36 pages • 1 hour read
Lauren GroffA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Although this novel takes place in the Middle Ages—long before feminism existed as a movement—Marie is in many ways a feminist heroine. She comes from a family of “viragoes,” or fierce, opinionated women who take up the same amount of space that men do and relish traditionally male activities, such as going into battle (28). At the same time, she is softer and gentler than it is acceptable for a woman of her time and station to be. As a prioress and then an abbess, she treats the nuns around her with thoughtfulness and as individuals, rather than as an anonymous herd. Both her fierce side and her gentle side put her at odds with the male-dominated church and with the world outside the church.
The values of this church have to do not only with men’s superiority to women but also with the church’s superiority to earthly life. It offers an ascetic, self-sacrificing vision of spirituality that privileges “the Word” over the physical world (243). Those who enter the church, especially if they are women, are expected to renounce their individuality and to lead a deliberately spartan and uncomfortable existence. They are supposed to perform tasks that are difficult for them to increase their humility. Marie challenges these assumptions and in doing so makes the abbey more of a spiritual shelter. She gives the nuns tasks that suit their talents while also pushing them to do more demanding physical work. These tasks increase the nuns’ strength and confidence and give them a sense of mission and community: “A strange magic has befallen their bodies […] How swiftly the women have all been working, filled with radiance and conviction” (110). Marie also allows the nuns to take joy in their bodies and in their earthly surroundings by making the abbey an easier place to live. She expands the abbey’s grounds, harvests the lands, and allows a more varied diet for her nuns, using her own money to do so. She also allows discreet sexual encounters at the abbey and engages in such encounters herself.
The nature of Marie’s religious visions is also a feminist one. Her visions come from her body and her lived experience and often challenge traditional church doctrine. This is why Tilde burns the notebook in which Marie documented these visions after her death: “In Marie’s visions, Eve and the Virgin Mary share a kiss; god is a colossal dove hen laying the eggs of the world; Marie herself is a protector well above the power of any woman born to woman” (253). While the traditional church doctrine is one of dichotomies—between good and evil, divine life and earthly life, men and women—Marie’s vision is more holistic and unified. She sees life itself as innately holy and views goodness and wickedness as complementary qualities; this is why she is able to see Eve and the Virgin Mary—two figures who are traditionally set in opposition—as united.
As well as having a feminist heroine, Matrix can be seen to have a feminist plot. There are myriad conflicts and incidents in the novel, but it does not have the traditional—and, by extension, patriarchal—plot anchored by a single, overarching conflict, crisis, and resolution. There are, rather, many large and small conflicts, all of which receive equal weight in the novel. The changes in Marie as a character over the course of the novel, moreover, are subtle rather than dramatic. They are framed less as changes imposed from the outside than as realizations of Marie’s inward self. Although Marie inhabits a violent, conflicted world, the main drama in the novel comes not from her surroundings but from her spiritual evolution. External global events, such as religious wars and royal kidnappings, are peripheral in the novel, as are its male characters.
Marie’s visions and actions are often viewed as heretical, or against the church. Yet, they are also often divinely inspired, even if she breaks traditional rules. This breaking of rules makes many of her own nuns uneasy, as when she assumes the role of priest. She does so partly as a practical measure after a fire in the nearby town kills many church people. Yet, as she tells the subprioress Goda, she also feels perfectly suited for this role, because of and not in spite of her gender: “Marie says, Goda, do you not think the Virgin Mary, though born a mere woman, is the most precious jewel of any human born to a womb?” (184).
When Marie dies, many of the nuns and servants in the abbey are divided as to whether she is a saint or a witch. The same qualities that make her formidable to some make her frightening and unwomanly to others: “Awesome, terrifying, the great domina was. Holy, holy. A saint” (256). Marie is succeeded as abbess by the prioress Tilde, who has a different, more obedient temperament than Marie: “Tilde is not blessed with mystical sight |…]” (253). While Tilde knows Marie is not a witch, she is also skeptical of Marie’s mystical side and so disconcerted by the notebook documenting her religious visions that she decides to burn it. This destructive action makes her feel at once relieved and shaken: “|..] The new abbess, so good, so obedient, so deeply pious, only feels a terrible sort of dark and tarry joy spreading inside of her […] for she has never before known the profound pleasures of destruction” (254).
Marie struggles with the limits of her saintliness and feels guilt about the destruction that she sometimes causes in her efforts to do good. However, she is also aware of the frequent hypocrisy and bullying perpetrated by the male-dominated church hierarchy: “These people who think of themselves as her superiors, how foolish and unnecessarily cruel they always choose to be […] Thus does power corrode the mind and soul, she thinks” (230). She believes that any destruction that she causes is still less than that caused by the traditional hierarchy.
Marie’s mystical visions have a real-life counterpoint in the nun Gytha’s eccentric wall murals. Gytha is both mad and illiterate, but her paintings have a strange beauty. They fuse the divine and the real in a way that Marie’s church superiors would view as heretical if they were to see them. One of Gytha’s paintings presents Marie herself as Mary Magdelene, “Marie’s favorite saint […] the truer rock of the church” (114).
While Marie’s position at the abbey is a private and isolated one, it is also very public and political. She must constantly defend her position to her male superiors at the church, as well as to Queen Eleanor and the surrounding townspeople. She knows that as a woman in power, she is viewed with suspicion and must tread carefully: “Nuns already are suspect, unnatural, sisters to witches” (57). The church, moreover, is closely linked to royalty, with church officials having as much or more power than kings and queens. This is seen in the power of papal interdicts, as well as in the prevalence of crusades, or religious wars.
The papal interdict in the novel is the result of “a fight between the crown and Rome” and has a devastating impact on England: “There will be sorrow, horror, everywhere, and in all the cities the people will suffer, they cannot be confessed, they cannot take communion, the beloved dead will be left to rot […]” (230). Upon hearing about this decision, Marie resolves at first to keep it a secret from her nuns at the abbey. The interdict gives her a disgust for the machinations of church officials who are supposed to be pure and unworldly but cause so much worldly destruction. It also makes her view the crusades, which she herself took part in as a child, with an equal disgust: “Once she had thought a crusade the human fist of god. Now she knows it is shameful, born of arrogance and greed” (234).
To challenge such destructiveness, Marie must adopt some of the tactics of its instigators. She must learn to be duplicitous and to hold domineering church officials at bay: “[..] She must train her superiors in the community like dogs or falcons, with rewards, and slowly, so they don’t know they’re being trained” (56). She also must emulate Queen Eleanor and learn how to surround herself with a network of allies and spies. She must do this, in part, to face down the queen herself. Eleanor keeps her distance from Marie but keeps close tabs on her. She lets Marie know that she has a spy in the abbey, which may or may not be a bluff, since the spy’s identity is never revealed. She delicately chides Marie about overstepping her boundaries, whether by constructing a secret labyrinth for the abbey or burying a novice in unconsecrated ground. While Marie once felt awe and love for Eleanor, as an adult she grows to have more of a measured respect for her. She understands her to be nothing more and nothing less than a savvy political operator, “a great and subtle political mind” (189).
Marie must also occasionally use blunt force, and even go into battle, to defend her ground. In this way, she is more a political operator than her predecessor, the kindly but passive Emme. When Marie learns as prioress that many of the peasants on the abbey’s land failed to pay their rent, she resolves to confront them at their houses. It is her first aggressive act in her new position, and it has the desired effect; the peasants eventually pay, and many of them even respect their new prioress’s aggression: “For it is a deep and human truth that most souls upon the earth are not at ease unless they find themselves safe in the hands of a force far greater than themselves” (50).
By Lauren Groff
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
LGBTQ Literature
View Collection
Medieval Literature / Middle Ages
View Collection
National Book Awards Winners & Finalists
View Collection
Popular Study Guides
View Collection
Pride Month Reads
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection