logo

39 pages 1 hour read

Wendy Mass, Rebecca Stead

Bob

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2018

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Forgetting and Remembering

This theme is presented immediately as the book opens, as Gran and Livy’s mother try to help her remember her trip to Gran’s five years prior. At this point, what is at stake in Livy remembering is not clear, and Livy’s forgetting is explained by her young age during her first visit. As she re-meets Bob, however, Livy realizes that she has forgotten many significant aspects of her previous visit. Initially, Livy presumes that her forgetting is natural and normal, though she is surprised that she has no memory of such an unusual event as meeting a “green creature.” As Livy travels into town, however, she forgets Bob again, and it is through the process of remembering him yet again with the help of the black pawn that Livy comes to understand that the forgetting is caused by some kind of magical force.

Bob is hurt by Livy’s inability to remember him. He, on the other hand, has eagerly awaited her return, focusing on her promise to help him return to his home. For Bob, the memory of Livy remains fresh each day, and he frequently imagines what might be keeping her away. When she finally returns, but with no memory of the promise she made, Bob regards this as a broken promise and his trust in Livy is damaged. But, with the discovery that Livy has not intentionally forgotten Bob, Bob is reassured and his complete trust in Livy renewed. In this way, forgetting and remembering is instrumental in defining and shaping their relationship.

The crux of the conflict is caused by both Livy and Bob’s inability to remember how Bob came to Gran’s farm and where he is from. It is with the help of items that serve as clues—the chess set, the chicken suit, the time capsule, Danny’s drawing of the well, and the Fairy and Folk Tales From A to Z book—that Livy and Bob arrive at the answer to their questions. In this way, remembering brings satisfaction and closure.

Secondary characters serve to aid in Livy’s remembering. Sarah has vivid and complete memories of Livy’s previous visit. She remembers what Livy cannot—namely, Livy’s assembling and burying of the time capsule that holds the information of Bob’s existence. Gran, too, remembers some details, though her memories are less precise at times. It is through Gran that Livy learns of the importance of the chess pieces and of her interest in the Fairy and Folk Tales book. Livy’s commitment to remembering, in the end, is a sign of her caring and compassionate character, and she remains determined to follow through on the promise she once made to Bob.

Finally, the theme is carried out to the end of the novel as Bob leaves the black pawn with Livy, in hopes that she will find it and be able to always remember him.

Discovering the Truth

The novel’s central conflict focuses on Bob’s existence. Neither Livy nor he knows who he is, where he comes from, or how he might return to his home. That neither of them can remember how Bob came to arrive at Gran’s house serves as an obstacle to their goal. Their uncovering of the truth involves remembering details and events from Livy’s visit five years prior. Bob’s chicken suit is one of the first clues to his identity, as Livy speculates that he is in fact the “wrong chicken” (3) that she remembers, albeit vaguely. This leads Bob and Livy to the chicken coop, where Livy hopes to jog Bob’s memory.

Knowing who he is and where he comes from is important to Bob and Livy for different reasons. Bob repeatedly informs Livy that she promised—on her first visit five years prior—to help Bob return home. That she was never able to fulfill this promise plagues Livy, despite her having no memory of making the promise. She is determined to fulfill her promise, demonstrating Livy’s kindness and commitment to Bob. In this way, she trusts the wisdom of her younger self, though she cannot recall the circumstances in which she made the promise. Similarly, she must now trust Bob though she cannot fully understand many of the details concerning him. For instance, Bob insists Livy put the black pawn in her pocket, though he cannot provide her with an explanation when she asks for one. He merely states that it was “what she always did before” (78). In this way, Livy and Bob possess the means to discover the truth of Bob’s identity and must trust the fuzzy memories that serve as puzzle pieces.

Bob’s desire to return home is bound up in his understanding of his identity. Because he does not know who he is or, rather, cannot remember, he feels incomplete and emotionally lost. He lacks a connection to other beings like him, and his desire for this grows stronger as he observes the way Livy’s mother comforts and cares for her. That he feels incomplete and upset by his inability to remember who he is demonstrates how important discovering the truth is to him. When Bob does return home—thanks to Danny’s drawing and the information in the A to Z book—he is joyous upon learning that he has an important purpose as a well dweller. The rain he and his family provide instills in Bob a sense of meaning.

The Importance of Family and Friends

The importance of family connections takes many forms throughout the novel. That Gran and Livy’s relationship is potentially hindered by the physical distance that separates their homes is apparent when Livy has difficulty remembering details from her earlier trip. Livy knows that Gran worries she has stayed away too long and that forging a bond between her and Gran becomes increasingly difficult the longer they remain apart. That Livy is anxious and unable to sleep when she is apart from her parents indicates that she is close to them and that they have a warm, caring connection. By the same token, however, this suggests that Livy has difficulty trusting or becoming comfortable around new people. She is initially shy and awkward around Sarah, despite being assured that she and Sarah enjoyed one another’s company on Livy’s last visit.

Livy’s mother recognizes that the distance between Australia and Massachusetts serves as an obstacle to Livy and Gran forming a close connection. Livy’s mother makes certain that Livy speaks with Gran often on the phone for this reason, and she takes special steps to assist Livy in forging a bond with Gran’s home. Her mother shows her the well that her father built, acquaints Livy with the animals, and introduces Livy to Gran’s neighbors at the local restaurant. Livy warms to both Gran and Sarah quickly, thanks to each character’s reliance on the things that they bonded over previously to reforge the relationship with Livy. During her stay, Livy witnesses the strong friendship Gran and her mother possess with their neighbors, as evidenced by the fun they have talking and laughing over dinner in the restaurant with Sarah and her mother and by the care Sarah’s grandfather takes in delivering the news of the possible foreclosure to Gran. The neighbors help Gran cope with this difficulty, and she, in turn, proves to be reliable and caring when she participates in the search for Danny when he is missing.

Indeed, Bob observes the safety Livy experiences from her mother’s hugs and snuggling, which makes him long for a mother of his own. The eagerness with which he awaited Livy’s return indicates how lonely he felt upon her absence. He found himself passing the time using what distractions were available to him—the partial chess set, the dictionary, the Lego set—but never lost focus on Livy and her promise to return. While his friendship with Livy makes Bob’s life rich and meaningful, his desire to return to his family outweighs his desire to spend time with Livy. Though he is not certain whether he has a family or not, Bob seems to know on an instinctive level that he must have some sort of tie to other beings like him. Indeed, the enthusiasm and extreme joy Bob expresses when he is reunited with his mother indicate how important she is to him. The love Bob’s mother holds for him is also evident in the steps she takes to prevent Bob from escaping from the well network again in the future by seizing the pawn from Livy. Though the friendship between Livy and Bob is a meaningful one, Bob cannot live among both Livy and his family, as he forgets the well when he strays from it. In the end, both family ties and friendship are important, though they serve different purposes. The novel illustrates that, via the black pawn, Livy will not forget Bob as she did previously, and in this way, their friendship can remain alive despite their physical distance from one another.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text