logo

48 pages 1 hour read

Beatriz Williams

Husbands & Lovers

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Power of Maternal Love

Content warning: This section of the guide discusses antisemitism, rape, and child loss.

The overwhelming strength of a mother’s love for her child(ren) is demonstrated by Mallory and Hannah’s experiences throughout the text.

When Mallory learns that she is pregnant, she has no way of knowing whether her baby’s father is Monk, the man she loves, or his father, the man who drugged and raped her, but this uncertainty in no way impacts her love for Sam. Neither Sam nor anyone else in Mallory’s life even guesses at her confusion on this point because Mallory is such a dedicated mother. The phone call when she learns that Sam has eaten a poisonous mushroom “changed [her] life” (3), and she rushes to New Hampshire, afraid to pause or stop lest Sam die and she’s not there. She considers Sam her “shining, beautiful boy” (7), untainted by his mother’s personal trauma. For years, Mallory drives him to regular dialysis appointments and monitors his fluid intake so as not to overtax his system. She never regrets Sam’s birth but feels that her “mistake was not giving [him] a real dad” (42). However, even Sam knows Mallory “did the best [she] could” (209). Mallory puts her son first, allowing him his privacy and encouraging him to be open to Monk’s overtures. Her love for him is the strongest feeling that she has, reinforcing the novel’s message about its power.

Hannah’s love for her children also transcends every other consideration in her life. After Jànos goes to war, Hannah is left alone to care for Mìklos and Lèna. Despite her care, they all contract typhoid fever. She says, “Sometimes I think, if I had only found more to eat. They would have been stronger, they would have survived it” (356). She was their sole caregiver then, and she faults herself for their deaths, despite her own illness. After the Soviets invaded their home, killing Jànos and stealing their baby, Kàroly, Hannah was prepared to “go back into the house and burn to death in [her] husband’s arms” (408). Without Kàroly, she’d prefer death. Later, after the theft of her daughter, Lucile, at the convent in Ireland, Mother Bernadette says, “you should have heard that poor mother screaming for her child” (340). This reinforces the centrality of her children to her life. Ultimately, Hannah loves her daughter so deeply that she gives up her cobra bracelet, a gift to her from her beloved Lucien, so that Lucile might one day know her and know where she came from. Although Mallory and Paige’s mom seems never to have uncovered the bracelet’s secret, they do, and they reconnect with Kàroly as a result. Hannah’s powerful maternal love makes this possible, and the ending therefore conveys that maternal love is a positive force.

The Deceptiveness of Appearances

Several characters, in addition to the gold cobra bracelet, illustrate how deceptive appearances can be, in both good and bad ways. Lucien and Hannah hide their religious and cultural identities in an era and political setting in which revealing them could be dangerous. Lucien conceals his family’s Jewish history so that he can protect his mother and work as an Israeli intelligence operative without arousing suspicion. After he introduces Hannah to his mother and reveals this history to her, he says, “It’s not something you go about proclaiming, these days” (293). Hannah is quite familiar with this feeling, as she chose to hide her own background for the same reasons. During the war, despite Jànos’s opinion that she would be safe in their home in the country, Hannah thinks, “Don’t you understand, there is nowhere safe on this earth” (398). Her father was deported to an extermination camp for being a Jew, and Hannah knows that a similar fate could befall her. This is implicitly the reason why she makes the decision, after the war and the demise of her family, to conceal her background and marry Alistair, who knows nothing of her past and has no interest in it. When Hannah tells him that she’s pregnant, he knows it’s Lucien’s baby and already knows that Lucien’s family is Jewish, musing about how upset his father would be to think of “Jew blood in the ancient family line” (395). Alistair exhibits similar bigotry throughout the text, which fuels Hannah’s motivation to keep her background a secret. This subplot therefore suggests that oppression forces people into deceiving others by keeping up appearances.

The most significant and symbolic object in the text, the cobra bracelet, reveals how deceptive appearances can be. What looks like a detailed and lovely, if unusual, piece of jewelry possesses a hidden compartment that can be used to conceal messages. Even the shape it takes reflects the thematic idea that appearances should not be taken at face value, as cobras can remain hidden until they strike. An area might look safe, allowing a person to relax, until the animal “crawl[s] directly into your house or tent or trouser leg, so you’d bloody well better watch your step” (19), according to Alistair. This is, of course, what happens when Hannah is bitten.

For his part, Alistair’s appearance is deceptive as well, like Mr. Adams’s, and both men manipulate others under the guise of being something they are not. Alistair may seem doddering and oafish, but he is smart enough to figure out that Hannah is having an affair and to have Lucien investigated in secret. He relishes telling Hannah what he’s learned, suggesting “smug[ly]” that Lucien won’t be around long enough to cause any trouble for him and “smil[ing] at [Hannah’s] shock” when he reveals what he knows (395). Likewise, Monk’s father works hard to ingratiate himself with Mallory, sharing her work with colleagues and asking her to “think of [him] like a godfather” (308). He gains her trust enough that she never suspects the lengths to which he would go to prevent his son from squandering his “Adams” privilege. He assures her that they are “[o]n the same team” (306), and then he drugs and rapes her when she doesn’t do as he wants. His fatherly guise disappears when Mallory refuses his wishes, revealing a calculating and Machiavellian manipulator.

Female Perseverance and Strength

The female characters suffer myriad personal traumas, and they consistently find the strength to persevere despite their physical pain, emotional suffering, and loss of loved ones and sense of safety. Williams therefore suggests that women through the centuries survive trauma and violence, and the text offers an homage to the often-overlooked stories of those who persevere.

Mallory is raped, violated, and deprived of her future with Monk by his father, and yet she endures pregnancy and motherhood, and even thrives as an adult. She is compelled to “[g]o on living and loving, don’t let it define you. Don’t let it beat you” (494-495). Mallory comes to terms with her rapist’s fault—his failure to act as he should have—to blame him for what happened rather than herself. Further, she does go on “living and loving,” refusing to allow Mr. Adams’s views of art to inform her own and isolating his identity from Sam’s so that it does not impact her relationship with her son.

Hannah also endures sexual violence after she’s captured by the Soviets, and she had already endured so much loss before this. Her children die of typhoid, and she believes her husband is dead. Later, her father is sent to a death camp, and Jànos is shot before her. Her infant son is stolen from his crib. Still, she doesn’t waste away or dissolve into guilt or bitterness and inaction. Instead, she goes to Budapest “[t]o kill as many of them as [she] could. Nazis and Soviets, [she] didn’t care” (408). She finds ways to deal with the violations of her body and mind, and, like Mallory, Hannah finds the strength to love again and risk her heart anew. After Lucien dies saving her from the Cairo fire and her baby girl is stolen from her, Hannah rededicates herself to protecting Hungary from Soviet rule, going back to her home to engage in dangerous, life-threatening work.

The women in the novel repeatedly find ways to manage their pain and recover from their losses, notably being brave enough to open their hearts to love again. Even Mallory’s sister, Paige, manages the betrayal she feels after her husband’s infidelity by throwing herself into learning her family history. Time and again, these female characters prove how strong women can be both in terms of what they survive and how they choose to live again.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text