48 pages • 1 hour read
Tracy KidderA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Kidder records Tony’s history as told by Tony to both Jim and Kidder himself. Tony grew up in the North End of Boston and witnessed domestic violence throughout his childhood as his father beat his mother. He saw murder by the time he was seven, and he and his brother tried to kill their father. After trying to kill himself at 15, Tony stayed in a mental hospital and had been diagnosed with a range of disorders such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Kidder reports that much of what Tony describes of his childhood is true, though there are key inconsistencies. For example, Tony tells a story about being kidnapped and raped by a neighbor. Kidder finds such an instance documented around the time when and location where Tony grew up but describes Tony’s “nonchalance” in talking about such severe sexual assault. Kidder also states that many young boys from the North End experienced sexual assault at the hands of priests, but Tony feverishly denies that this ever happened to him.
Tony officially went to prison when he was 26 for “assault with intent to commit rape,” the victim being 17 at the time (124). Tony tells Jim and Kidder that the crime wasn’t sexual and instead a robbery. He was convicted as a level-three sex offender and served 18 years in prison.
Tony shares that during his time in prison, he eventually grew to be comfortable. He knew what to expect in his days and built a community. A man named Isaac praised his “strength and generosity” (241). Tony describes how different the world had become and the challenge of finding money, shelter, and support after his release in 2013. Though Tony picked up some work and couch surfed for a while, he went back to jail for failing to register as a sex offender.
Upon Tony’s release from jail, Kidder writes that “life on the street was his only real option” (128). When Tony needed suboxone and a friend recommended a doctor who could help, Tony met Dr. Jim.
Tony struggles to obtain housing because of his classification as a level-three sex offender. Though Tony faces a great deal of challenges, he values his relationship with Jim, which gives him a sense of great purpose. Kidder writes that one way Tony demonstrates this is by telling people that Jim is his great-uncle—despite this being false.
As Tony and Jim work more closely together, Tony becomes a fixture in the Health Care for the Homeless Program. Tony becomes Jim’s eyes and ears at the McInnis House, keeping Jim informed about patients and helping the community grow and heal—at least as much as both Tony and Jim can.
Tony begins to regulate the McInnis House—both to protect Jim, in his eyes, and help the patients. Tony sometimes deals drugs and sometimes counsels patients about not taking them. Kidder writes about the chaos of rough sleeping through Tony. Tony becomes a reliable fixture for a time but then disappears. This inconsistency is common and wears on Jim.
Kidder writes about another rough sleeper named John Cotrone, a man who has struggled with addiction for many years. The team helps John find housing. Though John is still adjusting to life indoors, he remains living in his apartment with help from Jim, who, Kidder writes, sometimes struggles to maintain boundaries with clients. John and Jim meet at a coffee shop called Finagle a Bagel on Friday mornings, and, like Tony, John helps Jim glean information about patients on the street.
One Friday morning, Jim begins street rounds at Mousey Park. Both Tony and BJ—a gentleman in a wheelchair who had one leg amputated—are missing. BJ is at Mass General, having just had his other leg amputated due to an incurable infection. Kidder joins Jim and Eileen, a psychiatrist, for Friday street rounds. He details the patients they see, including a woman with schizophrenia sleeping under a blanket and patients with handwritten signs asking for funds.
Kidder reflects on the saintly nature of Jim’s work once again, though Jim denies this and instead feels he is a “fortunate man” (152). They end street rounds with visiting BJ, who is recovering in the hospital. He acknowledges that, as he’s felt for many years, he needs to quit using alcohol.
Kidder writes that, though the work the Street Team does is sometimes defeating, recovery is possible. He records stories of the patients who have successfully been housed and the many board members who’d been unhoused, like Larry Adams and Sara Reid. Kidder tells the story of one such board member named Joanne Guarino. Joanne often speaks at public events, including an annual speech at Harvard Medical School for incoming students. She tells her life story and the impact the Health Care for the Homeless Program has had on her life. She advises the new medical students that “you gotta listen, that’s the key. You have to have compassion” (161). The students cheer for Joanne.
Through Tony, Kidder tracks how the criminal justice system, interpersonal conflict and complex trauma, mental health disorders, and substance abuse impact houselessness. Tony’s untreated trauma from his early life created a cycle of violence and criminality. After Tony’s imprisonment, it’s increasingly more difficult for him to establish his life. Kidder demonstrates how being a convicted sex offender impedes him from getting housing. He juxtaposes statistical evidence with Tony’s lived experience to illustrate Systemic Failures as a Catalyst for Houselessness.
Kidder uses Tony’s story, and the story of figures like BJ or Joanne Guarino, to demonstrate how Jim and the Health Care for the Homeless Program positively impact the lives of their patients. Kidder uses patient testimonies and experiences to show that compassion and direct action are beneficial. Though houselessness in Boston won’t be solved because of the program, the lives of many people are changed. Joanne, for example, is a formerly unhoused person who became a board member for the program. This is because of the program’s ability to provide mutual aid and direct action.
The narrative shows both the good and bad sides of people. Tony finds purpose in his relationship with Jim but lies about Jim being his great-uncle. He helps people get off drugs but also deals them. He is sometimes a reliable fixture in the program, but then he disappears. In this way, the narrative shows how humans are complex.
Kidder also emphasizes the importance of human relationships and a patient-centric approach. Tony’s relationship with Jim helps both men, as Tony serves as Jim’s eyes and ears. Joanne sums it up when speaking at Harvard Medical School and emphasizing the role of empathy: “[Y]ou gotta listen, that’s the key” (161).
By Tracy Kidder
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Common Reads: Freshman Year Reading
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Poverty & Homelessness
View Collection
Sociology
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection