69 pages • 2 hours read
Elizabeth GaskellA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Bell comes to Milton to visit. He thinks Milton has influenced Margaret with socialist ideas. Richard and Bell discuss how the men in Milton are uneducated. Bell extols the beauty of his home Oxford. Thornton comes for tea. Thornton did not want to hear how his mother’s meeting went with Margaret. His jealousy for her has grown but so has his love. Thornton resolves to not alter his behavior for her. Margaret has a letter from Lennox explaining there is no hope for a pardon for Frederick. Thornton does not understand much of the conversation as Bell and Thornton make many references to classic literature. Thornton and Bell debate how one should spend their time whether in the pursuit of knowledge or to earn money. Thornton does not understand the concept of leisure. Margaret defends Thornton saying he is a leader in Milton. Bell reminds them he is a Milton man, but he is much fonder of living in a university town. They debate the merits of a town being architecturally beautiful or functional. Thornton argues the people of Milton have been too busy working to make the town aesthetically pleasing. He champions the spirit of the people: “Our glory and our beauty arise out of our outward strength, which makes us victorious over material resistance, and over greater difficulty still” (455). The men have different views on the past. Margaret attempts to change the subject by mentioning Edith. Richard makes a joke about Edith exaggerating the truth and Thornton makes a snarky comment about Margaret valuing the truth. He instantly feels ashamed.
After Thornton leaves, the men remark on his poor attitude, but Margaret defends him. Bell suggests to Richard that Margaret cares for Thornton. Bell leaves and invites Richard and Margaret to come to live at Oxford. The Hales visit Higgins and the Boucher children. Thornton comes to visit them regularly and is making certain they receive an education. However, Thornton is regularly skipping his lessons with Richard. Having worried himself about Bell’s suggestion, Richard asks Margaret about Thornton’s affection. She tells him about the proposal and her refusal. Richard is glad she does not return his feelings. Margaret changes the subject to the Lennoxes to avoid showing emotion.
Thornton is too mired in his business problems to visit the Hales. Margaret slips into a depression and struggles to find any joy in life except spending time with the Boucher children. Frederick writes announcing his marriage to Dolores. In response to the news of the impossibility of a pardon, he renounces his loyalty to England. He has married into a wealthy family. Dolores sends letters to Margaret and sent her a lace mantilla as a gift. Richard’s health is failing but he still goes to visit Bell. Margaret opts to stay in Milton and enjoy a respite from work and worry: “For months past, all her own personal cares and troubles had had to be stuffed away into a dark cupboard; but now she has leisure to take them out, and mourn over them, and study their nature, and see the true method of subduing them into the elements of peace” (469). Martha tells her Fanny Thornton is engaged to a wealthy merchant. The Thorntons cared for Martha when she was younger after her family had experienced hardships. Margaret visits Mary Higgins and finds Nicholas subdued and more interested in religion. Margaret burns the letters from Lennox. She thinks of her father and hopes he returns from Oxford in better spirits.
Richard is weary from visiting old friends, but he is heartened to know they approved of his decision to leave his role as vicar. He laments his decision cost him so dearly. Richard asks Bell to care for Margaret upon his death. Bell commends Richard for caring for Margaret. Richard dies in his sleep. Bell immediately takes the train to Milton and sees Thornton on the way. Thornton is concerned about what will happen to Margaret, and Bell assumes she will go to the Lennox’s but says he plans to watch after her. Thornton reveals he has recently traveled to Helstone. As soon as Margaret sees the carriage arrives, she knows her father is dead.
Margaret falls into a despondent state of grief. Dixon and Bell write to Mrs. Shaw requesting her help. Mrs. Shaw cannot stay long because Edith is pregnant, so she wants to take Margaret home with her immediately. Edith mentions the possibility of Margaret returning to Lennox and he ignores it. Mrs. Shaw arrives with her maid and judges Milton to be filthy. Bell leaves Mrs. Shaw to comfort Margaret. He will have to stay at the Thorntons as they are out of rooms at the Hales’. Bell tells Thornton that Margaret is glad to leave Milton as it has been a place that has only brought her sorrow. Thornton thinks the last 18 months have been a boundless joy to him. Fanny and Mrs. Thornton are busy with wedding preparations. Bell refers to Margaret’s brother Frederick and his exile, and Mrs. Thornton is shocked. She asks if he has ever visited Milton and Bell says no. Mrs. Thornton asks about the man at the rail station and Bell misidentifies him as Lennox. Thornton explains to Bell his relationship with Higgins. Thornton creates a cafeteria for his workers and consulted Higgins on the plan. Higgins helped him perfect the plan. Thornton has begun dining with his workers and forming relationships with them. Bell offers him money for the project but Thornton declines saying he does not want charity.
Mrs. Shaw is anxious to leave Milton. She does not like the town and feels it is making Margaret’s health worsen. Bell sends Margaret a letter outlining all the plans for liquidating the Hales’ assets in Milton. He tells her she will have his inheritance when he dies. Margaret keeps only her father’s books. She sends some to Bell and sends one to Thornton. Margaret wants to say goodbye to the Thorntons and the Higgins’s. Her aunt accompanies her. Mary gives her a cup that belonged to Bessy. Mrs. Thornton is kind to Margaret knowing she is leaving. Margaret apologizes to her about their last meeting. She exchanges a few words with Thornton, and he strains to keep his emotions hidden. Margaret visits Higgins last. He expresses his condolences for the loss of her father. Margaret gifts him Richard’s Bible and money for the children.
Margaret has plenty of leisure time on Harley Street, but she finds herself bored. Aunt Shaw spoils her with new clothes, but she is mostly excluded from the social engagements of the family. Margaret never interacts with members of the lower class and even the servants are hidden. Bell comes for a visit, and they meet with Lennox about his unsuccessful search for witnesses to support Frederick. Bell and Lennox have a private conversation where Lennox questions Richard’s decision to leave Helstone. He says the bishop offered Richard an alternative to leaving: “[T]hese country clergymen live such isolated lives-isolated, I mean, from all intercourse with men of equal cultivation with themselves” (517). Richard disagrees defending his friend’s choice, claiming Lennox does not know him at all.
Bell has a dream about Mr. and Maria as newlyweds. He thinks often of Helstone. Margaret and Bell meet with Lennox to close the case on Frederick. They conclude he is safe and happy in Spain. Bell invites Margaret to visit Helstone with him and Aunt Shaw agrees she can go.
Bell becomes an important figure in these chapters. A man of jovial wit, he brings a lightness to the narrative, but he is also a beloved friend and fierce ally to Hale. Bell is an educated Oxford gentleman, but he also owns property in Milton upon which factories are built. He fancies himself an academic but through his land ownership, his wealth paves the way for the expansion of industry. Gaskell uses the character of Bell to further draw the contrast between the North and the South. Having been a northerner first and now identifying himself as a southerner, Bell embodies a strong disdain for the Milton way of life. Bell is critical of Margaret’s views seeing her as too liberal and socialist, influences gained from living in the industrial capital. She stands rooted in her beliefs seeing them as the way of the future. Whereas Bell is committed to the old ways and mired in his classical literature and philosophy. Bell symbolizes the past and Margaret is an emblem of the future. Thornton labels himself a man of the present. He does not care for the stories of the past and has little time to ponder the future. The business of running the mill during a period of successive crises requires him to live focusing on the day to day.
Thornton’s love for Margaret has turned into emotional torture. Gaskell explores his self-awareness through his internal dialogue. He constantly reevaluates every choice he makes regarding Margaret. He is intent now on conquering his love. He is still living under the cloud of misunderstanding thinking Frederick is Margaret’s lover. Thornton also feels disoriented in the conversation between Bell and Hale. Their obscure literary and historical references are lost on him, and his frustration comes out as a poor attitude. Bell misunderstands him as a spoiled, rich man, but he is merely a man worn under the strain of work woes and unrequited love. While Thornton chafes under the strain of his broken relationship with Margaret, he grows in his respect and understanding for Higgins. Thornton’s idea for the cafeteria shows his growth as a person in that he truly desires to know his workers better. Higgins helps him make the idea a reality. Thornton even takes it a step further and begins to dine with the workers. Having meals together equalizes them and is a move in the direction of understanding that will lead to unity.
Margaret is the least understood of all the characters. Richard and Bell cannot understand her feelings for Thornton, and Edith fails to understand her lack of selfish vanity. In the days she spends alone, Margaret wrestles with the weight of all her decisions and cannot find peace in her solitude. Ironically, her brother’s exile has brought him great happiness in a fortuitous marriage. The lie Margaret told to save him has caused rifts in her relationships and weighed heavily on her conscience. Just as she is making peace with her decisions and enjoying a few days of rest, her father dies leaving her an orphan. The ensuing grapple for who will “get” Margaret exemplifies the Victorian ideal of women as property. Margaret has shown herself to be a strong, decisive woman, but after Richard’s death, Aunt Shaw and Bell treat her like a child. Though she did not follow the same path as Edith in gaining a husband and producing children, she has experienced tremendous personal growth during her time in Milton. Now, she undergoes a regression as she returns to Harley Street where her aunt dresses her up like a doll and mostly ignores her emotional well-being. Her procession of tearful goodbyes is symbolic of her leaving behind all the maturation and development she has made in her personal life. Aunt Shaw uproots her from Milton, forcing Margaret to sever all her friendships further compounding the grief of losing her parents.
In the Shaw-Lennox home, everything is the same as when she left it, but Margaret is a completely different person, and she sees with new eyes the workings of the home and the empty lives of the socialites. Harley Street feels like an alien world, so when Bell offers an opportunity to return to Helstone, she jumps at the chance to return to her home.
By Elizabeth Gaskell