54 pages • 1 hour read
Xóchitl GonzálezA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Eurocentrism in the art world is one of this novel’s most important and well-developed themes. In both narrative timelines, Gonzalez explores the deeply white supremacist beliefs that underpin relationships between artists, important players within the world of art, and the general viewership, delivering a thorough critique of the notion that identity does not impact art.
Within this context, Anita is well aware that she is one of the few artists of color in the predominantly white art world of 1980s New York City. Although she is happy to be part of a small but growing cadre of artists who are diversifying this Eurocentric space, she experiences a great deal of prejudice because she is part of the first wave of artists of color to achieve mainstream success. She often observes the surprise that various members of the art world express when they hear that she has a new show or has sold an important piece, and she notes: “White men loved to use words that implied astonishment whenever women of color accomplished anything they deemed their ‘terrain’” (42). In addition to the lack of support that her work receives from people like gallerist Tilly Barber, Anita is viewed primarily through the lens of stereotype. She expected to be a “loud Latina” and realizes that Jack’s white friends relate to her more effectively when they believe that she is conforming to this stereotype.
Raquel also feels the sting of being a woman of color in a majority-white space, and although she has developed a deep appreciation for artists of color, she knows that such artists are not particularly well represented in the curriculum of her art history program at Brown. She fiercely advocates for the inclusion of Black and brown artists in the canon of major figures, but she is told that such artists do not represent the real scope and history of art in the Americas. In addition to Raquel’s realization that artists of color go unrecognized in Ivy League curricula, she is also acutely attuned to her own differences from those around her, observing that at Brown, she will “always be an Other in this place” (18). She is shunned by the clique of white art history majors, and the sole friend she makes in the department, Mavette, is another student of color. (Even their relationship is not without issue, as Mavette herself benefits from her wealth and is initially allied with the clique of white students. She, too, has to develop a better sense of self in order to reach out to other students of color.) Ultimately, Raquel’s article on Anita de Monte revives her work and stands as a powerful endorsement for the power of communities of color. Raquel, who is herself a woman of color, sees the inherent value in de Monte’s work and realizes that in spite of the influence that Jack and Tilly wielded to suppress it, Anita de Monte’s work actually represents real artistic innovation. When Raquel writes an article arguing for that Anita’s artistic influence transcends that of Jack Martin, Gonzalez uses this narrative moment to argue that in a cultural landscape where artists of color go unrecognized by white patrons and viewers, it is possible for other artists and critics of color to exert influence and generate appreciation for marginalized works of art.
Throughout the novel, Xochitl Gonzalez exhibits a deep understanding of intersectionality, and she is just as attuned to the politics of class as she is the politics of race and culture. She explores the impact that class has on artists of color primarily through her characterization of Raquel, who experiences class-based prejudice at the hands of her classmates, her boyfriend Nick, and Nick’s family. Raquel grew up in Brooklyn and was not born into the kind of affluence that characterizes the lives of most of the other students at her Ivy League school. Whereas her classmates’ parents wield considerable influence in the realms of art, real estate, and finance, Raquel’s own mother works at the Met’s cafeteria. The difference in her background is immediately apparent to Raquel upon arrival at Brown. She realizes that small details set her apart from others; for example, her shower caddy contains drug store brands like Noxema, while her classmates use unfamiliar and expensive products. As one of a handful of students of color in her department, she knows that she stands out, but she also realizes that the clique-entrenched girls at school see her as a poor, underprivileged woman of color. Raquel is unaccustomed to seeing herself in that light, for although she is not wealthy, she grew up in a happy, supportive, functional home, and she never lacked for anything. The gap between how Raquel is perceived and what her childhood was actually like is meant to show the disutility of using class as a framework by which to judge an individual. The other students miss so much about Raquel because they see her as “poor,” and this dynamic becomes particularly apparent to Raquel when one of her rare conversations with the “Art History Girls” devolves into an argument and a smear campaign. As one of them angrily tells her, “We all see how you work John Temple; how you manipulate the faculty. This poor, pitiful public school kid routine. Poor little minority, always so fucking earnest about how hard she works” (67). This contemptuous tirade embodies many of the inherent prejudices against which Raquel must fight in order to forge her own place in the art world.
Raquel also experiences class-based discrimination in her romantic relationship. Although Nick fancies himself modern and likes to think that he has escaped the trappings of his privilege because he is “open-minded,” he, too, sees Raquel through the lens of difference. He assumes that she wants access to the high-class world that he moves in because he equates money with success and happiness. He is sure that she is grateful to him for “saving” her from her lower-class life, and he even thinks himself modern for dating a woman with a background so different from his. His parents also see Raquel through the lens of class and fancy themselves open-minded for accepting their son’s underprivileged girlfriend. Well aware of these undercurrents, Raquel observes casual bigotry in much of their conversation with her, and she realizes that they share their son’s belief that Raquel must be grateful for the opportunity to have access to their world.
Despite these roadblocks, Raquel ultimately achieves success on the basis of her own merits, and her unique and authentic approach proves that class is not an accurate predictor of intellect or intelligence. Although she does not have access to the same set of privileges that her affluent classmates do, Raquel nonetheless develops a keen, critical eye through her own powers of reasoning and through the influence of her mother, who is knowledgeable about art and art history despite her lack of a degree or a high-powered position within the art world.
Gonzalez is deeply invested in depicting the biases and hazards of toxic masculinity, and the narrative therefore provides a particularly detailed examination of the relationship between misogyny and intimate partner violence. By linking key parallels between Anita’s storyline and Raquel’s, Gonzalez demonstrates the cost of sexism for women and reveals misogyny to be a systemic problem within contemporary society. Although Jack’s abuse and Nick’s take different forms, their general worldview is misogynistic in nature, and they both believe in the inherent superiority of men over women. As Anita muses early in the narrative, “The beginning of the end was the first time I chose Jack Martin over myself” (37). Although Anita does acknowledge her willingness to focus more of her energy on her partner than on herself, she also realizes how skillfully Jack has manipulated her and how deeply ingrained his sexism truly is. Jack is initially drawn to Anita because he sees her as vulnerable and believes that because she has not yet found mainstream success, she will be perfectly willing to stand on the sidelines and cheer him on. When she began to sell pieces and get shows of her own, he cannot stand the idea that his wife might outshine him. His subtle dismissal of her ideas and opinions soon give way to more overt abuse, and their relationship becomes dangerously volatile. That Jack is ultimately capable of both physical abuse and murder indicates his unwillingness to see his wife’s humanity; he is only able to kill her because he sees her and women in general as less worthy and less important than men.
Although Nick is not a murderer and is not physically abusive like Jack, he too embodies many aspects of toxic masculinity. He initially gives Raquel ostensibly generous gifts of clothing and advice, but his ulterior motive is ultimately revealed to be less than kind, for he only wants to control Raquel’s appearance so that her curated appearance will improve his own public image. Raquel eventually realizes that Nick “[makes] her feel like an accessory” (272), and she begins to understand that he engages in this behavior in order to benefit himself, not her. As his success increases, his behavior grows worse, and in this he also resembles Jack. Eventually it becomes clear to Raquel that Nick sees her as a lesser being. As the narrative states, “She began to feel he wanted to hobble her at her knees, to make her feel grateful for his love” (319). Because Raquel is a woman of color whom he has labeled as “poor,” he looks down on her even as he claims to love her. With both Jack’s and Nick’s characters, Gonzalez is making a clear statement about the systemic nature of patriarchal attitudes, for Jack and Nick did not create the idea that men are inherently more intelligent and talented than women. This attitude was inculcated in them by a society that values male achievement and dismisses female accomplishments. These attitudes are also evident to a lesser degree in characters like John Temple and the various other men in the art world who praise Jack’s work more than Anita’s despite the superior quality of her artistic techniques and underlying messages.
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Art
View Collection
Books About Art
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Hispanic & Latinx American Literature
View Collection
Music
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Reese Witherspoon's Hello Sunshine...
View Collection