43 pages • 1 hour read
Christina Diaz GonzalezA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Miguel continues narrating the events of the story. In the morning, Dayara asked Miguel if she could copy his homework, and when he said she should do it herself, she grabbed his book and several illustrations fell out. Miguel felt embarrassed when Dayara complimented his artwork, but he felt frustrated by the knowledge that his father would be disappointed if he chose to pursue art instead of baseball. While picking up litter outside, Miguel and Dayara spotted the same little girl as yesterday standing outside the fence. She was holding a doll and looked distraught. Miguel introduced himself and found out that the girl’s name was Lisa. She pointed to a van and announced that she and her mother lived there, but then suddenly remembered that she was supposed to keep that fact a secret. Just then, Lisa’s mother came over and called her away. Miguel, Dayara, and Sara realized that the two were living in the van, and Miguel vowed to find a way to help them.
In the present moment, Dayara steps in to add that Miguel was not the only one who wanted to help the mother and daughter, and that she was the one to suggest doing something to help. On that day, they filled George in on the conversation with Lisa, and Nico yelled at the group to watch out for Mrs. Grouser, who was glaring at them in the distance. Dayara recalls that after school that day, she went to see her mother at work at the auto shop and then struggled to complete her homework, which was all in English and appeared as a scramble of words on the page. In a montage of moment-by-moment scenes, Dayara slowly slumped over her homework in sheer frustration and exhaustion. When her mother asked what English she learned that day, Dayara internally recalled the phrases, “Problem kid, Late to class, Late homework, Graduate late” (74), all of which she understood as phrases that labeled her as someone bound to fail. Not wanting to cause her mother stress, Dayara refrained from telling her about her struggles in school. Dayara’s papi then called to say that he would be home late from work at the airport.
The students continue to tell their story to the interviewer and relate that the next day, the group arrived at the field to find Lisa and her mother still living in the van on the other side of the fence. They approached and Lisa seemed happy to see them, screaming about having a tea party. Miguel gave her a dress for her doll and George shyly asked Lisa’s mother whether she needed help. When Dayara asked in Spanish if the two were living in the van, the woman reacted defensively and denied it at first, but she softened enough to admit that her situation was only temporary until she could find a job. She asked the kids not to tell anyone. The mother noted that she and her daughter were “pretty much invisible” (83) anyway. With a dark shadow across her face, Sara put her hand up on the fence and admitted that she could relate to that feeling. George offered to bring the woman and her daughter breakfast the next morning, and she looked at him with deep gratitude in her eyes.
The next day, the kids went to the cafeteria as usual, but this time, they took a few of the leftovers to give to Lisa and her mother. They were careful not to let Mrs. Grouser notice. They took the food outside and gave it away, but when Sara revealed two brand-new juice boxes, George questioned whether Sara stole them. In the present moment, Sara interrupts the children’s story to declare that she left some money for the juice boxes and didn’t just steal them. The interviewer encourages Sara to tell her side of the story.
Sara continues the narrative, recalling how she enjoyed the feeling she got from impressing Dayara when Dayara thought she stole the juice boxes. She hoped that the incident would let them become friends. George gave Lisa an old coloring book, and Sara watched as Dayara helped her read the letters inside it, surprised at how nice she was being. When Dayara mixed up “b” and “d,” the other kids laughed at her, but Sara just looked sad. Nico challenged Dayara, who insisted that she could spell perfectly well in Spanish, and proved it. Mrs. Grouser suddenly appeared and yelled at the kids, questioning what they were doing and where the food came from. When she found out that the food was from the cafeteria leftovers, she threatened to tell the principal and call the police. George managed to talk their way out of trouble for the moment, but they were left with the threat of being watched even more closely than before.
Afterward, Nico blamed Sara for what happened, but Dayara reminded her to stay strong in the face of criticism. When Sara overheard George saying that working with her was a terrible way to spend a morning, she took Dayara’s inspiration and used it to tell George that he was a “jerk” for saying that. George chased after her and apologized, and they agreed to be friends. Sara admitted that she is a high honors student, and when George warned her to avoid acting like Dayara and referenced her supposed theft of the juice boxes, Sara tried to tell him that she didn’t steal them. However, George became distracted by some friends and didn’t hear her. After school that day, Sara stopped at the grocery store to make her papi’s favorite meal. She and her papi came to America to find new opportunities, leaving Sara’s mother and brothers behind in Mexico. That night, Sara’s papi told her that he has planned for the whole family to stay in the United States. Sara was happy to hear that she would get to see her mother and brothers again soon.
As the plot progresses and the characters’ lives become more intertwined, the author branches out and provides a glimpse into the lives and challenges of Dayara and Sara, in addition to delving into the central conflict of Lisa and her mother’s predicament: the motive force that inspires the students to overcome their many differences and work together, thereby developing the theme of Kindness Inspired by Adversity. As the students continue to interact with both mother and daughter, it is also clear that Lisa, the little girl, seems eager for socialization and support, while her mother, on the other hand, is more reluctant to reach out. While the novel does not overtly state the underlying issue, this moment of dialogue implies the possibility of child services becoming involved should they discover that she is living in a van with her daughter.
In the artist’s depiction, it is also significant that both mother and daughter are drawn standing beyond the chain-link fence, rendering the scene symbolic of the many ways in which poverty cages and obscures people from society’s awareness and opportunities. Thus, the scene speaks to the title of the novel itself, for Celeste feels unseen, as though people fail to see her struggles or make any effort to help her; she is thus grateful for the support she gets from the students, who are just like her in their experience of feeling invisible and misunderstood in a largely inaccessible world that was not built to respect or understand them.
George in particular understands Celeste’s desire to hide her poverty from view, for he also struggles with shame and humiliation, immersed in the pressure to hide parts of himself in order to maintain a certain reputation. Thus, all the children use Kindness Inspired by Adversity as a motivation to help both mother and daughter.
In her quest to make the invisible visible, Gonzales devotes extensive time and care to allowing each character a “voice” in the larger narrative, for they all get an opportunity to share their side of the story, their experiences of adversity, and the pressures and expectations that loom over them. Thus, the novel highlights the importance of Individual Identity and Group Solidarity, for as the children grow closer together in their joint quest to help the struggling family, they also find new ways to celebrate their own individual identities. This becomes a core principle within the novel, and it is most clearly demonstrated when each student is given ample chances to speak and communicate their inner thoughts and experiences. Likewise, the students’ individual problems are designed to highlight the Unseen Pressures on the Children of Immigrant Families. For example, the author reveals that Dayara’s struggles at school are not a result of indifference or laziness, but rather are caused by her ongoing difficulties in learning English. This unfamiliar language is like a maze for her, and it serves as a significant barrier to her success in the school environment. This issue is compounded by the unspoken pressure she feels from her family to succeed, for she avoids telling her mother about her academic struggles so as not to disappoint or worry her.
Like Dayara, Sara’s own home life is complex as well, and she also faces pressure from her parents to do well in school and learn English. Both Dayara and Sara have a secret desire to make friends, and they eventually find friendship with one another. It is also noteworthy that Dayara helps Sara to find her voice by telling her, “Sara, don’t let that guy make you feel bad. You have to be strong” (103). Sara also shows herself to be mature beyond her years, taking up a motherly role in her mother’s absence and achieving honors at school but never boasting about it. Both girls show depth and layers beyond the surface of their public personas, and both feel frustrated by the judgments and misunderstandings of others.
As each character takes their turn narrating the story, subtle shifts in the coloring of the artwork are employed to differentiate between different settings and to emphasize the unique lives and personalities of the students. For example, the scenes in Dayara’s life are filled with gray, as though her world is clouded over, while the backgrounds depicting Sara’s home life sprout with color, as though nothing brings her more joy than being with her papi. A great deal of unspoken information is also conveyed through the artist’s depictions of the characters’ eyes and body language. When Nico tells Sara, “This is your fault. Things turn out better when you don’t’ speak” (102), his nose is upturned and his eyebrows thicken and darken as he looks down at Sara. Likewise, when Dayara struggles to remember the difference between the lower-case b and d, a close-up illustration shows the lines in her face as she tenses up, and a drop of sweat as she strains to recall the correct information. When Miguel corrects her mistake, a dark shadow is drawn over her eyes—another classic anime-style technique for depicting a darker mood—and her face turns bright red as she feels embarrassed and angry. In order to fully grasp the nuances of the characters’ internal emotional experiences, it is necessary to take careful note of these subtle expressions.
By Christina Diaz Gonzalez