logo

47 pages 1 hour read

Nathan Thrall

A Day in the Life of Abed Salama: Anatomy of a Jerusalem Tragedy

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Weight of Israeli Occupation

The school bus accident at the center of the narrative is intended to serve as one example, albeit an especially grisly one, of the harsh conditions facing Palestinians in the occupied territories, particularly the West Bank and East Jerusalem, which remain under Israeli rule to this day (Israel evacuated the Gaza Strip in 2005). Small villages such as Anata struggle to maintain traditional ways of life as Israel expands its apparatus of control. Following the conquest of the territories in 1967, Israel had created a security architecture and networks of dependency so that Palestinians “drove cars on Israel’s multilane highways, bought food at its supermarket chains, and used Hebrew at its office towers, malls, and cinemas” (11). However, following the outbreak of the First Intifada, with its sudden upsurge of widespread resistance, Israel immediately began to clamp down, even as divisions among various Palestinian factions intensified. Young men, in particular, became universally suspect and subject to brutal repression, even for throwing stones or associating with those who did. The majority of an entire generation of males disappeared behind the wire for years at a time, leaving behind precarious families and returning to fraught job prospects as a Byzantine system of color-coded identification cards placed onerous restrictions on employment and movement. Before long, someone like Abed Salama could not even go to the mosque without having to worry about “Israel’s oversight or that of the sulta” (65)—the Palestinian authority set up by the peace process that acted more like a collaborationist regime than a fledgling Palestinian state.

The most severe manifestation of Israeli occupation is the security barrier, which began to come up during the Second Intifada. The wall proved to be one of many ways in which the peace process actually helped tighten Israeli rule rather than grant Palestinian independence. The boundaries that Arafat and others had painstakingly negotiated with the Israeli government served as a pretext for cutting off Arab peoples from Israeli cities—most notably Jerusalem—and subjecting their lands to a ludicrously complicated system of checkpoints, military bases, and segregated highways. The Palestinian areas were persistently under-resourced, and residents were exposed to the state more in the form of the police baton rather than the fire engine or ambulance. The latter is shown in how long it takes for emergency personnel to reach the scene. Nathan Thrall concludes that “children were killed on a road controlled by Israel and patrolled by Israel,” beset with “checkpoints [that] were used to stem Palestinian movement and ease settler traffic,” while the overarching aim of the government was to “reduce [the Palestinian presence] in greater Jerusalem” (217). Thrall’s conclusion is unmistakable—the conditions of the occupation killed those children.

The Endurance of Family and Kinship

As the people of the West Bank and East Jerusalem suffer under an oppressive regime, a rare source of stability is the dense family networks that have sustained them through generations of turmoil. For Abed, being a Salama was of paramount importance, connecting him to a dense linkage of cousins, ancestors, and tribal allies, all tracing back to semi-mythic points of origin. No matter the convulsions of the modern age, “Abed was born into [an] aristocracy” (11), and his family retained enormous legitimacy even as their material fortunes shrank with the expansion of Israeli rule. Abed was not particularly religious, even joining a Marxist-Leninist faction of the DFLP, but even as he forewent one aspect of tradition for modern party politics, family still grounded every aspect of his life. His love affair with Ghazl was stridently individualistic by the standards of the time and place, but he ultimately turned his back on romance out of loyalty to the Salama name, even if he did so under painfully mistaken circumstances, believing the lie of a family member regarding the words of a non-family member concerning the Salama name. After losing the love of his life, Abed had to carefully navigate the norms of polygamy—permissible but generally frowned upon within Palestine—while also trying to seek out the greater opportunities that Israeli citizenship could grant him. When communal norms and political access came into conflict, Abed chose the former with little hesitation, refusing citizenship if it meant being with a woman and family whose “social lives, their mannerisms, the Hebrew in their speech [made them] too much like Israelis” (57) and who even expressed vocal admiration for the occupying forces.

The question of family becomes most salient in the context of the bus crash. People who juggle a host of identities drop everything to try and save children, even if they have nothing to do with those children and might even have cause to regard them as potential enemies. No one waits for news or mourns alone—as parents desperately search for information, they do so in large crowds. This can, in some cases, provide comfort, especially among those grieving their losses together, but it does prevent people like Abed from feeling their pain on their own or feeling the unique connection between parent and child. Family is, of course, a unique gift and source of strength, but the figures involved are also individuals born into linkages beyond their choosing, and these connections can compound pain as well as alleviate it.

Degrees of Complicity in Tragedy

When a terrible event occurs, such as the bus accident claiming the lives of several children, there are multiple layers of guilt. In some respects, the guilt is obvious and undeniable, such as in the case of the semi-truck driver who was severely underqualified and drove recklessly on a poor-quality road in bad weather. If his prison sentence is woefully insufficient, it is hardly unjust. But various other forms of complicity emerge from such a complex tragedy. The driver of the bus was not guilty in any obvious way, but he was reluctant to take the job, as he “could hear a ferocious wind and see dark clouds overheard. A terrible storm was coming, and the local roads weren’t built for such weather,” especially with a “beat-up, twenty-seven-year-old bus” (105). Before the accident, several parents report (at least after the fact) premonitions about the day, especially given the bad weather, or just an eerie feeling about the trip itself. It’s impossible to tell if these feelings were true or emerged only after the events transpired, but in either case, the weight of events could not do anything other than impress feelings of guilt and shame upon parents who could do nothing to change the unbearable facts of their situation.

By the end of the text, Thrall is unsubtle in his assessment of who bears real complicity for the tragedy. Whatever decisions individuals may have made, Thrall finds complicity in the system of Israeli occupation that ensures its own security at the expense of insecurity for Palestinians. Especially once the security barrier was built, it became harder and harder for commerce and government resources to flow into the occupied territories, at least those not deemed worthy of state protection:

In and around Shuafat Camp, parents took their children out of the schools in Jerusalem, afraid to put them in daily contact with soldiers at the checkpoint. There was only one city school on their side of the wall, in a former goat pen. […] [T]here were children at the city schools who still couldn’t read at the age of nine (162).

Bad schools were the prime indication of bad infrastructure, including poorly kept roads and insufficiently trained bus drivers. When all of those conditions combined to produce a terrible accident, it turned out that the authorities either did not care or had set up such complex systems that those who did care were incapable of delivering effective aid. The children were so poorly served that even those who did everything to save them were left feeling themselves part of a system that abandoned them.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text