48 pages • 1 hour read
Mary LawsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Clara tells a panicked Dan what Liam told her, promising him that he won’t get in trouble. Liam’s car pulls up, and Dan dives into the bushes to hide. Liam asks Clara if he has spoken to Dan yet, and when Clara is evasive, he realizes that Dan is still around. He announces that he will take Dan to talk to Sergeant Barnes and stay with him the entire time, ensuring nothing happens to him. After a while, Dan emerges from the bushes, and he and Liam drive away together.
Clara tells Moses later that day that since it is Tuesday, Rose will be home no later than Friday. The rest of the week Clara is in good spirits, even stepping out at recess to skip rope with the other girls. When Rose isn’t back by Saturday, Clara spends the whole morning at the living room window, humming tonelessly. She goes over to play with Moses in the afternoon, who disappears as usual as soon as Liam walks in the door. Liam tells Clara it might take the police a while to find Rose.
On Monday, Clara comes home to find neighbors over and her mother extremely upset. The police have found a girl’s body, and John has gone to Toronto to see if it is Rose. Clara goes over to Liam’s, and he reassures her that it probably isn’t Rose, as the girl the police found had long hair. He lets her unpack another box. John confirms that the dead girl isn’t Rose on Tuesday, and Diane is relieved, but an image of a dead girl haunts Clara’s dreams.
A few days later, Clara falls sick and is in bed for a couple of days. She dreams of Rose sitting by her bed, and wakes up to find her parents talking in the kitchen. A while later, a police car pulls up, and Sergeant Barnes and a doctor emerge from it with Rose. John cries, and Diane embraces Rose. They bring Rose in, and Clara notices that Rose looks like she doesn’t know where she is. Over the next few nights, Rose thrashes around in her bed at night, in the throes of nightmares; she doesn’t seem to recognize or acknowledge Clara.
Dan meets Clara again on the way back from school, and Clara describes Rose’s situation. Dan begins to visit and talks to Rose every day but gets no response. Clara heads over to Liam’s and asks him what is wrong with Rose. When he suggests she ask her parents, Clara yells at him. Liam doesn’t reprimand her and lets her unpack another box.
On Sunday, Clara goes over to Liam’s and they unpack the final box. Liam bequeaths more things to Clara, giving her some of them right away, and for a horrified moment she thinks it means he is dying. He clarifies and Clara is relieved. She also discovers that the little boy in Mrs. Orchard’s favorite photo is Liam.
When Clara gets back home, she realizes that Rose looks different: She actually sees Clara. Clara whispers how glad she is to have Rose home, and stands by her bed biting her nails. After a moment, Rose reaches up and pulls Clara’s hand away from her mouth, making her promise to stop biting her nails.
Mrs. Orchard explains to Martha what her doctor said and invites her to talk about it, but Martha doesn’t want to. Mrs. Dubois’s family visits again, and she is finally allowed to sit up a little, so there is a little celebration when the family reunites. After the children leave, Martha asks Mrs. Orchard to stay with her until the end, and Mrs. Orchard promises to do so. Martha passes away later that night. Mrs. Orchard is the one to notice, as Martha wakes Mrs. Orchard up from a nap before falling silent.
Mrs. Orchard grieves Martha’s passing deeply. To distract herself, she writes a final letter to Liam, enclosing the photographs she brought with her and a covering letter to her lawyer. She then relives the part of her past she has constantly been trying to suppress.
The argument between Mr. and Mrs. Orchard is a turning point in their marriage, and a distance creeps in between them for a long time. In retrospect, Mrs. Orchard knows she wasn’t being rational: She had fantasies of Liam being passed on to them to adopt, and watching how good Mr. Orchard was with Liam only fueled these fantasies.
In her flashback, Liam spends increasing amounts of time at the Orchards’, now completely ignoring Annette when she speaks to him, which upsets her. One evening, when she comes to pick him up, he proclaims he wants to live with the Orchards and have them be his parents, as he likes them more than Annette. Instead of reassuring Annette, Mrs. Orchard hastily calls Liam “silly” and asks him to go home. However, her expression gives her away, unsettling Annette.
Liam heads to “his room,” and when Annette follows him and sees how perfectly done up for Liam it is, she is furious and horrified. She accuses Mrs. Orchard of tempting Liam and turning him against her, and drags a screaming Liam back home. Annette yells at Mrs. Orchard, calling her “crazy” and threatening to call the police, even as Mrs. Orchard denies everything.
Mr. Orchard is away for work, and there is no one to calm a frantic Mrs. Orchard down. She goes over to the Kanes’ to try and speak to Ralph, but Annette almost physically attacks her. Desperate, Mrs. Orchard steals into the Kanes’ house at midnight and carries a sleeping Liam out to her car. She drives away aimlessly in the middle of the night, but by dawn the police catch up with her and bring her back. Liam remains asleep through it all.
A huge scandal follows, with the Kanes moving away and Mr. Orchard transferring universities. Mrs. Orchard is charged with abduction and sentenced to prison for a year. Mr. Orchard is shaken, having hoped the judge would consider his wife’s mental state and good reputation and pass a lenient sentence. After Mrs. Orchard gets out, her condition necessitates a stay in a psychiatric hospital, and she gets through her time there with the help of her therapists and her husband’s unwavering love and support.
A new occupant moves into Martha’s bed; Mrs. Orchard keeps the pleasantries to a minimum. She finds it increasingly difficult to breathe now, and asks the nurse to help turn her onto her side. As she drifts off, she feels her husband’s hand cupping her side, just as he used to every night in bed.
Ten days after Rose is found, Liam is walking home from work when Sergeant Barnes pulls up alongside him and offers him a lift. Sergeant Barnes thanks Liam once again for his help with finding Rose, revealing she was found in a derelict house on the outskirts of town where an organized gang kept young girls to be raped by customers. Rose was possibly picked up within a day or two of arriving; her cropped head was the key identifier that helped the police find her, as people remembered her. She will undoubtedly have some lasting psychological damage from the incident, but the doctor is keeping an eye on her.
Sergeant Barnes also claims he heard Liam picked up some ice cream. He subtly warns Liam to be careful with Jo, as she has been through a couple of rough, abusive marriages in the past. Liam thinks about how he has visited Jo quite a few times since the first, and now understands her caution. She initiated sex, so he feels comfortable continuing.
Later that night Jo mentions her past, and Liam reveals Sergeant Barnes already told him, trying to warn him off Jo. Jo understands Sergeant Barnes is being protective and admits the hardest part is trying not to think about her past.
Liam and Jo continue their affair, slowly getting to know each other. The time he spends with Jo means Liam sees less of Clara; however, he thinks it a good thing, as he is planning to leave soon and has a sense that Clara is beginning to depend on him.
Liam turns up to work one day to find Cal missing; Jim reveals he took Liam up on his advice and went back to university. Jim’s wife, Susan, has invited Liam over for dinner.
On Thursday morning, Liam and Jo get out of bed and have French toast and ice cream together. Liam notices how beautiful Jo is, and Jo curls up next to him in bed. Liam realizes he is in love with her, and instantly Fiona’s assertions that he is incapable of love and trust come rushing back. Sure he will mess things up sooner or later, Liam tells Jo he will be leaving Solace soon, and they end their affair.
Later that night, he feels sick with grief and is tempted to leave town straightaway. However, he knows he cannot suddenly leave because of Clara, and decides to give it a couple of days. The next time he sees Clara, she asks about Rose, and when he suggests she ask her parents instead, she is furious and close to tears. They unpack another box instead.
On Sunday, Liam and Clara unpack the last box. Liam finds Mrs. Orchard’s last letter to him and the photographs she took with her to the hospital. In the letter, she hopes that what he remembers from his time with the Orchards, above all else, is how much they loved him. Liam remembers how special he felt at the Orchards’, and is sure his mother must have known that he never wanted to return home from there. Liam shows Clara the photograph that has him in it, telling her he is the little boy. She is delighted, and claims this is why Mrs. Orchard left him the house, because she loved him very much.
Clara helps Liam replace the photographs exactly where they were on the mantelpiece. Liam offers a wood carving of four card players, which he had promised Clara she could have when he dies, for her to take home straightaway. Liam had hoped this would help soften the blow of his leaving, but Clara looks so stricken at the thought that he might be dying that he rushes to reassure her instead. He promises she can keep them in his house and play with them when she comes over to see him and Moses.
After Clara leaves, Liam regrets not having told her he was leaving. He tries to convince himself that she will get over it. After eating a bowl of ice cream, Liam heads over to Jo’s and tells her he is having trouble leaving. She invites him in to talk about it. When he gets back home, he has a sense that something has changed. He switches on the light to find a cat sitting in the center of the living room, gazing up at him. Liam greets the cat: “Hello, Moses […] It’s good to meet you” (288).
The final set of chapters is rife with revelations and resolutions for the different plotlines and internal conflicts within the story. Clara’s, Liam’s, and Sergeant Barnes’s joint efforts are successful in eliciting important information from Dan, leading to Rose’s eventual return home. The mystery of the past “incident” involving Mrs. Orchard is also fully revealed, explaining the rift between the Orchards and the Kanes.
The theme of The Complexities of Relationships is once more at the fore as Mrs. Orchard finally confronts her most painful memory. As young Liam spends increasing amounts of time with the Orchards, Mrs. Orchard’s unhealthy level of attachment intensifies, straining her marriage and eventually leading to a permanent rupture with Liam’s family. She fantasizes about Liam officially joining their family and appears unable to resign herself to the fact that Liam is not actually her son. Mrs. Orchard’s inability to see the larger picture in the situation is heightened by the use of first-person narration for her sections of the novel, enabling such memories to be filtered through her own biased subjectivity.
Annette’s fury when she discovers the blurred boundaries between Liam and the Orchards—particularly the discovery of “his” room in their home—brings the situation to its climax, suddenly exposing the strain the Orchards’ over-involvement has placed on Liam’s family as well. While Mrs. Orchard has convinced herself that she was always doing the right thing for Liam, the rupture with Annette makes explicit just how far she has crossed the line in respecting Liam’s family and the little boy’s own needs. Mrs. Orchard’s kidnapping of Liam afterward only solidifies how enmeshed she has become, with her subsequent arrest and sentencing forcing her to confront the consequences of her actions.
There is, however, some resolution at hand, reflecting the theme of Confronting and Overcoming Challenges. Mrs. Orchard regains control of both her life and her mental health after reaching her lowest point following her arrest: She eventually receives expert psychiatric help, which empowers her to work through her grief over her infertility in a healthier way. Her marriage is also saved, with Mr. Orchard offering her unwavering love and support as she rebuilds her post-prison life. Back in the present-day narrative, the fact that Mrs. Orchard is now able to recollect these past events, as difficult and traumatic as they are, with clarity and objectivity are signs of the progress she has made over time. Facing her memory once and for all brings Mrs. Orchard a sense of peace, allowing her to die with the sensation of her husband’s hand upon her—a sign that she has found the resolution she needed.
Clara must also confront a final challenge in the novel. When Rose arrives back home, Clara discovers that her return does not immediately resolve the stress and anxiety her disappearance caused: Since Rose is deeply traumatized, the family will need time and support before things return to a sense of normalcy. Clara, however, relies less on her former patterns and rituals to self-soothe and instead turns to an adult she trusts: Liam. Revealing her true feelings to Liam—even to the point of lashing out at him—enables Clara to confront her emotions and work through them in an open and healthier way, granting her a relief her rituals could never give her. Liam allows her to cope in a safe space (his house) by doing something that calms her down (unpacking the cardboard boxes).
Finally, the novel also offers some closure for The Search for Solace and Understanding in Liam’s character arc. Although Liam is still living in the shadow of Fiona’s taunts about his failures in relationships, his actions reveal how much he has grown in both self-confidence and in his ability to relate meaningfully to others. Having experienced a difficult relationship himself, Liam is respectful of the space Jo silently demands within their relationship, and even more so once he learns about her past. With both Clara and Jo, Liam is mindful of what they need and careful not to hurt them. He tells Jo he is leaving soon and asks her what she would prefer him to do. Similarly, although he is heartbroken after the affair with Jo ends and wants to leave town immediately, he refrains from doing so out of concern for Clara.
When Liam realizes at the novel’s close that he does not want to sell the house after all, he recognizes that the connections he has formed have turned the town of Solace into not just a temporary refuge but a real home. Thus, the book ends with Liam finally meeting the elusive Moses, signaling that he now fully belongs to the house, the town, and the community.
By Mary Lawson
Canadian Literature
View Collection
Childhood & Youth
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Mothers
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
The Booker Prizes Awardees & Honorees
View Collection