logo

41 pages 1 hour read

Erica Armstrong Dunbar

Never Caught, the Story of Ona Judge: George and Martha Washington's Courageous Slave Who Dared to Run Away; Young Readers Edition

Nonfiction | Biography | Middle Grade | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 1-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 1 Summary: “America’s Daughter”

Content Warning: This guide includes references to slavery, racism, and physical violence and depictions of racist beliefs about Black people.

Ona Judge is born in 1773 to an enslaved woman named Betty and to Andrew Judge—a white, English indentured servant to George Washington. Betty is the property of Martha Washington’s first husband and, upon his death, becomes Martha’s property. Betty meets Andrew when Martha marries George. Both Andrew and Betty are seamstresses, but the nature of their relationship, including whether it is consensual, is unknown.

In June of 1773, Martha’s daughter from her first marriage, Patsy, dies of a seizure. Martha and George are devastated, and Betty likely tries to comfort Martha. Shortly after Patsy’s death, Betty gives birth to Ona.

Chapter 2 Summary: “Mount Vernon”

Ona grows up at Mount Vernon—the estate owned by George Washington. Before he became the country’s first president, George was known as a strong military leader, having fought in the French and Indian War in the 1750s. He spent much of his life expanding Mount Vernon, the farms of which grew tobacco, wheat, and flax and also had livestock. He also owned fisheries at the Potomac River and a distillery. Labor by enslaved people is necessary for the success of the estate; by the time of Ona’s birth in 1773, George owns more than 200 enslaved people.

Ona lives in a brick building near the Mount Vernon mansion called the Quarters, which is heated but has to be shared by all the servants that work in the mansion rather than in the fields. It is likely she that she is given chores such as gathering firewood or collecting vegetables. Ona does not attend school because it is illegal to educate enslaved people.

Chapter 3 Summary: “The New Country”

In 1775, George Washington becomes the commander of the Revolutionary Army, which fights the British for freedom. He leaves Mount Vernon and will be gone six years; Ona is two when he leaves. A relative, Lund Washington, runs the estate but is unskilled. Because the British offer freedom to any enslaved person who aligns with them, running away is tempting. When a British ship parks in the Potomac in view of Mount Vernon, 17 enslaved people take advantage and flee to it. Lund tries to barter with the ship’s captain, offering food in exchange for the return of the enslaved people, but the captain refuses.

When America declares its independence in 1776, George is away from Philadelphia still commanding the army. On October 17, 1781, the British surrender after the Battle of Yorktown. The enslaved people who escaped to England’s side are abandoned, and seven of those who escaped from Mount Vernon are returned and re-enslaved. The establishment of the new country is now underway, and the nation must decide how to establish laws that treat all states equally.

Chapter 4 Summary: “The List”

When she is 10, Ona is selected by Martha Washington to be her personal attendant. Martha notices that Ona is both intelligent and obedient; Betty begins teaching Ona to sew.

Meanwhile, George is involved in the establishment of the new government. When it is decided that the executive branch will have a single leader, George anticipates being wanted. He is nominated by the representatives of the 13 states and reluctantly accepts the position. Martha is angered that he chose a professional, public life over a private one and does not wish to move to New York. She makes a list of enslaved people who will accompany her; Ona’s name tops the list.

Chapter 5 Summary: “The First Trip North”

In May of 1789, Martha leaves Mount Vernon for New York. Among the enslaved people are Ona’s half-brother, Austin, and a 34-year-old woman named Moll who will care for the Washington grandchildren. Ona and Austin must leave Betty behind; Austin is also forced to leave his wife and child.

As they make stops along the way, Ona is expected to clean the dust from Martha’s riding dress and provide her with clean changes of clothing. They are scheduled to stay in Baltimore on the first night and then travel to Philadelphia for a five-night stay. All the enslaved people are eager to arrive in Philadelphia after hearing much about the city from George’s valet—an enslaved person named William Lee. Many free Black people reside there, including a woman named Margaret whom William met and fell in love with. Margaret agreed to move to Mount Vernon but never did, for reasons unknown.

Chapter 6 Summary: “A Short Stay in Philadelphia”

The crowded city is shocking to Ona, as is the fact that there are far more white people than she is accustomed to seeing at Mount Vernon. As Pennsylvania is a leader in the abolition movement, there are few enslaved people and a large population of free Black citizens.

This is due in part to the efforts of Benjamin Franklin, who late in life became a staunch abolitionist, and the presence of Quakers, who oppose slavery due to their belief in equality. The movement is also spurred by the efforts of a printer named Matthew Carey. In 1789, he prints a broadside depicting the conditions on slave ships to convey the inhumane conditions by which enslaved people are transported to the new country. Despite this strongly abolitionist atmosphere, Martha Washington holds tightly to her desire to keep enslaved people.

Chapter 7 Summary: “New York”

After the five days in Philadelphia, Martha and the rest of the family are taken by barge to New York harbor. The enslaved people follow behind a ferryboat. Upon arriving in New York, Ona sees that the population is much denser than in Virgina and that there are also white people who live in poverty and work as servants. New York is one of the remaining Northern states where slavery is still acceptable.

Chapter 8 Summary: “Surviving”

Ona’s role as Martha’s personal attendant is not only to keep her clothes tidy but also to regulate her moods while accompanying her. Martha, though unhappy to leave Mount Vernon, falls into a vigorous social life. George, however, suddenly falls ill with a fever and a leg tumor, which requires surgery. The family keeps his condition a secret, and he recovers a few months later. They then move to a larger house.

It is there that a famous meeting with Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and Alexander Hamilton takes place. They debate how to handle states’ war debts and disagree about moving the capital of the country further south. They finally compromise and make plans to establish a new capital nearer to Philadelphia on the Potomac. The move is delayed when George catches influenza, but he recovers.

Chapters 1-8 Analysis

The opening section addresses Ona’s youth, which parallels the establishment of the new nation and shows her status as property in American culture, highlighting Racial Injustice as Central to America’s Founding. The authors draw suppositions about what Ona’s life in this early time most likely is like, based on historical records. As the child of a seamstress, Ona is in some small regards fortunate to be spared from the harder, physical labor of farming that many enslaved people would be forced to engage in at Mount Vernon. But the narrative stresses that her being assigned to work in the mansion comes with the drawback of a lack of privacy: The house where the mansion’s enslaved people live—the Quarters—is crowded. Ona grows up constantly surrounded by people and without a quiet moment to herself. She is property and has no life of her own. Further, the authors stress that daily life is not easy for the enslaved who work indoors. They are still expected to be deferent to their enslavers and risk severe punishment if they disobey. As a personal attendant, Ona occupies a strange space in which she frequently appears in public—always at the side of Martha to ensure her clothes are tidy and to take care of any need that might arise—yet she must conduct her work in a manner that does not draw attention to herself. Because of her status as an enslaved person, it should seem as if Ona is not truly there, as if she were invisible. The authors stress that Ona must be particularly skilled in attending to Martha, as Martha keeps Ona in this position for such a great length of time.

This section also sets the stage for Ona’s later flight and demonstrates Severe Hardship as the Price of Freedom. The authors examine instances in which Ona is likely to be tempted with freedom in the speculation about her mindset and identity as an enslaved person. Though her reaction to the enslaved people fleeing onto the British ship is unknown, this is possibly an early seed of her hope for a life beyond slavery. Great emphasis is placed, too, on the certainty that Ona witnesses free Black people when she arrives in Philadelphia. This not only serves to demonstrate a different way of life for Ona but also highlights the difference between the post-Revolution northern states and southern states. Were she not hand-selected by Martha to move north, Ona’s future may have played out differently. Importantly, what little is known of Ona’s personal life and family is documented in this section. Knowing that she has a mother who loves her as well as a half-brother underscores Ona’s humanity, reminding readers of the injustices of slavery and the harsh realities of the way it frequently tore families apart. Additionally, the details about her mindset within slavery and historical escapes look forward to the sacrifices she is willing to make to obtain freedom later in the novel.

The actions of George Washington are important in that they come to affect Ona’s life, showing how an understanding of one figure is crucial to an understanding of the other. His drive to succeed and the vigor with which he continuously takes on new ventures in and around Mount Vernon paint him as an admirable person in keeping with the way history lauds him. However, the narrative also points out his flaws, including that he is not always extremely financially successful in his business ventures, nor is Mount Vernon as profitable as it could be. The narrative also reveals some reluctance on his part to enter into public life—a factor that serves to portray the Founding Father as fallible. His problematic thoughts on slavery are also hinted at in this section, which allows readers valuable evidence on which to judge his character. The narrative contains evidence, too, of the effective leadership skills George possesses, such as his willingness to compromise and to maintain an air of diplomacy when differing in political opinions from his peers. Likewise, the narrative draws a distinction between his public life and image and his personal and private life; he and Martha strive to keep the latter secret. These chapters offer a rounded depiction of George, and such a depiction is central to the aims of the novel. The authors wish to reexamine George’s character and legacy, showing his problematic thoughts on and behavior toward an ostensibly beloved enslaved person.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Erica Armstrong Dunbar