44 pages • 1 hour read
Steve KlugerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Charlie begins his long train ride to his first military assignment and opens Joey’s letter containing the checklist of NYG baseball equipment from the Boston game where he first served as batboy. Charlie writes a response noting that all the other well-wishers had cried upon his departure: Hazel, Ida, and Carrie; however, Joey merely shook his hand and said, “Take care of yourself buddy” (259). This leads the ballplayer to suspect that Joey has some sort of plan that has not yet come to fruition. He includes a military anecdote, explaining that the train has one chow car for 800 soldiers; he had lined up for breakfast at 6:30 a.m., but lunch was being served by the time he reached the car. He coins a new military acronym: “SABUS (Screwed Again By Uncle Sam)” (260).
Mrs. Hicks provides a semester report for Joey, who once more has earned A’s in all academics, although now he has worked his way up to a B- in Obedience. She notes a change in her student, which she attributes to maturity, noting that he delivered the “Friends, Romans, Countrymen” speech from Julius Caesar with great feeling and poise. She notes that Joey and Rachel “cannot keep their eyes of one another” (261).
Joey writes to Charlie requesting further relationship advice regarding Rebecca, and he receives a response delineating which colors are appropriate to use in complimentary similes written about Rachael. The color white is recommended, as the ballplayer notes that this is reminiscent of “[c]louds, stars, the moon and that bubble crap that comes on top of waves” (265).Joey also notes that he sneaked into the Brooklyn Navy Yard and “was on the assembly line for 45 minutes before [he] got the boot” (264).In return, Charlie provides further advice regarding relationships with girls, suggesting that Hazel pick the movie which Joey and Rachel plan to see together, adding: “Mr. Moto and Confessions of a Nazi Spy and etc. will not do the trick” (265).
Midsemester break is greeted with another composition assignment from Mrs. Hicks, this one describing “How I Spent Spring Vacation,” a topic selected by the Board of Education. Craig Nakamura writes Joey describing his experience in an internment camp due to suspicion of all Japanese-American citizens. He notes the loss of all family valuables as well as a hotel formerly owned by his aunt and uncle. He and his mother have been separated from his father and uncle and are housed in a racetrack horse stall which has not been cleaned of droppings. He asks whether Charlie Banks might be willing to try to get the family released. A letter replying to a request for assistance from Press Secretary Stephen Early does not produce the desired outcome for Joey; Early notes that “only history can judge whether we have made a fitting choice or a regrettable mistake” (274) with regard to the camps.
Charlie’s suspicions about Joey hatching a plan prove to be correct: the boy hides under duffel bags in a transport vehicle in the Brooklyn Navy Yard and does not emerge until reaching Camp Pendleton in California. Upon his apprehension, he will only provide his name, rank, and serial number, and he asks to see Charlie Banks and Stuke immediately. While awaiting their arrival in Col. Patton’s office, Joey is heard calling the officer a “biscuithead” (278) with regard to military decisions made in the Pacific. The ballplayers are given 72 hours leave to show Joey around Hollywood and ensure his departure, and Charlie describes all the entertainment in a letter to Hazel. He also expresses a begrudging admiration for Joey’s ingenuity in travelling to California and regales Ida and Carrie with the story of Joey playing the sax on stage with Louis Armstrong. While Charlie is not successful in achieving the Nakamura’s release from camp, he and Joey are able to convince administrators to reunite the family.
The star struck first baseman, Stuke, convinces famed actress Veronica Lake to let him take her out on a date, mentioning that he will ship out in 36 hours; to his amazement, she accepts, and allows him to kiss her. This section ends with a War Bulletin reporting that U.S. planes have bombed five Japanese cities.
Hazel (McKay) Banks writes Charlie about how much she misses him, her increasingly successful singing career, and her ongoing game of one-upmanship with singer Ethel Merman. Joey sings duets with her regularly at the supper club, and the famed songwriter Cole Porter promises to write a number specifically for her. In War news, a newspaper article announces the Japanese victory at Corregidor, where 42,000 American and Philippine soldiers are captured. The 2nd Division of Marines, to which the ballplayers are assigned, receive notification that they are shipping out to the Pacific. Stuke, who becomes increasingly communicative with Joey, assures the boy that he will protect Charlie. Charlie also writes a reassuring letter to a plaintive Joey and devises a scheme to navigate the censors who read all mail. He will advise of his location by composing a second sentence in the letter, where the first letter of each word will be combined to alert the boy of his location. With regard to the budding romance with Rachel, Charlie advises that she has Joey “on a string like a yo-yo” (316).In the interim, Charlie is selling the macaroons—“the pointy coconut things” (316)—that Aunt Carrie sends him regularly to his shipmates. In an exchange with his new bride, Hazel, Charlie alludes to the singer having brought Joey to Radio City for his 14th birthday.
Joey’s adoration for Rachel has only grown stronger; he writes her a letter letting her know that he loves her. She agrees to come to the Canteen to see him perform with Hazel, and afterwards, the two kiss for the first time. Joey writes to Charlie asking him to be the Best Man at their wedding, which he would like to hold at third base at the Polo Grounds. He also tries to sneak into the Naval Yard assembly line again; Hazel agrees to appear on the cover of Time magazine dressed as a female riveter in exchange for Joey emerging from this plan unscathed. In an ironic twist, Joey’s former nemesis, Lenny Bierman, pays Joey “two bits a week” (331) to complete his algebra homework for him.
Charlie is upset by President Roosevelt’s order that no “All-Stars” are to see direct action, as “Washington does not want any dead All-Stars on their hands […] it screws up newsreels” (326). This missive results in Charlie being assigned to the Communications Room as a typist. In a coded letter, Charlie advises that he is now in Guadalcanal, and he writes a joyful yet solemn reflection of the experiences that the two have shared. Finally, the ballplayer relates the true story of his family history. Charlie’s mother died when he was 2 years old; his father was a “cheap hood” (332) who died in a shootout in Wisconsin. A few days prior to his death, he used a baseball bat to assault Charlie, who was playing with his father’s pen knife, but Harlan intervened. Charlie writes: “It wasn’t a pitch that killed him, it was my father” (334). Charlie has never shared this information with anyone else.
Hazel ultimately receives a telegram advising her that Charlie was killed in action. As Stuke relates to Joey, Charlie was ordered to remain on the ship. Upon seeing Stuke and seven other Marines pinned down on the beach by enemy fire, he defied orders by running up the beach to help defend their position, and subsequently, he saved all the men involved. Prior to being shot himself, he asks Stuke never to relate the story to Joey. He was afraid that the boy would follow his example. Craig Nakamura writes Joey that he will come to Brooklyn to console him, even if he has to travel by foot. Rabbi Lieberman writes that the Temple will say Kaddish, a traditional Jewish prayer for the dead, in memory of the late Protestant ballplayer, and the dreaded Ethel Merman sends a condolence telegram to Hazel and visits her for tea. Aunt Carrie, who is attached to her Jewish faith, reads a Bible passage announcing:“Christ shall be magnified in my body, whether it be by life or by death” (344). Charlie is laid to rest in his hometown of Racine, Wisconsin. Joey is given a letter that was written to him by Charlie in the event he was killed, itemizing: “[A] couple more things you need to know before you’re ready to do the rest without me” (346).Among the observations are the thought that all people have some worthwhile element, and that in some way, Charlie will always be able to see Joey’s future accomplishment. Finally, he tells Joey: “A long time ago I told you I did not know for a fact yet that you were somebody special. Now I do. […] I love you Bucko” (346).
The author switches to the first person in the Epilogue, and the setting is moved to August 2, 1977, which would have been Charlie Banks’ 60th birthday. Joey Margolis, sportswriter and author, is scheduled to speak at Charlie Banks Day, along with the President of the United States and the Governor of Wisconsin. The proceeds of this game will fund a college scholarship in the ballplayer’s honor. Joey has found events such as this to be too painful to attend in the past; however, his own 9-year-old son, Chucky, persuades him to appear. While preparing his speech, Joey finally opens a metal box containing Charlie’s military medals and realizes that the ballplayer had saved all the childhood letters that he had written as a young boy. Charlie had also carried a photo of himself and Joey at a ballpark in Cincinnati in his wallet.
Hazel is married to a wealthy Manhattan architect and continues to sing. She and Ethel Merman have made peace and appear on television singing duets. Stuke is a Philosophy professor at a small college in New Hampshire. Aunt Carrie Gettinger has died, and Joey’s 88-year-old mother insists on doing her own cleaning, despite the fact that he has provided her with a housekeeper. Craig Nakamura is a Civil Liberties attorney in San Francisco. Charlie and his grammar school sweetheart, Rachel, are raising their three children in a brownstone not far from their old neighborhood. Joey’s biological father has died recently, and the writer notes: “I lost my Dad in 1936. But I got a much better deal all the way around” (353).Joey is a confirmed Brooklynite and advises the reader that “Brooklyn was-and still is-about Charlie” (353).
The final section of the book depicts the maturation and evolution of the characters, particularly Charlie and Joey. While the former retains much of the sarcastic irreverence that has characterized all his communications thus far, he becomes more stereotypically paternal in his interaction with Joey. Joey, who is now 14 years old, blossoms under the masculine tutelage that he has received and seeks advice regarding ways to proceed in his relationship with his beloved Rachel. The author takes a more somber approach when he relates the internment of the Nakamuras after their move to California. Craig documents the events leading to the separation of his father and uncle from the family as well as the economic inequities they have suffered and the squalid conditions they endure. Joey, always possessed of an innate sense of integrity and justice, receives a missive from the normally unflappable White House Press Secretary regarding the internment camps. He ruminates that the Administration will be judged by history for its actions but notes that the Nakamuras might have faced more dangerous conditions outside the camp due to anti-Japanese sentiment among Americans.
Charlie is an unlikely military hero who spends the vast quantity of his enlistment composing insulting acronyms about his superior officers. He often appears gruff, unpolished, and irreligious; nonetheless, he dies a hero while saving the lives of seven other soldiers. In a somewhat prescient manner, he divulges the true details of his brother Harlan’s death in the last letter that he writes. Harlan died saving Charlie from an assault by his abusive father, and Charlie has never shared this story with anyone else. The nature of Charlie’s nurturance of Joey is a replication of Harlan’s care for Charlie as a child. While Charlie is an atypical hero, he embodies all the necessary characteristics: self-sacrifice and recognition of the validity of dying for a cause more important than the happiness of an individual.
The themes of true religiosity and universality appear in the description of the aftermath of Charlie’s death. Long-time competitors Ethel Merman and Hazel share a cup of tea after his passing, and traditional Jewish prayers for the dead are said in Charlie’s name at the temple where he blessed Joey at his bar mitzvah. Beneath his cynical exterior, the ballplayer extols idealistic precepts to Joey and advises him to seek something good in all people. In reminding Joey that he will always be there on some level to see his future accomplishments, he provides Joey with the same sense of security that Harlan provided for him and demonstrates the true impact of a hero upon the life of a fatherless boy.