46 pages • 1 hour read
Lucy AdlingtonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Index of Terms
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Auschwitz prisoners engaged in both successful and unsuccessful attempts to thwart SS officials. For example, Maria Stromberger, a Catholic nurse who volunteered for service at Auschwitz, reportedly “saw it as her humanitarian mission to help inmates whenever possible, including Jews” (236). This help often took the form of passing along information to Marta Fuchs and others; Stromberger also preserved some of the evidence of Auschwitz’s atrocities that would be presented in postwar trials.
Alliances developed among the Stabsgebäude workers. Here, prisoners not only traded food and other goods but engaged in intellectual discussions and taught one another their native languages. Importantly, they also provided care for anyone who fell ill. The network of alliances helped pass along information about the war and Allied progress. For a time, privileged prisoners were allowed to send mail to family outside of Auschwitz. Though heavily monitored and censored, such mail could carry coded warnings to uncaptured Jews.
Because she made frequent trips to the Kanada storehouses, Marta was well positioned to participate in the underground resistance. She not only had access to vital contacts but to “bribes, papers, and disguises for escape” (243). Though escape was rarely successful—even those who made it outside the camp risked round-ups—Marta planned to try. Walter Rosenberg, a friend of Irene’s, became the most famous Auschwitz escapee. He and fellow escapee Alfred Wetzler were able to verify rumors of the Auschwitz exterminations and provide warnings for the Hungarian Jews who were the next target. Other attempts failed, such as that of Mala Zimetbaum—a friend to the seamstresses who opted for suicide when returned to the camp. While successful escape attempts heartened many inmates, the risk of betrayal by disloyal peers was a constant threat to resistance efforts.
Unfortunately, 40 prisoners were killed by Allied bombing on September 3, 1944. Among the injured was seamstress Lulu Grünberg. The chapter closes by recounting a gunpowder smuggling operation that resulted in the destruction of one of the crematoriums. Leader of the operation and friend of the seamstresses Róza Robota was hanged for her involvement.
As 1945 began, Allied troops advanced and Auschwitz was abruptly abandoned. All records were destroyed and inmates were ordered to evacuate at gunpoint. The seamstresses debated whether it was safest to try to stay at the camp in hopes of Russian assistance or to follow the orders of the SS. They left as a unified group, though they later parted as Marta and four other seamstresses split off, aiming to reach freedom. The four were ultimately discovered and shot by German soldiers; Marta alone survived.
Meanwhile, the remaining dressmakers and prisoners were loaded into coal wagons to be taken to Germany. Many did not survive the horrific conditions of the journey; those who did found themselves at Ravensbrück concentration camp, already filled beyond capacity with prisoners.
Hunya, Bracha, Katka, and the other dressmakers remained there for an unknown amount of time until they were suddenly transported (via an actual passenger train) to Malchow, a satellite camp. Here the young women were assigned separate work duties. Hunya did some seamstress work for the wife of one of the camp’s factory managers. They remained there until the German surrender in May 1945, when SS officers fled the camp. Hunya and others hid in a shed until Russian soldiers discovered them and assured them that they were indeed free. They were brought to a German house, where they took what clothing and food they found, and were then transported to Prague. There Hunya reunited with her sister and brother-in-law.
Bracha and Katka obtained refuge in a German home but then journeyed back toward Bratislava by foot and by hitching rides. They were later able to travel via train, now flooded with refugees from many nations. Though their family members had perished, they reunited with Irene Reichenberg, who, along with Renée Ungar, avoided recapture on the death march out of Auschwitz. The women began trying to recover remaining family possessions and to start their new lives.
In the ensuing months, the Czech textile and fashion industries gradually returned. It was through an invitation to join a new salon that Bracha learned that Marta Fuchs had survived; a book in her backpack thwarted the bullet. Though her journey to safety was a long one, she received help from Polish allies who vouched that Marta had indeed been an Auschwitz prisoner and not a Nazi posing as one. Marta faced many challenges in the establishment of the new salon: Supplies were difficult to obtain and antisemitic sentiments still present. Hunya and Manci Birnbaum joined Bracha in accepting seamstress positions from Marta. In the years that followed, many of the women married and started families. Some would emigrate from Europe to the United States or Israel (including Irene and Renée).
The fate of major Nazi officials and their wives varied: Some died by suicide while others were captured and imprisoned. Hedwig Höss was protected by a network of Nazi leaders who hid her in the months following the war’s end, but she was eventually interrogated by British soldiers. Either she or her brother gave up information on Rudolf’s location, and he was captured and hanged.
Adlington reveals that Bracha Berkovič is her primary source of information for the book. Now Bracha Kohút, she is nearing the age of 100.
The Auschwitz experience continues to traumatize both direct victims and subsequent generations of Jews. While some of the seamstresses shared their experiences, many remained silent due to both the pain of such memories and the unwillingness of others to listen. It was not until the 1980s, with the inception of the World Gathering of Holocaust Survivors, that society began to view the experiences of the victims as historically important and worthy of preservation. In a questionnaire distributed and completed at this event, Adlington found a valuable resource for her book. One of these response was completed by Hunya Volkmann and contained her thoughts on everything from reparations to the reason she survived her imprisonment.
The friendships forged in the Upper Tailoring Studio endured beyond the Auschwitz gate. Adlington met descendants of some of the women; many still possess garments sewn by their survivor mother, grandmother, or aunt. Adlington reminds readers that Auschwitz-Birkenau and other camps still stand and are open to visitors.
Bracha Berkovič Kohút—the longest living survivor of the Upper Tailoring Salon—passed away in February 2021, around the time of the book’s publication.
Chapter 9’s focus on underground resistance efforts in the camp reinforces the theme of Solidarity and Alliances: Tools of Survival. Knowing who could and could not be trusted was instrumental to thwarting the Nazis. Importantly, prisoners were able to unify across racial, ethnic, and class boundaries in a common effort. The agency that resistance afforded was mentally beneficial, restoring to prisoners a modicum of their dignity and sense of worth. Though it is impossible to know whether those who survived would not have done so without a keen sense of resourcefulness and daringness, these qualities proved valuable. The bonds forged in the Auschwitz salon not only held throughout the women’s time at the camp but drove several women to reunite post war.
The Politics of Clothing remains an important theme to the book’s end. Adlington details its importance in escape attempts: Inmate garb betrayed prisoners while access to SS uniforms could increase their chances of success. The escape of Rosenberg and Wetzler owed something to the warm items they secured, along with the smart suits that brought them credibility once they reached the outside world. Chapter 10 further stresses the value of warm and durable clothing, as newly freed prisoners often had to walk miles to safety. Further, for many of the Upper Tailoring prisoners, sewing provided a means to re-enter society, as several of the women relied on seamstress work to support themselves and establish postwar lives.
By way of conclusion, Chapter 11 shifts to the present day, reminding readers that while Holocaust survivors remain today, their numbers are dwindling. To that end, Adlington argues, recording their stories while they are alive is increasingly important. Many documents associated with the Holocaust (e.g., the mail relatively privileged prisoners had access to) have already been lost, thanks in part to Nazi efforts to destroy camp records. This makes the testimonials of survivors all the more important—not only as important historical records but as challenges to the taboo that demands the Holocaust’s atrocities not be spoken of. Knowledge of the genocide is essential in preventing further atrocities and in quelching both xenophobia and institutional racism. By highlighting the seamstresses’ individuality and humanity, Adlington’s book serves as this kind of historical document.
Art
View Collection
European History
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
International Holocaust Remembrance Day
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
World War II
View Collection