luna feels energized by the moon, which is about to rise. She feels like her love and knowledge are drawing her toward her grandmother.
Meanwhile, Fyrian is growing, unevenly and piece by piece. Fyrian, thinking he is already Simply Enormous, is excited to be even bigger. Glerk struggles to diplomatically tell Fyrian that he has not always been huge, and was, in fact, tiny. But Glerk assures Fyrian that his heart has always been Simply Enormous. Glerk finally admits that neither he nor Xan have understood what is going on with Fyrian or why he stayed in his babyhood for 500 years. Glerk vows to support Fyrian through all his changes.
Glerk spies Luna’s magic and knows she is “turning into a grown-up. And a witch. Both at the same time” (323). Glerk also sees Xan’s magic and worries she doesn’t have enough to transform. Fyrian fears that the volcano is about to erupt: It feels the same as it did just before his mother died. Fyrian and Glerk hurry to warn Xan about the impending eruption.
After hearing Antain’s story, Xan is tormented with self-recrimination. While she knows she saved all the babies from starvation or being eaten by animals, she feels that she should have done more to stop the sacrifices. When the moon rises, Xan plans to gather moonlight, transform out of her swallow form, and magically send Antain safely home. Antain and Xan hear people approaching. Xan spots the signature silver and blue of Luna’s magic, and Antain prepares to slit the witch’s throat.
At Xan’s home, the madwoman wears the Seven League Boots. Sister Ignatia arrives and orders her to remove them. The madwoman refuses; the boots make her feel strong and light and alive. She feels magic everywhere around her, and so does Sister Ignatia. Both women gather up as much magic as they can, and the madwoman understands how to find Luna.
Smoke billows from one of the volcano’s craters, and Sister Ignatia knows it is about to erupt. She offers to take the madwoman back to the Tower in return for the boots. The madwoman knows she is lying. The madwoman has a vision of Sister Ignatia long ago, taking the boots and leaving all the magicians to die. The madwoman calls Sister Ignatia “Tiger’s Heart,” which upsets the Sister. The madwoman says everybody has heard the story about the Witch who ate a tiger’s heart. Sister Ignatia angrily denies that there is any story like that, and she should know because she started them all. The madwoman insinuates that the other Sisters in the Tower talk about Sister Ignatia. When Sister Ignatia says that is impossible, the madwoman counters that lots of things that seem impossible—like flying on paper birds and Luna being alive—are true.
Sister Ignatia attacks the madwoman, who avoids her magically flying knives. The madwoman runs away in the Seven League Boots to find Luna. Sister Ignatia follows swiftly behind.
True stories emerge to counter many false narratives. Both Ethyne and the madwoman were curious children who questioned the veracity of their mothers’ stories. Both learn that stories can deceive. We discover that Ethyne (like the madwoman) lost an older brother to the Witch, and we can infer that her mother is one also of the first-person parent narrators. Over time, the stories of the Witch conflate; the appearance and nature of the “Witch” in both mothers’ stories blur between the baby-eating witch and one with a tiger’s heart and magical boots. Sister Ignatia becomes part of the very stories she introduced.
Ethyne learns that “controlling stories is power indeed” (309). Ethyne tells the Sisters “a story” (311)—the truth about Sister Ignatia—that changes the balance of power in the Protectorate. Sister Ignatia started all the false stories to gain power over the people and milk their sorrow. Ethyne takes power back from Sister Ignatia by revealing the true narrative.
As people ask more questions, the Protectorate’s repressive nature begins to crumble. By opening the Tower and unlocking the library—so coveted by young, inquisitive Antain—Ethyne makes knowledge available to all. Previously the Sisters had controlled all access to knowledge, “hoarded and hidden” (312) it, yet ironically, they had little self-knowledge or awareness about the evil in their midst or the control Sister Ignatia exercised over them.
Out from under Sister Ignatia’s influence, the Protectorate transforms: The people experience sorrow at the loss of their children, but with the sorrow comes hope and joy. The more people question, the more they hope, so the clouds are lifted from peoples’ hearts and minds. Now they can stage a rebellion against the tyranny of “grief” and the tyranny of the Council of Elders and the Sisters.
Fyrian is also transforming—he is finally growing up. Glerk doesn’t know why Fyrian has stayed a child for so long, but he speculates “Maybe Xan did it” (320) or perhaps Fyrian did it to himself. Either way, Fyrian is leaving his childhood. Luna is also transforming into an adult. Her memory is “unlocked” and she gains self-knowledge. Glerk feels sorry for Xan, knowing that she “did her best to hold on to Luna’s childhood” (323), but Luna’s maturation is inevitable.
Finally, we again see the power of familial love. Parents will do anything to safeguard their loved ones. Xan lies “to protect” and tries to keep Luna from adult sorrows. Antain, a kind, gentle person, is prepared to take a life to keep his family together. The madwoman quite literally does the impossible to find Luna, as her madness and grief boost her magical skills.
By Kelly Barnhill