52 pages • 1 hour read
Robert GalbraithA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
On a rainy Friday, Robin goes to an interview for a job she is not enthusiastic for. Strike gets a call from Wardle confirming that his information was good and arranging to drop off the Lula file that evening. Strike goes through it, making his own commentary and comparing the documentation to things Wardle said when they met. When reading Evan’s testimony, Strike reflects on substance use disorders, which include his own mother’s death by heroin overdose. When reading Ciara’s testimony, Strike learns that the afternoon of her death Lula asserted that she planned on leaving her possessions and money to her brother. Lula also repeatedly tried to call John and Tony the day of her death. He reads some of her emails and is struck by her seemingly cheerful nature.
Strike arrives at his sister’s house for his nephew’s birthday, where he avoids questions about Charlotte. Strike is repeatedly questioned about his prosthetic and his relationship with his father. Overwhelmed, Strike goes inside and uses Lucy’s DVD player to play the CCTV footage of the Runner and his apparent companion. Strike’s nephew, Jack, enters the room. Strike gives him his birthday gift before Lucy forces them to return to the party.
Strike arranges to meet John for lunch and to get Lula’s laptop, then calls Derrick and asks him to check the logbook for Rochelle’s surname. Strike then looks at Guy’s website, where he sees hoodies that look like ones that he saw on the men in the CCTV footage.
Robin and Strike go to Vashti, the boutique Lula and Rochelle visited the day she died. Robin privately reflects on a job offer she received but feels dread whenever she thinks about it. At Vashti, Robin shows initiative and wins over the saleswomen by trying on expensive items and pretending that Strike is rich. Her clothing items include a green dress that, when she shows Strike, creates an uncomfortably intimate moment. She gently pushes the shop girls to talk about Lula. They believed Lula called Evan while in the shop, asking for him to come over late that night.
Robin and Strike part ways. As Strike walks, he is discomfited by how attractive he finds Robin. He arrives at a nice restaurant and meets Tony, who notes that John is delayed and wants this opportunity to speak to Strike privately. He talks disparagingly about Strike’s career choice, and in revenge Strike shows some of his knowledge about his law firm’s inner workings. Tony believes that John is having a mental health crisis and that his suspicions about Lula’s death are unfounded. He critiques Yvette Bristow’s parenting style, blaming Charlie’s death on her lack of discipline. Before John arrives, they talk briefly about the day Lula died.
John joins Tony and Strike. There is some tension as Strike resumes his questioning about Lula’s visit to her mother the morning of her death. He also asks about the many times Lula tried to call him, but Tony was attending a conference and assumed Lula’s concerns could wait. Tony speaks disparagingly about Lula’s chauffer before departing. After lunch, Strike and John talk about Tony’s prejudices. The conversation about family leads John to ask Strike about his biological father. John repeats that Charlie died, and Tony blamed the death on Yvette, which culminated in a years-long rift between the two.
As they near John’s offices, he describes Lula’s desire to find her biological family. He had disapproved, but Lula found her mother, Marlene Higson, anyway. John views her biological mother as a “shameless mercenary” (209) who sold information about Lula to the press. Strike asks John about Lula’s intentions to leave her possessions to him, and John is dismissive of the claim, believing it to be exaggeration. John promises to try to get Strike in contact with Guy and Marlene, then gives Strike Lula’s computer.
The end of Strike’s amputated leg is increasingly uncomfortable due to his recent walking. He returns to his office, where Robin provides him with the day’s updates before leaving. He removes his prosthetic and finds his scar tissue enflamed. The day’s conversations lead him to think about his mother’s turbulent relationship history and the difficulties of family. He then travels to a Chinese restaurant where he meets a man named Spanner, to whom he gives Lula’s computer and requests he examines it. He returns to his office, worrying about his leg. Charlotte texts him, requesting a phone call. He thinks back to the night they met.
Robin arrives to work and realizes Strike is sleeping in the inner office. She wakes him with a knock and, when he is decent, delivers news: she has found Rochelle by calling her outpatient services and pretending to be her to get an appointment time. Strike asks her to look up the legal conference Tony attended the night Lula died as he rushes out of the building. He waits outside the hospital for Rochelle. He notes her expensive coat, which she claims to have bought herself. They get coffee and Strike tries to navigate Rochelle’s fear that she has been implicated in Lula’s death. Rochelle asserts that she believes it was a suicide.
Rochelle explains how she met Lula at an outpatient clinic and that the girls bonded over their mental health conditions and Black ancestry. She is vague about the details of their visit to Vashti. Rochelle describes a test Lula did on her companions, giving each of them different stories to see who would go to the press. After she states she was surprised when she found out about Lula’s death, she leaves. Strike follows her and overhears part of her phone conversation. When Rochelle notices him, he asks for her number, then gives her a business card. Strike watches her leave and believes that her coat is too expensive for her to have bought by herself.
Strike returns to the office, where Lucy is waiting for him. Robin tactfully excuses herself so that Strike and his sister can have privacy. Lucy asks him if he and Charlotte have broken up. When he confirms, she repeatedly expresses her concern for his well-being.
Robin picks up lunch and reflects on her conversation with Lucy, during which she learned about both Strike’s mother’s death and his amputated leg. It is revealed that she has accepted a job with a media consultancy, much to Matthew’s delight, but has yet to tell Strike. She feels guilty about having learned so much from Lucy, although she is curious and wants to find out more. When she returns, Strike is using her computer. They exchange information about their days, but their discomfort at their recent intimacies makes them distant. Robin has arranged an appointment with Guy.
When Strike accesses the police file, he shifts his attention from collecting objective evidence to subjective evidence. He connects the contents of the file with what he has heard and uses it to direct his ongoing examinations, gaining insight into the motivations of those who interacted with Lula on her last day. This is where Strike’s attention to detail arises most evidently and reinforces the growing theme that The Proof Is in the Details. Galbraith lays the foundation of the novel’s reveal in these early chapters by having Strike take note of things that the police failed to see, the details of a custom Guy Somé hoodie on CCTV footage being one of the most prominent examples. Strike’s ability to notice these details also reinforces how he fits into the detective trope, in that his intelligence allows him to outwit people around him.
More familial interactions, both between Strike and his loved ones and between the Bristows, illuminate their inner workings. Strike’s life is compared both implicitly and explicitly with the life of his half-sister, Lucy. Lucy has a nuclear family, which gives her a sense of normalcy that she did not experience as a child. It is made evident through her conversations with Strike that she wants him to have a similar life, believing that he can find a sense of purpose if tied to a traditional family structure. Strike’s discomfort within his own family is mirrored in Lula. While alive, Lula tried to find her biological family members, seeking a greater sense of identity through her parentage. This reveals an inherent discomfort with her adoptive family, paired with an uncertainty of her identity. Tony confirms this during his interview with Strike, as his disdain for Yvette’s parenting style reveals components of a childhood that might have hindered Lula from flourishing.
This section is bookended by Robin grappling with her future. She begins Part 3 with a job interview and then reveals that she has been offered the position. Throughout the section, however, she becomes increasingly involved in the investigation. She showcases her initiative by arranging for Strike to meet Rochelle and acting with discretion about his living situation, repeatedly proving her worth to Strike and the detective agency. This reinforces her devotion to a job that, logically, she understands she must need. Robin’s desire to follow her passions adds depth to her character, especially when paired with Matthew’s growing contempt for something that she enjoys.
In speaking with Rochelle, Strike learns more about Lula’s concern with the press, a previously alluded-to worry that is made clear when Rochelle describes how Lula tested those close to her. This conversation solidifies both The Price of Fame and The Importance of Trust. Lula’s fame also makes her the focus of media obsession, causing her life to be followed and analyzed by people who idolize her money and beauty. Others desire to profit off her, selling her secrets and making her distrustful. By testing those around her, Lula uncovered those who had her best interests at heart. However, this also reveals how little she came to trust people, as she was driven to such tests by her lack of stability and emotional security. This knowledge makes Lula more sympathetic to the reader, a direct contrast to the people who viewed her as selfish and careless.
By Robert Galbraith