41 pages • 1 hour read
De'Shawn Charles WinslowA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Early the next morning, Knot arrives at the Lovings’ house and, unusually for her, knocks. Otis Lee answers. Agitated, Knot demands to see him and Pep together at once. Otis Lee tries to calm her down, and she tells him what she heard from Fran: that Pep told Fran, Eunice, and Breezy that Knot is Fran and Eunice’s mother on the night that she found them fighting in her yard. Thinking Otis Lee was in on the secret, Knot confronts him for never telling her. Before Otis Lee has a chance to explain that he never knew, Pep appears and explains that her responsibility to do what is best for Breezy outweighed her promise to keep Knot’s secret, and that Knot gave up her rights to manage her children’s lives when she gave them away. As Knot leaves, Pep calls out, “They’s more to worry ‘bout in life than drinkin’ and readin’ them damn books” (174).
During this exchange, Pep refers to Knot as “yo’ friend” in a way that makes Otis Lee wonder whether he has been too attentive to Knot, whom he thinks of as a sister. A few minutes later, during breakfast, he offers to “forgive” Pep for keeping her actions secret from him, but she suggests he is the one who needs forgiveness for caring more about Essie and Knot that his wife and son.
Recognizing the truth in Pep’s parting words, Knot considers burning her books and liquor but can’t imagine giving up the comfort they provide. She cleans herself up and goes to visit Eunice at the apartment above the Mannings’ store where she lives with Breezy. On her way up the steps, she encounters Breezy, who discourages her from talking with Eunice about the past since “it might bring on trouble” (180).
In January 1966, Otis Lee visits Fran and Cedar. From his glances, Fran guesses that he suspects she is pregnant from her ongoing affair with Breezy, which she confirms. Fran expresses her surprise that Pep, who already knew, didn’t tell him. Otis Lee hurries home to confront Pep for keeping another secret.
Hoping to save Fran from heartache, Otis Lee asks Knot to talk Fran into giving up on Breezy; she refuses.
In June 1966, Fran gives birth to Lady Sequoia “Coy” Loving. Knot puts off visiting her for a few weeks until Fran and her children pay her a visit. Knot shows her a new room recently added to her house. Originally, Clara Pennington, Riley’s grandson, came up with the idea to add a room while she was buying pies from Knot, but Knot declined her offer to build it for free. Instead, she hired Valley and a few other men to build it.
While Cedar practices spelling, Knot asks Fran whether she intends to have any more children with Breezy. Fran responds that she might and threatens to leave if Knot lectures her. Angry, Knot responds that she doesn’t care what Fran does. Fran hints that Breezy has a reason for marrying Eunice. She mentions Otis Lee, who had to cut back on work after his health declined, and Pep, whose services as a midwife cannot compete with modern medical advances. Fran says that she gave Breezy permission to marry Eunice so that he could have the money to support his family, suggesting that their marriage “ain’t hittin’ on nothin’” (194). Knot worries for Eunice.
In 1975, Otis Lee and Pep watch a newscaster discuss the recently ended Vietnam War on their television, which they received as a gift from Breezy four months earlier. They are surprised by a knock on the door, which Otis Lee answers. He sees two young women that look vaguely familiar. They introduce themselves as Vera and Vic, Pleasant’s daughters and Otis Lee’s nieces. Vera comes in, and Vic goes to get a surprise, which turns out to be Pratt. He and Otis Lee hug “like long-lost brothers” (198). They go for a walk to Pleasant’s old house, which Vera and Vic intend to demolish before selling the property. Pratt tells Otis Lee that, after his military service, he lived a normal life, entering into a childless marriage that ended after 15 years. When he asks about Knot, Otis Lee tells him that she never married but admits that she “sorta” has children (200). Pratt goes to visit Knot, and Otis Lee wonders how she will respond. He returns to the Lovings’ home the next morning, apparently unaware that Knot gave birth to his daughter.
Otis Lee wakes up in the middle of the night to hear Pep praying for forgiveness. She explains that she wrote the note telling Knot’s parents that Knot had a baby and paid Milton Guppy to deliver it.
These chapters investigate the limits of social responsibility in various situations. Otis Lee ponders whether, as Pep suggests, he swapped friends and family on his priority list. After deepening her relationship with Fran, Knot wonders what she owes to Eunice. She also considers the impact of her drinking on her relationships. Otis Lee and Knot both feel an obligation to resolve the ongoing tensions between Fran and Eunice, though neither knows how to proceed. Taken together, these variations on a theme all share a fundamental concern with defining responsibility to others and translating that responsibility into meaningful action.
These chapters also highlight the significance of West Mills as a setting. When Pratt returns after more than 30 years away, he is struck by how little the town has changed, to which Otis Lee replies, “You in West Mills” (201), echoing the novel’s title. The town’s immutability mirrors its inhabitants, many of whom appear to be set in their ways. Knot still lives alone in her small house and spends much of her time with the same few people and activities. But even as Pratt wonders whether his relationship with Knot can return to what it was—or be even better—Pep’s confession shows that change and remorse are constantly at work, however subtly, even in West Mills.