55 pages • 1 hour read
Jonathan Safran FoerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: The source material uses offensive terms and stereotypes for Black people and Jewish people, which are replicated in this guide only in direct quotes of the source material.
In the shtetl, they hold a lottery to choose an official town name to be used for government records. But because Sofiowka is entrusted to deliver the name to the magistrate, he names the town after himself: Sofiowka. The other townspeople do not want to call it that, so they hold another lottery to pick an unofficial name. Yankel D’s entry wins, and he names the town Trachimbrod after his daughter, Brod, and her father, Trachim.
The narrative shifts to a letter written from Alex to Jonathan, dated after their quest to find Augustine. Alex says that he has been saving money and now has enough to buy a plane ticket to America. His father does not know. Igor is now 14 and has broken his arm. For his birthday, they had a party and his father bought him a bicycle. Alex relays that Grandfather asked about Jonathan and for another copy of Augustine’s photo. Alex also reports that Grandfather is not well.
From the letter, we understand that the story of the quest to find Augustine is being written by Alex, and Jonathan is reading and offering comments on it. Alex reveals that Jonathan has asked him to keep his English mistakes in the story for the sake of humor. Jonathan has also recommended cutting the dog out of the story, but Alex refuses. Alex then critiques Jonathan’s story, telling him that he loves The Book of Recurrent Dreams and feels empathy for Yankel, a good man who must have had a good reason to swindle in the past.
Alex, Jonathan, and Grandfather are on their journey to Lutsk. Grandfather gets lost in Lvov trying to find the superway to Lutsk, but they eventually get on their way. It is a five-hour trip, with Alex speaking Ukrainian with his grandfather, English with Jonathan, and moderating conversation between the two. As Grandfather insults and curses Jonathan, Alex offers up meaningless tour guide information in English instead of translating.
While they travel, Jonathan explains that he is looking for a girl named Augustine, who helped his grandfather escape the Nazi attack in which his wife and child were killed. Jonathan has not told his grandmother he is in Ukraine—she escaped during World War II, and her family were all killed. When Alex is surprised that no Ukrainians helped her escape, Jonathan tells him that Ukrainians were terrible to Jews during the war. Alex tells him he must be mistaken, but Jonathan refuses to agree. Alex then tells Grandfather the story, and Grandfather gets very sad. He looks at the picture of Augustine and together, they resolve to find her.
When they arrive at the hotel, Jonathan insists on going inside with Alex, who tells him not to speak so as not to give away that he is an American. Jonathan makes a fuss with the clerk. As a result, he is charged double, but Alex does not tell him. At the hotel restaurant, Jonathan tells them that he is a vegetarian and orders a piece of meat to get the two potatoes that come with it. One of the potatoes falls on the floor. Grandfather picks it up, cuts it into four, and gives a piece to each of them and one to the dog. They all laugh and share a moment of connection.
Alex and Jonathan discuss his career as a writer, and Alex forces him to accept the label of “writer,” even though Jonathan is very wary of labeling himself as such. Alex presses Jonathan for information about being an accountant in America, as this is the profession he hopes to pursue. Alex and his grandfather get a drink before bed and afterward, Alex lets the dog into Jonathan’s room. Grandfather wants to start early the next morning, and neither of them sleeps well that night, both thinking about what Grandfather did during the war.
In Trachimbrod, the women all reject Brod and even turn their children against her. As she gets older, the men all desire her. She cuts her own hair and makes her own clothes. Yankel still hasn’t told her that he is not her father, partly because he doesn’t want her to know that Trachim was her father or that Trachimday is about his death and her birth. Brod is always challenging herself, reading and learning, but she is lonely and sad, always feeling the need to justify her existence. She has great love inside of her but nowhere to put it.
Yankel was 73 years old when he adopted Brod. When Brod turns 12, Yankel begins to worry about what will happen to her when he dies. He is older and in much more pain than she knows, and she will still be too young to take care of herself when he dies. He hides signs of his deterioration by writing his memories on the ceiling above his bed, where he can read them each morning.
As Jonathan and Alex talk, Alex shows himself to be both insightful and thoughtful by asking interesting questions. In addition, we see his discomfort upon learning that Ukrainians did not help the Jews escape the Nazis. Alex tries to get Jonathan to recant this testimony, but he refuses. Alex’s heightened awareness of World War II then causes him to wonder, maybe for the first time, what his grandfather’s role was during the war. At the same time, there are many moments of connection between Alex and Jonathan on this trip, both meaningful conversations and light moments, like when Jonathan teaches Alex some Yiddish. We also see the first crack in Grandfather’s antipathy towards Jonathan during their dinner the first night. In this section, there are several instances in which Alex uses his role as translator to edit the comments of Grandfather, again illustrating how easy it is to edit and shape the truth. This reshaping of the truth is shown elsewhere, such as choosing a new name for Trachimbrod that will actually be used and Yankel convincing Brod that he is not losing his memories.
In telling the story of Brod and Yankel, Jonathan details the way in which they build their life together. They are both outsiders and live on the fringes of society; Yankel was convicted of a crime, and Brod was born to no family. Yet they keep secrets from each other, and so never truly know each other. Here, Jonathan makes a connection to his own relationship with his grandmother and the ways that secrets and silence keep them from knowing each other. This point connects back to the effects of generational trauma, and the way that the silence around it keeps loved ones from true intimacy.
By Jonathan Safran Foer