52 pages • 1 hour read
Robert GalbraithA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This novel contains depictions of substance use disorders, violence, warzone-related trauma, racism, and emotional manipulation. Further, the novel references mental health conditions, suicide, sexual assault, and financial manipulation.
Outside an apartment building, police block off journalists and paparazzi. Some girls bring flowers to the scene as reporters are filmed discussing a woman falling from her penthouse balcony. Detective Inspector Roy Carver and Detective Sergeant Eric Wardle wait for the police ambulance so they can move the woman’s body from the investigation tent. Several days go by and information about the case circulates in the media; the conclusion is that the woman died by suicide. Three months pass.
Robin reflects on her engagement to her partner, Matthew, which took place the night before as she exits the London Underground. She makes her way to her latest temporary secretary position. As she ascends the stairs, a woman nearly knocks her over. Robin reaches Strike’s private detective agency and is excited due to her secret desire to be a private detective. She starts to enter the office but runs into a large man who emerges from the door so quickly she is knocked off her feet.
Strike grabs Robin before she can fall down the stairs. He apologizes and ushers her into his office, not recognizing her. His poor finances forced him to let go of his last temporary secretary, making Robin’s arrival an unpleasant surprise. He refreshes himself in the bathroom and recalls his own evening, which involved being kicked out of his partner Charlotte’s apartment and their subsequent morning altercation that Robin interrupted. Strike emerges and gives Robin hasty secretarial instructions before going into his office. He muses on his mounting debt and sudden homelessness.
Robin interrupts his reflections by telling Strike he has a client. After making himself presentable, Strike is introduced to John. John tells Strike that they know each other from childhood, as Strike used to be friends with John’s late brother Charlie. John then talks about his dead sister, Lula. He recalls when the adopted girl joined his family and bursts into tears. Robin enters with coffee and biscuits. Strike passes her a note asking her to verify that John and Lula are siblings. John continues talking about Lula before he asks Strike to solve her death, believing that she did not die by suicide. Robin discretely passes Strike a note confirming John’s relationship to Lula, as well as additional pertinent information. John explains that Lula’s history of mental health concerns caused the police to believe her death was a suicide, leading them to ignore clues. Strike rejects John’s job, causing John to have an outburst of rage and frustration.
In the outer office, Robin surveys Alison, John’s girlfriend. Alison believes Lula died by suicide, a fact that John cannot seem to accept. In the inner office, John mentions justice and Strike agrees to help him. Strike recalls his training as a member of the special investigation branch of the military police as he starts to question John about the day of Lula’s death. John describes a fight he had with Lula about her choice of boyfriend, but they resolved the issue that morning. After visiting their mother, Lula had her makeup done and visited with her model friend Ciara before partying with her boyfriend, Evan. The two were seen arguing before Lula returned home, where she later fell to her death. John pays Strike a month’s advance and departs, although Alison expresses her displeasure.
Strike compliments Robin on her quick work. He exits and goes to the Tottenham pub for a beer and his thoughts turn to Charlotte. She is beautiful and smart but with deep problems that have made their relationship turbulent. She has done something that he cannot forgive, making him break up with her for the first time, as she was the instigator of their previous rifts. He then reflects again on his poor finances, as well as his recent weight gain exacerbated by his new prosthetic leg. He calls his friend Detective Richard Anstis to get the numbers of the police officers who were assigned Lula’s case. Strike then calls in a favor with a different, unnamed friend before calling Wardle. He offers Wardle information in exchange for Lula’s case file, and they set up a meeting. Strike ignores a call from Robin and goes on a walk, waiting until she leaves the office so he can sleep there.
In the office, Robin calls her friends to share news of her engagement. She performs some secretarial tasks and cleans the office, discovering Strike’s overnight bag. She assumes that the woman she nearly collided with earlier was a romantic partner to Strike. At five o’clock in the evening, she leaves.
Strike wastes time until that evening, then returns to his office with a camp bed to sleep on. He recalls some of his hectic childhood, during which his mother would move him and his sister to various unstable living situations. He then puts together the materials for Lula’s case before reviewing the evidence in an envelope from John. It contains pictures from CCTV footage of an unknown man, dubbed the Runner, approaching Lula’s neighborhood, then running past the camera again 50 minutes later. There are images of a second man as well, which John’s notes state is a possible lookout. There is also a note that the security guard on duty at the apartment building that night was unwell, leaving the lobby unattended for 15 minutes. John’s notes describe Lula’s neighbors, Tansy and Freddie Bestigui, as well as Tansy’s testimony that she heard Lula have an argument before falling.
Galbraith opens the novel with the Prologue, a detailed exploration and description of a young socialite’s death. This opening provides the reader with details surrounding Lula’s death through the lens of police conversations and media coverage, while also opening with action that creates suspense. The subsequent narrative time skip, which jumps forward three months, provides credence to the decision that Lula’s death was a suicide: Enough time passes that the public has lost interest, allowing for the unexpected return to attention spurred by John. While this is not a classic example of in medias res, a narrative technique in which a work of fiction begins in the middle of the action, it accomplishes many of the same goals, such as creating tension and inspiring curiosity.
Strike and Robin make an unlikely professional pair, which adds to the novel’s initial tensions. However, Robin quickly establishes herself as insightful and capable of taking initiative, while remaining sensitive to Strike’s new living situation; this contributes to Strike’s increasing faith in Robin and develops The Importance of Trust. Strike is comparatively gruff and disheveled, his outward appearance matching his emotional turmoil. His intellectual skills and past training distinguish him from other detectives, providing him with the necessary context to solve the previously dismissed case. They are foils as much as they are colleagues, contrasting each other while letting each other’s positive characteristics and capabilities shine through.
Strike’s first interactions with the case are subjected to other people’s perspectives. John filters his perception of Lula and her death through his status as the supposedly-loving older brother. The evidence he gives Strike is peppered with his own thoughts, which intentionally direct Strike to other suspects. Strike and Robin discover additional information through the internet, but most of the articles they find are filled with the opinions and emotions of the writers. This sets the pattern of the rest of the novel as Strike navigates people’s personal perceptions of Lula and her death, digging through their opinions to uncover the truth, showing that The Proof Is in the Details.
The first part of the novel is filled with parallels that continue to be explored throughout The Cuckoo’s Calling. Robin’s relationship has flourished and moved to the next step while Strike’s relationship has fallen apart. John, the living Bristow child, is sandwiched between a brother and sister who have both passed away. Media perception is contrasted to reality, showing the disconnect between gossip and truth. These are all components that allow the reader to study Lula, as understanding her interpersonal and parasocial relationships—a perceived relationship between a person and a media persona (such as a celebrity or a character in a television series)—is integral to understanding her death.
By Robert Galbraith