logo

48 pages 1 hour read

Beatriz Williams

Husbands & Lovers

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 19-24Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 19 Summary: “Hannah. January 1952. Cairo, Egypt”

A porter gives Hannah a package. She pockets it and goes up to her flat. Alistair is in the bath, and she informs him that she’s pregnant, implying that the baby is his. He knows that she’s been sleeping with Lucien, and he points out that Lucien is only interested in women who can pass him information. For this reason, Alistair had Lucien investigated and learned that he is part Jewish and an Israeli intelligence agent. Hannah recalls the baby that she had with Jànos about a year after his fever broke, a boy called Kàroly. One morning, Jànos told her that he received news that Hannah’s father was deported to a death camp, like many other Hungarian Jews. Jànos believes that Hannah will be safe in the countryside. As a Jew, however, Hannah believes that there is literally nowhere safe for her on earth.

Now, Hannah gets into a taxi, opens the package, and finds the gold cobra bracelet. At the hotel, she goes to Lucien’s rooms. They are “too tidy,” and she finds the closet and bathroom empty. Hannah remembers one “golden afternoon” with Kàroly, the day Jànos told her that the Soviets had crossed the border. He told her to pack and that he would drive her as far as he could in the morning. While reliving these memories, Hannah falls asleep. Suddenly, Lucien returns and wakes Hannah, and she asks if he would leave her without saying goodbye. Lucien touches the bracelet and says that he did say goodbye. She wishes that he’d told her he was a spy, but he claims that he did. She recalls meeting his mother, learning that she was Jewish, and Lucien saying that “[i]t’s not something you go about advertising these days. Only to people you trust” (405). Hannah realizes that he was truthful with her, though she never was with him. Quickly, she tells him about Jànos, the typhoid that killed Mìklos and Lèna, the birth of Kàroly, how Soviet soldiers broke into their home, beat Hannah, shot Jànos, stole the baby, and burned the house. Then she traveled to Budapest to kill Nazis and Soviets, but she was arrested by the Soviet counterintelligence squad. Hannah says that their interrogation “methods” are “even worse” for women than for men, and she had to separate her mind from her body to survive (408). The night Berlin fell, her captors got drunk, and she escaped. Finally, Lucien says that he must get his mother out of Egypt. He doesn’t want to leave Hannah, but Hannah says that she won’t leave Alistair and run away with Lucien, because Lucien isn’t cut out for fatherhood. At his insistence, she admits that she loves him.

Chapter 20 Summary: “Mallory. July 2022. Winthrop Island, New York”

Mallory goes running, and when she returns, she overhears Lee reprimanding Grace for not knowing the difference between instant oatmeal and overnight oats. Grace apologizes, but Lee continues yelling, saying that she’ll type up directions next time “with every last fucking detail highlighted” so that Grace can’t “screw up” again (414). Mallory confronts Lee, who cries. Monk finds Mallory packing her things, and he asks what happened with Lee. He wants to talk now, asking what he did to make Mallory leave and keep his son a secret. Mallory leaves Monk’s questions unanswered, and she, Paige, and the kids go to Lola’s house. Sedge asks Mallory for a walk on the beach, and they kiss. As he unbuttons her shirt, Monk shows up, holding flowers. She goes after him, and he tells her that Grace quit. Apparently, Lee behaved badly before, but Grace didn’t tell him because she didn’t want to hurt his feelings. He talks about “ersatz coffee,” a drink used as a replacement for coffee during World War II. It tasted terrible but people drank it because they needed something. He says that he’s not unhappy, and he’s thrilled to have a son and know that something “real” came out of the summer he spent with Mallory. Mallory returns to Lola’s, and Paige tells Mallory to let Monk go and give Sedge a chance. Mallory wakes up the next morning with Sedge in the other bunk, but he insists that they didn’t sleep together. Mallory’s phone rings, and she learns that Sam has a kidney donor.

Chapter 21 Summary: “Lucien. January 1952. The highway outside Cairo, Egypt”

Lucien puts his mother on a ship to Israel but returns to Cairo. He can see smoke rising from the city, and he pounds on the Ainsworths’ door. Alistair answers, refusing to tell Lucien where Hannah is. When Alistair calls him a “damned Jew,” Lucien punches him. Hannah isn’t there, so Lucien runs to Shepheard’s, which is on fire. Years ago, Lucien ran into an old friend, and they discussed the possibility of Israeli statehood. Shiloah, a rabbi’s son, told Lucien that they need “eyes and ears on the ground” (441); this is how Lucien gets the job at Shepheard’s and why he ended up in the beds of so many diplomats’ wives. Now, the heat from the fire is blistering, but Lucien runs to his rooms. Hannah is not there. As he makes his way downstairs, he finds her. Her leg is hurt, so he carries her through the flames. He loses consciousness and wakes up to Hannah’s screaming; he lurches to his feet, making his way outside. Hannah says that she loves him over and over, and he realizes that the pain isn’t as bad as it was. He is hopeful that he might yet live, but he dies in her arms.

Chapter 22 Summary: “Mallory. July 2022. Boston, Massachusetts”

Paige sleeps in a chair while Mallory watches Sam. Sedge arrives, and Mallory explains that the kidney was an ideal match, and the surgery was a success. Sedge is interested in a relationship, and Mallory agrees to join him for dinner soon. Sam wakes up and wonders where Monk is, and Mallory assures him that Monk loves him more than anything. Sam replies that Monk loves Mallory more than anything; Monk told him so. Mallory checks her messages, but there’s nothing from Monk. She tells Sam that his phone is probably off, but she feels an ominous dread that something bad has happened. She has several messages from Luca, who writes that the cobra bracelet was a device used by spies to hide and deliver messages. It takes some force, but she twists the cobra’s tail off, and a small piece of paper falls out. It is from their grandmother, who writes that she named her daughter “Lucile” after her father, who died to save her. She signed it “Hannah Countess Vècsey (Ainsworth)” (459). A doctor at Massachusetts General hospital calls Mallory, identifying her as Monk’s medical power of attorney. He says that Monk was in surgery—it turns out that he was the kidney donor—and went into cardiac arrest.

Jake comes to stay with Sam, and Paige and Mallory make their way to Monk’s hospital. Lee is there, but a doctor whisks Mallory away to update her on Monk’s condition. Blue and Chippy greet Mallory warmly. They are angry because Lee’s been posting about Monk’s condition on Instagram. The twins say that they even stopped visiting because of Lee. Monk doesn’t look good. Paige brings coffee, and Mallory describes her guilt—how if she told Monk about Sam sooner, Sam wouldn’t have gone to camp and eaten the poisonous mushroom, and Monk wouldn’t have had a heart attack while donating his kidney. Paige tells Mallory that she knows there must be some reason Mallory left Monk and kept Sam a secret, and she says that Mallory should tell Monk now. Mallory thinks that he won’t hear her, and she fears that, if she tells him the truth, any chance that they might have to reconcile will disappear. Nonetheless, she takes his hand and starts talking.

Chapter 23 Summary: “Mallory. August 2008. Winthrop Island, New York”

After Mallory and Monk have unprotected sex once, it is easy to do it again. On August 14, one day before they’re supposed to leave together, Mallory has a bad feeling. Mr. Adams invites her to lunch, where he raises concerns about their relationship. He tells her that Monk is quitting college to pursue his music. This is news to Mallory, but she supports Monk. Mr. Adams gives her his card and asks her to call him if she ever needs help.

Monk calls Mallory while she’s in the car with Mr. Adams. When she tells him what his father said, he apologizes for not telling her first. Monk compares his father to Machiavelli in terms of his willingness to manipulate and promises that they’ll discuss everything on their drive tomorrow. When they hang up, Mallory tells Mr. Adams that Monk deserves his support. She says that Monk is playing tonight at Mo’s and asks him to go and listen. After she puts the kids to bed, she can’t fall asleep. She goes downstairs for a drink, and Mr. Adams is there. He came back after Monk’s first set and offers Mallory a joint. Thinking that it will help her sleep, she accepts. He offers Mallory another drink, leaving briefly and returning with it. She begins to feel strange, and he admits he gave her “something to help [her] sleep” (493). He walks her to her room and begins to undress her. He claims to have seen “the way [she] look[s] at him” and says that he knows she’s “been wanting [him] to do this” (493). She tells him no. He rapes her.

Chapter 24 Summary: “Monk. September 2022. Mystic, Connecticut”

Monk arrives at Mallory’s house, telling himself not to mess things up. They sit in the garden and talk. Mallory confesses her desire to open a design house, saying that she wants to surround people with art rather than confine it to museums. She tells Monk about Lucien Beck, how her grandfather was an Israeli operative who gave the cobra bracelet to her grandmother, and that it holds secret messages. Mallory says that Hannah returned to Hungary after giving birth to work for the independence movement. She lived to see the Soviets leave before dying in 1992.

Monk remembers what Mallory said while he was in the ICU, and he already asked Paige if his memory was real. He is sorry that his family failed Mallory and that he failed her. He mentions that his manager, Kevin, once referred to her as “Rosebud.” She says that she didn’t tell him because it would’ve wrecked him, but he claims that losing her was worse. She feared that Monk would be revolted and that she would see his father when she looked at him. She still fears that Sam is Monk’s half-brother rather than his son, but Monk reminds her that Sam took a DNA test as part of the paternity agreement, and it confirmed that Monk is Sam’s father. He tells that her he broke up with Lee, and when Sedge came to see him, he told Sedge that he was still in love with Mallory. She asks why Monk didn’t tell her that he was donating his kidney, and he says that he didn’t want her worrying about him when Sam needed her. They sleep together, and Monk says that he wants to marry her.

Paige enters the house, and Monk and Mallory emerge from the bedroom. Paige ushers Kàroly, Count Vècsey, into the house. She tells Mallory that Kàroly was abducted by Soviet soldiers during World War II, and after the Berlin Wall fell, he traveled to Hungary to find his birth mother. He takes Mallory’s hand and says that he promised Hannah he’d find her.

Chapters 19-24 Analysis

These chapters contain a great deal of foreshadowing, heightening the tension until the narrative reveals why Mallory left Monk. First, though Sam has been saved by a mystery kidney donor, Mallory still has the ominous sense that something is wrong. She feels as though “[s]omething terrible lurks offstage, waiting for a cue” (456). She is unable to reach Monk, though she knows that he'd respond quickly to her texts about Sam if he saw them. Another clue about his health comes to fruition, too. When Mallory learns that this fit, youthful man had a heart attack on the operating table due to a previously undiagnosed heart condition, she recalls what he said to her when they were younger: “It hurts, Pink. Like a pain in my chest, like it’s too much to hold” (465). Suddenly, those words are a great deal more meaningful. He attributed the chest pain to his blinding happiness that they were finally together, as well as to a fear that something might happen to pull them apart. Now, his pain is literal.

Mallory’s sense of “foreboding” also comes to fruition when the narrative reveals that she is a rape survivor. The day before she was scheduled to leave Winthrop Island, she thought, “Something was going to go wrong” (472). It was later that night that Mr. Adams drugged and raped her, and she abandoned Monk, unwilling to tell him the truth about his father. Mr. Adams is hence revealed as the antagonist, reinforcing Monk’s fear that he had “stuck his finger in” (379). Finally, with the revelation of several truths—most significantly, that Monk has a heart condition, that Mr. Adams raped Mallory, and that Monk is definitely Sam’s father—all the ominous feelings of dread come to light and result in catharsis.

Ersatz coffee, the “Fake coffee” people “used to drink during the Second World War” is symbolic of Monk’s attempt to approximate happiness after Mallory left him (425). Her leaving was so unexpected and so painful, that it created a terrible emptiness in his life, a space he tried to fill by reuniting with Lennox Lassiter, an old college girlfriend who his father always preferred to Mallory. During a conversation with Mallory in Chapter 20, he describes ersatz coffee as something that filled a gap or a need in people’s lives. It wasn’t ideal, but it was better than totally going without. People love coffee, and many grew to depend on it as a source of comfort and warmth. Then, when the war went on and on, people were compelled to find something else to drink, so they invented ersatz coffee, made of ground acorns or chicory, Monk says. It didn’t taste the same, but “they drank it anyway because they didn’t have any real coffee and they needed something” (425). Monk never says so directly, but the narrative implies the coffee is a metaphor for his relationship with Lennox when he no longer had access to Mallory. Monk is aware that his feelings for Lennox were never the same as his feelings for Mallory; they weren’t as deep and fulfilling by any stretch.

The revelation that Mr. Adams is a rapist emphasizes The Deceptiveness of Appearances. Monk always resented his father’s hypocrisy, citing the man’s reputation as a patron of the arts while he privately torpedoed his son’s dreams of becoming a musician. When Mr. Adams tells Mallory that Monk unenrolled from college, Monk compares his father to Machiavelli, a Renaissance philosopher, who argued that rulers must prioritize what is best for the state over what is morally good. This suggests Monk’s understanding that his father values power above all and is willing to do immoral, unscrupulous things to retain that power and guarantee his family’s standing in the community. Once what Mr. Adams did is revealed, Monk thinks of Mallory as “[i]ncorruptible [because his father] had no power over [her]” (521). Monk always suspected his father’s ability to manipulate and exploit others for his own ends, despite the public face Mr. Adams showed the world, and now the man’s true nature is irrevocably revealed.

Williams highlights Female Perseverance and Strength through Hannah’s and Mallory’s experiences. Hannah describes her abuse at the hands of the Soviets, detailing how a half dozen soldiers beat her and forced Jànos to watch, then shot him in the head. While she cradled his body with “his brains on the bedroom wall” beside them (406), the Soviets stole her baby and tried to burn her alive. Williams creates graphic imagery to reinforce Hannah's characterization as strong and resilient. She’d already survived typhoid and lost two other children to the fever, and her father was sent to an extermination camp. Without Jànos or Kàroly, she then committed herself to killing Soviets and Nazis, but when she was captured, she hints that they repeatedly physically and sexually assaulted her. She had to “separate [her] mind from [her] body, [her] soul from [her] body” (408-409). Despite these horrors, she tries to hold onto love when she finds it with Lucien, and she even returns to Hungary after being forced to give up their daughter to continue fighting for the country’s independence. Her many losses and terrible personal violations do not deter her from surviving, serving herself and her country.

Further, her desire to keep her daughter, Lucile, of which Mallory and Paige learn when they travel to Ireland, highlights The Power of Maternal Love which outweighs every other consideration or feeling. Despite Alistair’s anger and her own traumas, Hannah longs to keep this child. Her feelings are conveyed by her insistence that Bernadette give the American parents the cobra bracelet that contains a message with the girl’s true identity and parentage inside. Her maternal love is reflected in Mallory’s character arc. For her part, Mallory survives being drugged and raped by her boyfriend’s father, a man who encouraged her to think of him as a godfather. She manages her pregnancy, her resentment, and the loss of the love of her life, as she rebuilds her sense of self amid stifling fears about Sam’s father’s identity. Mallory perseveres, exhibiting strength and fortitude. Further, her devotion to Sam suggests the power of her love. By drawing parallels between two storylines about women who survive violence and care for their children, Williams highlights the fact that women have endured such things for generations and yet persevere and often take on most of the childcare responsibilities.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text